Re: Dynamics placement in partCombine
Quick answer, and I’m not sure it will help much:
\dynamicUp affects the context (Voice) in which it’s placed.
\partCombine combines its arguments into new Voices and \dynamicUp
ended up in a different voice than the p
Thank you for your answer.
When you remove \dynamicUp ALL dynamics appear below. What irritates me
is that when you have identical dynamic markings in both voices
\dynamicUp and things like \override DynamicTextSpanner.style = #'none
work normally. However when voices have differing dynamics it stops to
work at some point.
Might be due to the temporary contexts created by \partCombine
internally. The current behaviour is very unexpected to me though.
The following seems to work:
- snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip -
\version "2.25.9"
musa = { \dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
\dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
musb = { \dynamicUp s1
\dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
\score {
\partCombine \musa \musb
}
\score {
\partCombine \musb \musa
}
\score {
\partCombine \musa \musa
}
\score {
\partCombine \musb \musb
}
- snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip -
Kind regards,
Michael--
Michael Gerdau email: m...@qata.de
GPG-keys available on request or at public keyserver\version "2.25.9"
musa = { \dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
\dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
musb = { \dynamicUp s1
\dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
\score {
\partCombine \musa \musb
}
\score {
\partCombine \musb \musa
}
\score {
\partCombine \musa \musa
}
\score {
\partCombine \musb \musb
}
partCombine-Test.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
Re: Dynamics placement in partCombine
Quick answer, and I’m not sure it will help much: \dynamicUp affects the context (Voice) in which it’s placed. \partCombine combines its arguments into new Voices and \dynamicUp ended up in a different voice than the p Thank you for your answer. When you remove \dynamicUp ALL dynamics appear below. What irritates me is that when you have identical dynamic markings in both voices \dynamicUp and things like \override DynamicTextSpanner.style = #'none work normally. However when voices have differing dynamics it stops to work at some point. Might be due to the temporary contexts created by \partCombine internally. The current behaviour is very unexpected to me though. Kind regards, Michael-- Michael Gerdau email: m...@qata.de GPG-keys available on request or at public keyserver
Re: Dynamics placement in partCombine
Quick answer, and I’m not sure it will help much: \dynamicUp affects the context (Voice) in which it’s placed. \partCombine combines its arguments into new Voices and \dynamicUp ended up in a different voice than the p Thank you for your answer. When you remove \dynamicUp ALL dynamics appear below. What irritates me is that when you have identical dynamic markings in both voices \dynamicUp and things like \override DynamicTextSpanner.style = #'none work normally. However when voices have differing dynamics it stops to work at some point. Might be due to the temporary contexts created by \partCombine internally. The current behaviour is very unexpected to me though. Kind regards, Michael -- Michael Gerdau email: m...@qata.de GPG-keys available on request or at public keyserver
Re: Dynamics placement in partCombine
I presume that partCombine overrides the dynamic placement so that
dynamics for the two parts are placed above and below, which seems a
reasonable approach when the parts are more distinct than in the given
example. Using ^ to override it in this case seems a tolerable alternative.
Thank you for your answer.
I'm not sure that's the correct explanation though.
See this:
- snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip -
\version "2.25.9"
musa = { \dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
musb = { \dynamicUp s1
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
\score {
\partCombine \musa \musb
}
\score {
\partCombine \musb \musa
}
\score {
\partCombine \musa \musa
}
\score {
\partCombine \musb \musb
}
- snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip -
When you repeat the last bar identically in both \musa and \musb the
dynamics stay below in the first two scores and stay above in the second
two scores.
To me this looks like a bug.
Kind regards,
Michael
--
Michael Gerdau email: m...@qata.de
GPG-keys available on request or at public keyserver\version "2.25.9"
musa = { \dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
musb = { \dynamicUp s1
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' }
c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
\score {
\partCombine \musa \musb
}
\score {
\partCombine \musb \musa
}
\score {
\partCombine \musa \musa
}
\score {
\partCombine \musb \musb
}
partCombine-Test.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
Re: Dynamics placement in partCombine
I presume that partCombine overrides the dynamic placement so that dynamics for
the two parts are placed above and below, which seems a reasonable approach
when the parts are more distinct than in the given example. Using ^ to
override it in this case seems a tolerable alternative.
Paul
From: Michael Gerdau
To: lilypond-user
Sent: 13/10/2023 11:30
Subject: Dynamics placement in partCombine
Hi list,
the following code places the 2nd \p under the music but I'd like it
above. I know I could explicitly add a placement (like ^\p) but wonder
why \dynamicUp doesn't do its job.
- snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip -
\version "2.25.9"
musa = { \dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } c'4\p \repeat unfold 3
{ c' } }
musb = { \dynamicUp s1 c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
\score {
\partCombine \musa \musb
}
- snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip -
Kind regards,
Michael
--
Michael Gerdau email: m...@qata.de
GPG-keys available on request or at public keyserver
Re: Dynamics placement in partCombine
Quick answer, and I’m not sure it will help much:
\dynamicUp affects the context (Voice) in which it’s placed. \partCombine
combines its arguments into new Voices and \dynamicUp ended up in a different
voice than the p
> 13 okt. 2023 kl. 12:32 skrev Michael Gerdau :
>
> Hi list,
>
> the following code places the 2nd \p under the music but I'd like it above. I
> know I could explicitly add a placement (like ^\p) but wonder why \dynamicUp
> doesn't do its job.
>
> - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip -
> \version "2.25.9"
>
> musa = { \dynamicUp c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c'
> } }
> musb = { \dynamicUp s1 c'4\p \repeat unfold 3 { c' } }
> \score {
> \partCombine \musa \musb
> }
> - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip - snip -
>
> Kind regards,
> Michael
> --
> Michael Gerdau email: m...@qata.de
> GPG-keys available on request or at public keyserver
>
>
