Re: Test drive of Skara feature to automatically resolve JBS issues

2019-12-09 Thread Jeanette Winzenburg



Thanks for the cleanup :)

Zitat von Kevin Rushforth :

I was planning to do that this morning (I was going to do it Friday  
afternoon, but ran into the JBS maintenance window, and then ran out  
of time). They actually had turned it on before the below bug was  
integrated, but there was a configuration error in the Skara bot  
that prevented it from working, and they haven't implemented the  
retry logic yet.


Thanks.

-- Kevin


On 12/9/2019 2:56 AM, Jeanette Winzenburg wrote:


Zitat von Kevin Rushforth :

The plan is to put this into place tomorrow (Friday, Dec 6) and  
test drive it for a week or two so that the Skara team can get  
feedback on how it is working for our project (they already use it  
for the Skara project).




hmm .. looks like https://github.com/openjdk/jfx/pull/56 was  
integrated too early for the magic to shine? (With a fix integrated  
today everything went fine :)


Should I update the corresponding issue manually?

-- CU, Jeanette










Re: Test drive of Skara feature to automatically resolve JBS issues

2019-12-09 Thread Kevin Rushforth
I was planning to do that this morning (I was going to do it Friday 
afternoon, but ran into the JBS maintenance window, and then ran out of 
time). They actually had turned it on before the below bug was 
integrated, but there was a configuration error in the Skara bot that 
prevented it from working, and they haven't implemented the retry logic yet.


Thanks.

-- Kevin


On 12/9/2019 2:56 AM, Jeanette Winzenburg wrote:


Zitat von Kevin Rushforth :

The plan is to put this into place tomorrow (Friday, Dec 6) and test 
drive it for a week or two so that the Skara team can get feedback on 
how it is working for our project (they already use it for the Skara 
project).




hmm .. looks like https://github.com/openjdk/jfx/pull/56 was 
integrated too early for the magic to shine? (With a fix integrated 
today everything went fine :)


Should I update the corresponding issue manually?

-- CU, Jeanette








Re: Test drive of Skara feature to automatically resolve JBS issues

2019-12-09 Thread Jeanette Winzenburg



Zitat von Kevin Rushforth :

The plan is to put this into place tomorrow (Friday, Dec 6) and test  
drive it for a week or two so that the Skara team can get feedback  
on how it is working for our project (they already use it for the  
Skara project).




hmm .. looks like https://github.com/openjdk/jfx/pull/56 was  
integrated too early for the magic to shine? (With a fix integrated  
today everything went fine :)


Should I update the corresponding issue manually?

-- CU, Jeanette






Test drive of Skara feature to automatically resolve JBS issues

2019-12-05 Thread Kevin Rushforth
The Skara team is ready for us to test drive the "gitupdater" feature of 
the Skara bot which will automatically resolve JBS issues as fixed when 
the associated pull request is integrated. It will also add a comment 
with the commit message.


I note that while it is far enough along for us to test, it isn't 
completely finished: the Skara bot will not set the fixVersion nor will 
it create a backport record (this latter isn't a concern yet, but will 
be in the future).


The plan is to put this into place tomorrow (Friday, Dec 6) and test 
drive it for a week or two so that the Skara team can get feedback on 
how it is working for our project (they already use it for the Skara 
project).


This means two things:

1. The Reviewers of a PR, as well as the Committer who will integrate 
(or sponsor) the fix, need to ensure that the JBS bug has the fix 
version set to the current release, which is openjfx14.


2. Once a fix is integrated, don't update the JBS bugs (other than you 
can remove the "review-requested" label if present). We want to give the 
Skara bot a change to do it's magic.


Let me know if you have any questions.

-- Kevin