Re: [I2nsf] Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

[Rakesh Kumar]

HI Linda,

I just uploaded the version -05 with the updates listed below in this thread.

Thanks
Rakesh
From: Linda Dunbar 
Date: Monday, December 5, 2016 at 1:44 PM
To: Rakesh Kumar , Susan Hares , "'Diego 
R. Lopez'" 
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' , "christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
, "i2nsf@ietf.org" 
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Rakesh,

I would think uploading soon (ASAP), so we can get over the WGLC by end of the 
year.

Linda

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: 2016年12月5日 15:41
To: Linda Dunbar ; Susan Hares ; 
'Diego R. Lopez' 
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' ; christian.jacque...@orange.com; 
i2nsf@ietf.org
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Linda,

Let me know when do you want me to upload this version.

Thanks
Rakesh
From: Linda Dunbar >
Date: Monday, December 5, 2016 at 11:37 AM
To: Rakesh Kumar >, Susan Hares 
>, "'Diego R. Lopez'" 
>
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >, 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
>, 
"i2nsf@ietf.org" >
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Is there anyone objecting adding Paul as co-author?
If not, please go ahead adding his name and upload the draft. So that we can 
start the WGLC.

Linda

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: 2016年12月5日 13:19
To: Linda Dunbar >; 
Susan Hares >; 'Diego R. Lopez' 
>
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; 
i2nsf@ietf.org; Rakesh Kumar 
>
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

HI Linda,

I think, we should add Paul’s name.
We can put his name as contributing author or as a co-author as others feel 
appropriate.

Thanks
Rakesh

From: Linda Dunbar >
Date: Monday, December 5, 2016 at 10:03 AM
To: Rakesh Kumar >, Susan Hares 
>, "'Diego R. Lopez'" 
>
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >, 
"myo.za...@gs.com" 
>, 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
>, 
"i2nsf@ietf.org" >
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Sue, Rakesh, Diego, et al,

Do you think the version updated by Rakesh is good enough for WGLC?
We are hoping to get the process started & finished by 2017.

Thanks, Linda

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: 2016年11月30日 13:59
To: Susan Hares >; 'Diego R. Lopez' 
>
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >; 
myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; Linda 
Dunbar >; Rakesh Kumar 
>
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Susan and all,

I took as much as possible from Pau’l contributions and added one section on 
“Regulatory and compliance” which I wanted to add.

Please find the attached “xml” document. I added following to the document sent 
by Diego. I don’t know how to diff between Diego’s version and mine.


1.  Section 3.1.1, Added a new item “Centralized or Distributed security 
functions:”

2.  Section 3.4, Added a new section “Software-Defined Networks”

3.  Section 4.4, Added section “Preventing Distributed DoS, Malware and 
Botnet attacks”

4.  Section 4.5, Added section “Regulatory and compliance security policies”

5.  In my opinion, we should add Paul’s name back. I have not done in the 
attached document but I feel we should.


Thanks
Rakesh
From: Susan Hares >
Date: Tuesday, November 29, 2016 at 5:49 PM
To: Rakesh Kumar 

Re: [I2nsf] Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

[Linda Dunbar]

Is there anyone objecting adding Paul as co-author?
If not, please go ahead adding his name and upload the draft. So that we can 
start the WGLC.

Linda

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: 2016年12月5日 13:19
To: Linda Dunbar ; Susan Hares ; 
'Diego R. Lopez' 
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' ; christian.jacque...@orange.com; 
i2nsf@ietf.org; Rakesh Kumar 
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

HI Linda,

I think, we should add Paul’s name.
We can put his name as contributing author or as a co-author as others feel 
appropriate.

Thanks
Rakesh

From: Linda Dunbar >
Date: Monday, December 5, 2016 at 10:03 AM
To: Rakesh Kumar >, Susan Hares 
>, "'Diego R. Lopez'" 
>
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >, 
"myo.za...@gs.com" 
>, 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
>, 
"i2nsf@ietf.org" >
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Sue, Rakesh, Diego, et al,

Do you think the version updated by Rakesh is good enough for WGLC?
We are hoping to get the process started & finished by 2017.

Thanks, Linda

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: 2016年11月30日 13:59
To: Susan Hares >; 'Diego R. Lopez' 
>
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >; 
myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; Linda 
Dunbar >; Rakesh Kumar 
>
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Susan and all,

I took as much as possible from Pau’l contributions and added one section on 
“Regulatory and compliance” which I wanted to add.

Please find the attached “xml” document. I added following to the document sent 
by Diego. I don’t know how to diff between Diego’s version and mine.


1. Section 3.1.1, Added a new item “Centralized or Distributed security 
functions:”

2. Section 3.4, Added a new section “Software-Defined Networks”

3. Section 4.4, Added section “Preventing Distributed DoS, Malware and 
Botnet attacks”

4. Section 4.5, Added section “Regulatory and compliance security policies”

5. In my opinion, we should add Paul’s name back. I have not done in the 
attached document but I feel we should.


Thanks
Rakesh
From: Susan Hares >
Date: Tuesday, November 29, 2016 at 5:49 PM
To: Rakesh Kumar >, "'Diego R. 
Lopez'" >
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >, 
"myo.za...@gs.com" 
>, 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
>, 'Linda 
Dunbar' >
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Rakesh:

Thank you for letting me know.

Sue

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: Tuesday, November 29, 2016 11:42 AM
To: Susan Hares; 'Diego R. Lopez'
Cc: 'Myo Zarny'; myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; 'Linda 
Dunbar'
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Susan,

I will send you the changes in next couple of days.

Thanks
Rakesh

From: Susan Hares >
Date: Monday, November 28, 2016 at 1:28 AM
To: "'Diego R. Lopez'" 
>, Rakesh 
Kumar >
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >, 
"myo.za...@gs.com" 
>, 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
>, 'Linda 
Dunbar' >
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Diego and Rakesh:

Let me know who has the token.  If Rakesh wants to send changes, I will update 
to this work.

Wi will unavailable via email during normal hours (8am-5pm ET) due to jury duty 
in the US.   I will 

Re: [I2nsf] Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

[Rakesh Kumar]

HI Linda,

I think, we should add Paul’s name.
We can put his name as contributing author or as a co-author as others feel 
appropriate.

Thanks
Rakesh

From: Linda Dunbar 
Date: Monday, December 5, 2016 at 10:03 AM
To: Rakesh Kumar , Susan Hares , "'Diego 
R. Lopez'" 
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' , "myo.za...@gs.com" , 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" , 
"i2nsf@ietf.org" 
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Sue, Rakesh, Diego, et al,

Do you think the version updated by Rakesh is good enough for WGLC?
We are hoping to get the process started & finished by 2017.

Thanks, Linda

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: 2016年11月30日 13:59
To: Susan Hares ; 'Diego R. Lopez' 

Cc: 'Myo Zarny' ; myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; Linda Dunbar ; Rakesh 
Kumar 
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Susan and all,

I took as much as possible from Pau’l contributions and added one section on 
“Regulatory and compliance” which I wanted to add.

Please find the attached “xml” document. I added following to the document sent 
by Diego. I don’t know how to diff between Diego’s version and mine.


1.  Section 3.1.1, Added a new item “Centralized or Distributed security 
functions:”

2.  Section 3.4, Added a new section “Software-Defined Networks”

3.  Section 4.4, Added section “Preventing Distributed DoS, Malware and 
Botnet attacks”

4.  Section 4.5, Added section “Regulatory and compliance security policies”

5.  In my opinion, we should add Paul’s name back. I have not done in the 
attached document but I feel we should.


Thanks
Rakesh
From: Susan Hares >
Date: Tuesday, November 29, 2016 at 5:49 PM
To: Rakesh Kumar >, "'Diego R. 
Lopez'" >
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >, 
"myo.za...@gs.com" 
>, 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
>, 'Linda 
Dunbar' >
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Rakesh:

Thank you for letting me know.

Sue

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: Tuesday, November 29, 2016 11:42 AM
To: Susan Hares; 'Diego R. Lopez'
Cc: 'Myo Zarny'; myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; 'Linda 
Dunbar'
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Susan,

I will send you the changes in next couple of days.

Thanks
Rakesh

From: Susan Hares >
Date: Monday, November 28, 2016 at 1:28 AM
To: "'Diego R. Lopez'" 
>, Rakesh 
Kumar >
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >, 
"myo.za...@gs.com" 
>, 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
>, 'Linda 
Dunbar' >
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Diego and Rakesh:

Let me know who has the token.  If Rakesh wants to send changes, I will update 
to this work.

Wi will unavailable via email during normal hours (8am-5pm ET) due to jury duty 
in the US.   I will be working 5pm (2pm PT) to 12pm ET, and 6-7 ET (am).

Sue

From: Diego R. Lopez [mailto:diego.r.lo...@telefonica.com]
Sent: Sunday, November 27, 2016 5:22 PM
To: Rakesh Kumar
Cc: Susan Hares; Myo Zarny; myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; Linda 
Dunbar
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Rakesh,

Good! I am attaching the latest version Sue shared with us.

Be goode,


On 27 Nov 2016, at 21:41 , Rakesh Kumar 
> wrote:

I will do it.

Please send me the latest copy otherwise I will take the latest version from 
IETF website.

Regards
Rakesh

Sent from my iPhone

On Nov 27, 2016, at 12:12 PM, Diego R. Lopez 
> wrote:
Hi Sue,

Trying to sort out a token deadlock we seemed to have…

Be goode,

On 26 Nov 2016, at 22:45 , Susan Hares 
> wrote:

Rakesh, Diego, Myo, and Christian:

Any updates on this 

Re: [I2nsf] Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

[Linda Dunbar]

Sue, Rakesh, Diego, et al,

Do you think the version updated by Rakesh is good enough for WGLC?
We are hoping to get the process started & finished by 2017.

Thanks, Linda

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: 2016年11月30日 13:59
To: Susan Hares ; 'Diego R. Lopez' 

Cc: 'Myo Zarny' ; myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; Linda Dunbar ; Rakesh 
Kumar 
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Susan and all,

I took as much as possible from Pau’l contributions and added one section on 
“Regulatory and compliance” which I wanted to add.

Please find the attached “xml” document. I added following to the document sent 
by Diego. I don’t know how to diff between Diego’s version and mine.


1.  Section 3.1.1, Added a new item “Centralized or Distributed security 
functions:”

2.  Section 3.4, Added a new section “Software-Defined Networks”

3.  Section 4.4, Added section “Preventing Distributed DoS, Malware and 
Botnet attacks”

4.  Section 4.5, Added section “Regulatory and compliance security policies”

5.  In my opinion, we should add Paul’s name back. I have not done in the 
attached document but I feel we should.


Thanks
Rakesh
From: Susan Hares >
Date: Tuesday, November 29, 2016 at 5:49 PM
To: Rakesh Kumar >, "'Diego R. 
Lopez'" >
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >, 
"myo.za...@gs.com" 
>, 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
>, 'Linda 
Dunbar' >
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Rakesh:

Thank you for letting me know.

Sue

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: Tuesday, November 29, 2016 11:42 AM
To: Susan Hares; 'Diego R. Lopez'
Cc: 'Myo Zarny'; myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; 'Linda 
Dunbar'
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Susan,

I will send you the changes in next couple of days.

Thanks
Rakesh

From: Susan Hares >
Date: Monday, November 28, 2016 at 1:28 AM
To: "'Diego R. Lopez'" 
>, Rakesh 
Kumar >
Cc: 'Myo Zarny' >, 
"myo.za...@gs.com" 
>, 
"christian.jacque...@orange.com" 
>, 'Linda 
Dunbar' >
Subject: RE: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Diego and Rakesh:

Let me know who has the token.  If Rakesh wants to send changes, I will update 
to this work.

Wi will unavailable via email during normal hours (8am-5pm ET) due to jury duty 
in the US.   I will be working 5pm (2pm PT) to 12pm ET, and 6-7 ET (am).

Sue

From: Diego R. Lopez [mailto:diego.r.lo...@telefonica.com]
Sent: Sunday, November 27, 2016 5:22 PM
To: Rakesh Kumar
Cc: Susan Hares; Myo Zarny; myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; Linda 
Dunbar
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Rakesh,

Good! I am attaching the latest version Sue shared with us.

Be goode,


On 27 Nov 2016, at 21:41 , Rakesh Kumar 
> wrote:

I will do it.

Please send me the latest copy otherwise I will take the latest version from 
IETF website.

Regards
Rakesh

Sent from my iPhone

On Nov 27, 2016, at 12:12 PM, Diego R. Lopez 
> wrote:
Hi Sue,

Trying to sort out a token deadlock we seemed to have…

Be goode,

On 26 Nov 2016, at 22:45 , Susan Hares 
> wrote:

Rakesh, Diego, Myo, and Christian:

Any updates on this document?  If you want me to edit in the changes, please 
let me know.

Sue

From: Rakesh Kumar [mailto:rkku...@juniper.net]
Sent: Wednesday, November 23, 2016 1:45 PM
To: Diego R. Lopez
Cc: Susan Hares; Myo Zarny; myo.za...@gs.com; 
christian.jacque...@orange.com; Linda 
Dunbar
Subject: Re: Suggested updaste from Paul Jeong

Hi Diego,

I wanted to take a stab at Paul's comment but it looks like you are planning 
for the same. I will let you handle in that case.

I wanted to add use-case listing how I2NSF would be useful for