Re: libfaac in ffmpeg on OpenBSD
On 2013-06-12, Peter J. Philipp p...@centroid.eu wrote: I made a patch to /usr/ports/graphics/ffmpeg but it needs fixing up to integrate it into the ports. However my patch works, which is awesome. The patch is uuencoded here: http://emea.centroid.eu/blog/index.php?article=1370984565 Perhaps we can see this in OpenBSD 5.4? Then I don't have to recompile ffmpeg. -peter Distributing packages built like this is a violation of GPL, FFmpeg devs are *very* vocal about this.
Re: libfaac in ffmpeg on OpenBSD
Peter J. Philipp p...@centroid.eu writes: I made a patch to /usr/ports/graphics/ffmpeg but it needs fixing up to integrate it into the ports. However my patch works, which is awesome. The patch is uuencoded here: http://emea.centroid.eu/blog/index.php?article=1370984565 Perhaps we can see this in OpenBSD 5.4? Then I don't have to recompile ffmpeg. OK, the legal issue has already been dealt with by Stuart. I hesitated replying to you privately, but I think proposals like this one should be avoided. On the technical side, your patch should have added audio/faac to LIB_DEPENDS. But about the method... - your mail should probably have been sent to ports@, not misc@ - your mail could easily include an inlined diff (an attachment is also possible on ports@). Instead here one should go to a website, copy/paste some text, uudecode it... wait - your diff is not based on -current, patching fails - any explanation other than I need this or go to ShitOverflow for the details? As a side not I don't even know what the heck is an Apple TV and I don't really care about that... -- Jérémie Courrèges-Anglas PGP Key fingerprint: 61DB D9A0 00A4 67CF 2A90 8961 6191 8FBF 06A1 1494
Re: libfaac in ffmpeg on OpenBSD
On 06/12/13 12:38, Jérémie Courrèges-Anglas wrote: Peter J. Philipp p...@centroid.eu writes: I made a patch to /usr/ports/graphics/ffmpeg but it needs fixing up to integrate it into the ports. However my patch works, which is awesome. The patch is uuencoded here: http://emea.centroid.eu/blog/index.php?article=1370984565 Perhaps we can see this in OpenBSD 5.4? Then I don't have to recompile ffmpeg. OK, the legal issue has already been dealt with by Stuart. I hesitated replying to you privately, but I think proposals like this one should be avoided. On the technical side, your patch should have added audio/faac to LIB_DEPENDS. But about the method... - your mail should probably have been sent to ports@, not misc@ - your mail could easily include an inlined diff (an attachment is also possible on ports@). Instead here one should go to a website, copy/paste some text, uudecode it... wait - your diff is not based on -current, patching fails - any explanation other than I need this or go to ShitOverflow for the details? As a side not I don't even know what the heck is an Apple TV and I don't really care about that... Since there was a legal thing the issue is closed. However you're just nagging. I enhanced the OpenBSD port and thought I'd share, your response will make me keep these things secret in the future. -peter
Re: libfaac in ffmpeg on OpenBSD
On Wed, Jun 12, 2013 at 12:59:53PM +0200, Peter J. Philipp wrote: On 06/12/13 12:38, Jérémie Courrèges-Anglas wrote: Peter J. Philipp p...@centroid.eu writes: I made a patch to /usr/ports/graphics/ffmpeg but it needs fixing up to integrate it into the ports. However my patch works, which is awesome. The patch is uuencoded here: http://emea.centroid.eu/blog/index.php?article=1370984565 Perhaps we can see this in OpenBSD 5.4? Then I don't have to recompile ffmpeg. OK, the legal issue has already been dealt with by Stuart. I hesitated replying to you privately, but I think proposals like this one should be avoided. On the technical side, your patch should have added audio/faac to LIB_DEPENDS. But about the method... - your mail should probably have been sent to ports@, not misc@ - your mail could easily include an inlined diff (an attachment is also possible on ports@). Instead here one should go to a website, copy/paste some text, uudecode it... wait - your diff is not based on -current, patching fails - any explanation other than I need this or go to ShitOverflow for the details? As a side not I don't even know what the heck is an Apple TV and I don't really care about that... Since there was a legal thing the issue is closed. However you're just nagging. I enhanced the OpenBSD port and thought I'd share, your response will make me keep these things secret in the future. Please do. -- Antoine
Re: libfaac in ffmpeg on OpenBSD
Peter J. Philipp p...@centroid.eu writes: On 06/12/13 12:38, Jérémie Courrèges-Anglas wrote: Peter J. Philipp p...@centroid.eu writes: I made a patch to /usr/ports/graphics/ffmpeg but it needs fixing up to integrate it into the ports. However my patch works, which is awesome. The patch is uuencoded here: http://emea.centroid.eu/blog/index.php?article=1370984565 Perhaps we can see this in OpenBSD 5.4? Then I don't have to recompile ffmpeg. OK, the legal issue has already been dealt with by Stuart. I hesitated replying to you privately, but I think proposals like this one should be avoided. On the technical side, your patch should have added audio/faac to LIB_DEPENDS. But about the method... - your mail should probably have been sent to ports@, not misc@ - your mail could easily include an inlined diff (an attachment is also possible on ports@). Instead here one should go to a website, copy/paste some text, uudecode it... wait - your diff is not based on -current, patching fails - any explanation other than I need this or go to ShitOverflow for the details? As a side not I don't even know what the heck is an Apple TV and I don't really care about that... Since there was a legal thing the issue is closed. However you're just nagging. Fine, I thought I was trying to be helpful, but after reading again my reply I admit that I shouldn't have wrote the last sentence. Sorry if you felt offended. I enhanced the OpenBSD port You did not. and thought I'd share, your response will make me keep these things secret in the future. I'd like to tell you that's a shame, but then I wouldn't be honest. Have a nice day, -- Jérémie Courrèges-Anglas PGP Key fingerprint: 61DB D9A0 00A4 67CF 2A90 8961 6191 8FBF 06A1 1494
Re: libfaac in ffmpeg on OpenBSD
On Wed, Jun 12, 2013 at 12:59:53PM +0200, Peter J. Philipp wrote: Since there was a legal thing the issue is closed. However you're just nagging. I enhanced the OpenBSD port and thought I'd share, your response will make me keep these things secret in the future. Come on, 5 mn spent with cvs history will show you that faac support used to exist but was dropped from ffmpeg for pretty solid licensing reasons. If you have enough pride, you should now try to prove us wrong by writing something genuinely useful for the ports tree, and share it with us so that we can see you can do interesting work.
