Re: Reply: Remove useless param for create_groupingsets_path

2022-07-01 Thread Tom Lane
XueJing Zhao  writes:
> You are right, The patch is incorrect, and I generate a patch once more, It 
> is sent as as attachment named new,patch, please check, thanks!

LGTM.  Pushed, thanks!

regards, tom lane




Reply: Remove useless param for create_groupingsets_path

2022-06-15 Thread XueJing Zhao
Hi, Richard
You are right, The patch is incorrect, and I generate a patch once more, It is 
sent as as attachment named new,patch, please check, thanks!

Best regards!
Zxuejing

From: Richard Guo 
Date: 2022-06-15 12:12
To: XueJing Zhao 
Cc: pgsql-hackers@lists.postgresql.org 
Subject: Re: Remove useless param for create_groupingsets_path


On Wed, Jun 15, 2022 at 11:33 AM XueJing Zhao 
mailto:zxuej...@vmware.com>> wrote:
Recently I work on grouping sets and I find the last param numGroups of 
create_groupingsets_path is not used.
In create_groupingsets_path we use rollup->numGroups to do cost_agg.

Yes indeed. The param 'numGroups' was used originally when we first
introduced in create_groupingsets_path(), and then all its references
inside that function were removed and replaced with the numGroups inside
RollupData in b5635948.

I generate a diff.patch, which is sent as an attachment.

BTW, the patch looks weird to me that it seems operates in the inverse
direction, i.e. it's adding the param 'numGroups', not removing it.

Thanks
Richard




new.diff
Description: new.diff