Re: [onap-discuss] 答复: 答复： 答复：RE: RE: RE: RE: [sdc][vfc] SDC questions from VF-C

2017-08-10 Thread yangyanyj 
BEGIN:VCALENDAR
METHOD:REQUEST
PRODID:-//Tencent Corporation//Foxmail
VERSION:2.0
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
BEGIN:VEVENT
UID:5D9103BE-419A-4FD0-93D4-95ABF53AB3A1
CLASS:PUBLIC
DTEND:20170811T14Z
STATUS:TENTATIVE
TRANSP:OPAQUE
CREATED:20170811T053224Z
DTSTAMP:20170811T053224Z
DTSTART:20170811T13Z
SUMMARY:Re: 答复: [onap-discuss] 答复： 答复：RE: RE: RE: RE: [sdc][vfc] SDC quest
 ions from VF-C
ATTENDEE;CN=onap-discuss@lists.onap.org;ROLE=OPT-PARTICIPANT;RSVP=TRUE:MAI
 LTO:onap-discuss@lists.onap.org
ATTENDEE;CN=ml6...@att.com;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;RSVP=TRUE:MAILTO:ml636r@at
 t.com
ATTENDEE;CN=er4...@intl.att.com;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;RSVP=TRUE:MAILTO:er43
 4...@intl.att.com
ATTENDEE;CN=ds2...@att.com;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;RSVP=TRUE:MAILTO:ds200p@at
 t.com
ATTENDEE;CN=zhang.maope...@zte.com.cn;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;RSVP=TRUE:MAILT
 O:zhang.maope...@zte.com.cn
LOCATION:
PRIORITY:5
SEQUENCE:0
ORGANIZER;CN=yangyanyj:MAILTO:yangya...@chinamobile.com
RESOURCES:
DESCRIPTION:Hi david, micheal and maopeng,\n\n\n\n\n\nBest Regards\nYan\n 
 \n发件人： zhang.maope...@zte.com.cn\n发送时间： 2017-08-11 12:10\n收件人： ds200p@att.
 com; er4...@intl.att.com; ml6...@att.com; yangya...@chinamobile.com\n抄送： o
 nap-disc...@lists.onap.org\n主题： 答复: [onap-discuss] 答复： 答复：RE: RE: RE: RE: 
 [sdc][vfc] SDC questions from VF-C\nHi david, micheal\n\n   Email Summary 
 is as following, please check it.   If I am wrong, please correct me. Plea
 se PTL(yangyan,micheal) arrange a virtual meeting to discuss these issues,
   thanks.\n\n   1.  Now the things confirmed:\n   1.1. In ONAP R1, the
  SDC will add the openo tosca type. The types’ namespace would follow Open
 ECOMP convention\n   Note: the final node type definition stil
 l need to be cleared.\n   1.2. controllerinfo in the service level wil
 l be supported via new parameter servicetype and serviceRole.\n\n2.  T
 here are still following questoins needed to be clear from SDC side.\n
  2.1.  VF level need the vnfminfo, for VFC suggests add a new paramete
 r for VF.  what's the advices from SDC team?\n  vnfminfo i
 s used by vf-c to identify which vendor vnfm driver to choose. The vnfminf
 o is a string, such as gvnfm,juju,zte,HUAWEI,etc. hope the description can
  clear the vnfminfo parameter. \n 2.2. Whether to support ELAN VL,
  which can be shared among VNFs.\n  [Maopeng ] now the SDC
  supports VL, but it is automatically produced.  Now I can design the Elin
 e type VL, but for the VoLTE case , we needmultiple VNFs share one VL.
 \n  what's the automatic rule of VL cr
 eating? How to design it? could you show with us. thanks.   \n
   [Michael: David can you respond?]\n 2.3. About S
 ervice /VNF package\n 2.3.1  In the wiki page, SDC_TOSCA_A
 ID_1710 document has no nodes definitions, please provide it in the wiki.\
 n   [David] @Michael – Could you please make sure 
 we the node type definition file(s) for VF and Service exist in the wiki?\
 n 2.3.2  We want to know the VNF CSAR package format expor
 ted from SDC, can you give us an example, we want to confirm whether the p
 ackage has some format restrictions.\n   [Maopeng ] In the
  R1,  VNFSDK bundles a VNF package, and import to the SDC. VFC get the VNF
  package from theSDC catalog.\n   
 Is theVNF package defined in the VNFSDK or SDC for R1? What's 
 the VNF package format for VFC in R1? 
 \n[Michael] since we are now still dev
 eloping the Tosca onboarding I cannot provide you the exact output. I can 
   share an example of the CSAR we currently create  for the vFW/vDNS use c
 ase.   \n[Maopeng] The service package and
  vnf package CSAR in the SDC catalog, please share them. Thanks\n 
This is really a block issuse for VFC if the servic
 e and VF package format can not be provided specifically in time.\n\n 
2.4. About the parser, VFC written in python can not use the java lib  
 directly.\n  Oneway:  If in the SDC can provide th
 e REST API & JSON output, it will be welcome for R1\n 
  The other way: the CSAR output of SDC follow the  OASIS tosca simple 
 profile, it can be parsed by other parsers.\n 
 If the output is not standard, we need to know which part 
 is not standard, and can it be fixed in the R1?\n 
  \nBest Regards\nMaopeng\n原始邮件\n发件人：张茂鹏10030173\n收件人： ;\n抄送人： ; ;\n日 期
  ：2017年08月10日 21:43\n主 题

[onap-discuss] 答复: 答复： 答复：RE: RE: RE: RE: [sdc][vfc] SDC questions from VF-C

2017-08-10 Thread zhang.maopeng1 
Hi david, micheal




   Email Summary is as following, please check it.   If I am wrong, please 
correct me. Please PTL(yangyan,micheal) arrange a virtual meeting to discuss 
these issues,  thanks.




   1.  Now the things confirmed:

   1.1. In ONAP R1, the SDC will add the openo tosca type. The types’ 
namespace would follow OpenECOMP convention

   Note: the final node type definition still need to be cleared.

   1.2. controllerinfo in the service level will be supported via new 
parameter servicetype and serviceRole.




2.  There are still following questoins needed to be clear from SDC side.

 2.1.  VF level need the vnfminfo, for VFC suggests add a new parameter 
for VF.  what's the advices from SDC team?

  vnfminfo is used by vf-c to identify which vendor vnfm driver 
to choose. The vnfminfo is a string, such as gvnfm,juju,zte,HUAWEI,etc. hope 
the description can clear the vnfminfo parameter. 

 2.2. Whether to support ELAN VL, which can be shared among VNFs.


  [Maopeng ] now the SDC supports VL, but it is automatically 
produced.  Now I can design the Eline type VL, but for the VoLTE case , we need 
   multiple VNFs share one VL.


  what's the automatic rule of VL creating? How to 
design it? could you show with us. thanks.   


  [Michael: David can you respond?]


 2.3. About Service /VNF package


 2.3.1  In the wiki page, SDC_TOSCA_AID_1710 document has no 
nodes definitions, please provide it in the wiki.


   [David] @Michael – Could you please make sure we the 
node type definition file(s) for VF and Service exist in the wiki?


 2.3.2  We want to know the VNF CSAR package format exported 
from SDC, can you give us an example, we want to confirm whether the package 
has some format restrictions.


   [Maopeng ] In the R1,  VNFSDK bundles a VNF package, and 
import to the SDC. VFC get the VNF package from theSDC catalog. 
   


   Is theVNF package defined in the VNFSDK or SDC for R1? 
What's the VNF package format for VFC in R1?
 


[Michael] since we are now still developing the 
Tosca onboarding I cannot provide you the exact output. I can   share an 
example of the CSAR we currently create  for the vFW/vDNS use case.   


[Maopeng] The service package and vnf package 
CSAR in the SDC catalog, please share them. Thanks


This is really a block issuse for VFC if the 
service and VF package format can not be provided specifically in time.






2.4. About the parser, VFC written in python can not use the java lib  
directly.


  Oneway:  If in the SDC can provide the REST API & 
JSON output, it will be welcome for R1


  The other way: the CSAR output of SDC follow the  
OASIS tosca simple profile, it can be parsed by other parsers.
 If the output is not standard, we 
need to know which part is not standard, and can it be fixed in the R1?


  


Best Regards

Maopeng



原始邮件



发件人：张茂鹏10030173
收件人： 
抄送人：  
日 期 ：2017年08月10日 21:43
主 题 ：[onap-discuss] 答复： 答复：RE: RE: RE: RE: [sdc][vfc] SDC questions from VF-C





hi, 
 
The vnfminfo is a string, such as gvnfm,juju,zte,HUAWEI,etc. 
hope the description can clear the vnfminfo parameter. 
 
thanks. 
 
 






发件人:   张茂鹏10030173  
收件人:ds2...@att.com
抄送:er4...@intl.att.com onap-discuss@lists.onap.org
日期:   2017-08-10 21:29:59  
主题:[onap-discuss] 答复：RE: RE: RE: RE: [sdc][vfc] SDC questions from VF-C  


hi, 
 
vnfminfo is used by vf-c to identify which vendor vnfm driver to choose. 
 
thanks 
maopeng 
 
 




发件人:   SHADMI,DAVID  
收件人:张茂鹏10030173 LANDO, MICHAEL ROZIN, EDEN
抄送:yangya...@chinamobile.com denglin...@chinamobile.com 孟照星10024238 
onap-discuss@lists.onap.org
日期:   2017-08-10 20:57:55  
主题:RE: RE: RE: RE: [sdc][vfc] SDC questions from VF-C  




  




Hi,


 


My comments are embedded.


 


@Michal, @Eden – could you please help with the three questions about ELAN VL, 
service and VNF package, and the Parser?


 


Thanks,


David


 


 


From: zhang.maope...@zte.com.cn [mailto:zhang.maope...@zte.com.cn] 
 Sent: Thursday, August 10, 2017 2:57 AM
 To: SHADMI, DAVID 
 Cc: LANDO, MICHAEL  yangya...@chinamobile.com 
denglin...@chinamobile.com meng.zhaoxi...@zte.com.cn 
onap-discuss@lists.onap.org ROZIN, EDEN 
 Subject: 答复: RE: RE: RE: [sdc][vfc] SDC questions from VF-C


 

hi david

 

thanks, david. a few