Re: [H] i5-750 vs i7-920
Steve, The interesting thing with i5-750 is overclockable. My i5-750 is able to run at 3.6GHz daily use, and the i7-920 3.3GHz daily. Of course all need HSF upgrade to Xigmatek Red-Scorpion. I haven't tried Core-two-Duo Quad-core previously, so dunno the increment with the new one. My older one is E6600 (default speed 2.4GHz) At 12:44 AM 2/20/2010, you wrote: Not that I'm ready to pull the trigger on a new upgrade, but I was wondering what kind of performance increase I could expect from an upgrade. Currently my fastest system is an E8500 (the other is an E6850) and I was looking at bang for the buck. Here's the confusion, in comparing the i5-750 and i7-920 (roughly my price range), the benchmarks are all over the place with one not definitively better than the other. The big issue, of course, is that the i7-920 is about $100 more. So is there any reason (for a gamer) to go with the i7-920 over the i5-750? ThanksSteve
Re: [H] i5-750 vs i7-920
The one thing that keeps me torn between the 800 series LGA1156 and 900 series LGA1366 chips is the number of PCI Express lanes. The LGA1156 chip and P55 platform offer very few PCIe lanes at 24 (16 from the CPU itself, plus 8 from the P55), whereas X58 with ICH10 offers 42 lanes (36 from X58, 6 from ICH10). 24 is probably more than enough for most systems, but with one (or more) GPUs, a RAID controller, and a smattering of onboard and add-in components, and you're well beyond the LGA1156/P55's capabilities. Plus, the PCIe lanes from the CPU itself can become a constraint when overclocking, since they're tied to the chip's uncore clock. > -Original Message- > From: hardware-boun...@hardwaregroup.com [mailto:hardware- > boun...@hardwaregroup.com] On Behalf Of Veech > Sent: Friday, February 19, 2010 7:23 PM > To: hardware@hardwaregroup.com > Subject: Re: [H] i5-750 vs i7-920 > > yep.. from what I looked at, the i7-860 is the one to get. Like the > 5850 > graphics card, the i7-860 hits the higher end sweet spot for > price/performance. > > > - Original Message - > From: "Steve Tomporowski" > To: > Sent: Friday, February 19, 2010 16:48 > Subject: Re: [H] i5-750 vs i7-920 > > > > Gee, James, thanks for muddying the water some more! ;-) > > > > Actually I hadn't considered it and, from the benchmarks I just went > to > > look at, I believe you're correct. For the most part it is faster > than > > either the i7-920 and the i5-750, didn't check price but did notice > that > > it also runs cooler than the 920. > > > > Thanks muchSteve > > > > On 2/19/2010 2:47 PM, James Boswell wrote: > >> I'm gonna say... I7-860 > >> roughly the same price for the chip as the 920, fits the same board > as > >> the i5-750 and is quicker than either > >> > >> 2.83Ghz base clock, peak of.. 3.46Ghz turboboost (IIRC) > >> 4 cores, HT enabled > >> > >> On 19 Feb 2010, at 17:44:280, Steve Tomporowski wrote: > >> > >>> Not that I'm ready to pull the trigger on a new upgrade, but I was > >>> wondering what kind of performance increase I could expect from an > >>> upgrade. Currently my fastest system is an E8500 (the other is an > >>> E6850) and I was looking at bang for the buck. Here's the > confusion, > >>> in comparing the i5-750 and i7-920 (roughly my price range), the > >>> benchmarks are all over the place with one not definitively better > >>> than the other. The big issue, of course, is that the i7-920 is > about > >>> $100 more. So is there any reason (for a gamer) to go with the i7- > 920 > >>> over the i5-750? > >>> > >>> ThanksSteve > >> > >> > >
Re: [H] i5-750 vs i7-920
yep.. from what I looked at, the i7-860 is the one to get. Like the 5850 graphics card, the i7-860 hits the higher end sweet spot for price/performance. - Original Message - From: "Steve Tomporowski" To: Sent: Friday, February 19, 2010 16:48 Subject: Re: [H] i5-750 vs i7-920 Gee, James, thanks for muddying the water some more! ;-) Actually I hadn't considered it and, from the benchmarks I just went to look at, I believe you're correct. For the most part it is faster than either the i7-920 and the i5-750, didn't check price but did notice that it also runs cooler than the 920. Thanks muchSteve On 2/19/2010 2:47 PM, James Boswell wrote: I'm gonna say... I7-860 roughly the same price for the chip as the 920, fits the same board as the i5-750 and is quicker than either 2.83Ghz base clock, peak of.. 3.46Ghz turboboost (IIRC) 4 cores, HT enabled On 19 Feb 2010, at 17:44:280, Steve Tomporowski wrote: Not that I'm ready to pull the trigger on a new upgrade, but I was wondering what kind of performance increase I could expect from an upgrade. Currently my fastest system is an E8500 (the other is an E6850) and I was looking at bang for the buck. Here's the confusion, in comparing the i5-750 and i7-920 (roughly my price range), the benchmarks are all over the place with one not definitively better than the other. The big issue, of course, is that the i7-920 is about $100 more. So is there any reason (for a gamer) to go with the i7-920 over the i5-750? ThanksSteve
Re: [H] i5-750 vs i7-920
Gee, James, thanks for muddying the water some more! ;-) Actually I hadn't considered it and, from the benchmarks I just went to look at, I believe you're correct. For the most part it is faster than either the i7-920 and the i5-750, didn't check price but did notice that it also runs cooler than the 920. Thanks muchSteve On 2/19/2010 2:47 PM, James Boswell wrote: I'm gonna say... I7-860 roughly the same price for the chip as the 920, fits the same board as the i5-750 and is quicker than either 2.83Ghz base clock, peak of.. 3.46Ghz turboboost (IIRC) 4 cores, HT enabled On 19 Feb 2010, at 17:44:280, Steve Tomporowski wrote: Not that I'm ready to pull the trigger on a new upgrade, but I was wondering what kind of performance increase I could expect from an upgrade. Currently my fastest system is an E8500 (the other is an E6850) and I was looking at bang for the buck. Here's the confusion, in comparing the i5-750 and i7-920 (roughly my price range), the benchmarks are all over the place with one not definitively better than the other. The big issue, of course, is that the i7-920 is about $100 more. So is there any reason (for a gamer) to go with the i7-920 over the i5-750? ThanksSteve
Re: [H] i5-750 vs i7-920
I'm gonna say... I7-860 roughly the same price for the chip as the 920, fits the same board as the i5-750 and is quicker than either 2.83Ghz base clock, peak of.. 3.46Ghz turboboost (IIRC) 4 cores, HT enabled On 19 Feb 2010, at 17:44:280, Steve Tomporowski wrote: Not that I'm ready to pull the trigger on a new upgrade, but I was wondering what kind of performance increase I could expect from an upgrade. Currently my fastest system is an E8500 (the other is an E6850) and I was looking at bang for the buck. Here's the confusion, in comparing the i5-750 and i7-920 (roughly my price range), the benchmarks are all over the place with one not definitively better than the other. The big issue, of course, is that the i7-920 is about $100 more. So is there any reason (for a gamer) to go with the i7-920 over the i5-750? ThanksSteve
Re: [H] i5-750 vs i7-920
How long until the next upgrade? If you plan to keep that chip for 4 years and the 920 is faster on most things you will be doing (based on extrapolated data from those charts), then you're only paying $25 / year for that. Of course, you need to be able to afford it now. I think bang-for-your-buck calculations are really hard to do nowadays. so many options and scattered benchmark performance. The chip makers have done an excellent job in confusing the market for buyers, IMO. If you think you'll upgrade again soon, I'd get the cheaper chip. On 2/19/2010 12:44 PM, Steve Tomporowski wrote: Not that I'm ready to pull the trigger on a new upgrade, but I was wondering what kind of performance increase I could expect from an upgrade. Currently my fastest system is an E8500 (the other is an E6850) and I was looking at bang for the buck. Here's the confusion, in comparing the i5-750 and i7-920 (roughly my price range), the benchmarks are all over the place with one not definitively better than the other. The big issue, of course, is that the i7-920 is about $100 more. So is there any reason (for a gamer) to go with the i7-920 over the i5-750? ThanksSteve No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 9.0.733 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2697 - Release Date: 02/19/10 02:34:00
[H] i5-750 vs i7-920
Not that I'm ready to pull the trigger on a new upgrade, but I was wondering what kind of performance increase I could expect from an upgrade. Currently my fastest system is an E8500 (the other is an E6850) and I was looking at bang for the buck. Here's the confusion, in comparing the i5-750 and i7-920 (roughly my price range), the benchmarks are all over the place with one not definitively better than the other. The big issue, of course, is that the i7-920 is about $100 more. So is there any reason (for a gamer) to go with the i7-920 over the i5-750? ThanksSteve
