Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
On Mon, Nov 03, 2008 at 10:17:50AM -0500, Eric Sproul wrote: > Christian Weisgerber wrote: > > A grep over a recent set of amd64 bulk build logs shows these ports > > generating warnings that indicate possible 64-bit problems: > > > > > libssh2-0.18 > > Hi, > I finally got around to setting up an amd64 test platform, and with -current > from yesterday, I get no warnings of any type during the build. I'm happy to > provide the portslogger log if anyone is interested. I was not able to test > at > the time the warnings were announced (late June), so I'm curious what might > have > changed since then, as I've made no changes to the port, nor have there been > any > upstream updates. I want to mention that it does have problems. I was attempting to help someone on PerlMonks and had problems with p5-Net-SSH2 causing perl to core dump on amd64. http://www.perlmonks.org/?node_id=720724 My reply with test code that caused the dump is the first reply in that thread. I don't actually use it, and didn't have time to file a complete bug report, but I did see that it was broken. l8rZ, -- andrew - ICQ# 253198 - Jabber: [EMAIL PROTECTED] BOFH excuse of the day: endothermal recalibration
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
Christian Weisgerber wrote: > I do. > > sftp.c: In function `libssh2_sftp_fstat_ex': > sftp.c:1470: warning: cast to pointer from integer of different size Interesting... after removing the cached package and doing 'make deinstall && make clean', I now see the same warning. I'm not sure what I did to miss that before, but sorry for the noise. I'll go away and see if I can get rid of the warning. Regards, Eric
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
Eric Sproul <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > A grep over a recent set of amd64 bulk build logs shows these ports > > generating warnings that indicate possible 64-bit problems: > > > libssh2-0.18 > > I finally got around to setting up an amd64 test platform, and with -current > from yesterday, I get no warnings of any type during the build. I do. sftp.c: In function `libssh2_sftp_fstat_ex': sftp.c:1470: warning: cast to pointer from integer of different size -- Christian "naddy" Weisgerber [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
Christian Weisgerber wrote: > A grep over a recent set of amd64 bulk build logs shows these ports > generating warnings that indicate possible 64-bit problems: > > libssh2-0.18 Hi, I finally got around to setting up an amd64 test platform, and with -current from yesterday, I get no warnings of any type during the build. I'm happy to provide the portslogger log if anyone is interested. I was not able to test at the time the warnings were announced (late June), so I'm curious what might have changed since then, as I've made no changes to the port, nor have there been any upstream updates. Regards, Eric
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
"Arnaud Bergeron" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
> I'll admit I didn't think about this. So I'll have to fix it. It
> helps that most uses of the pointers look like that:
>
> int main() {
> int true = 1;
> void *nonnull = (void *)0x7000;
> true = true && nonnull;
> printf("%d\n", true);
> }
>
> which does work correctly.
>
> Arnaud
I'm pretty sure !! will normalize anything to a correct truth value without
any type problems, but I'm not a C lawyer.
//art
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
> > "Arnaud Bergeron" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
> >
> >> mt-daapd suffers from a case I've named 0.5:
> >>
> >> pointer -> int
> >>
> >> and then the int is used as a truth value. So this is not a bug.
> >
> > Not a bug? Really?
> >
> > $ cat foo.c
> > int
> > main()
> > {
> >int true;
> >void *nonnull = (void *)0x7000;
> >
> >true = nonnull;
> >printf(true ? "true\n" : "false\n");
> >true = !!nonnull;
> >printf(true ? "true\n" : "false\n");
> > }
> > $ make foo
> > cc -O2 -pipe-o foo foo.c
> > foo.c: In function `main':
> > foo.c:7: warning: assignment makes integer from pointer without a cast
> > $ ./foo
> > false
> > true
> > $
> >
> > //art
>
> I'll admit I didn't think about this. So I'll have to fix it. It
> helps that most uses of the pointers look like that:
And think about the big-endian 64 bit machines too. If the cast is
in the right place, and you ensure that all memory is allocated below
4GB... guess what happens.
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
2008/7/3 Artur Grabowski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
> "Arnaud Bergeron" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
>
>> mt-daapd suffers from a case I've named 0.5:
>>
>> pointer -> int
>>
>> and then the int is used as a truth value. So this is not a bug.
>
> Not a bug? Really?
>
> $ cat foo.c
> int
> main()
> {
>int true;
>void *nonnull = (void *)0x7000;
>
>true = nonnull;
>printf(true ? "true\n" : "false\n");
>true = !!nonnull;
>printf(true ? "true\n" : "false\n");
> }
> $ make foo
> cc -O2 -pipe-o foo foo.c
> foo.c: In function `main':
> foo.c:7: warning: assignment makes integer from pointer without a cast
> $ ./foo
> false
> true
> $
>
> //art
I'll admit I didn't think about this. So I'll have to fix it. It
helps that most uses of the pointers look like that:
int main() {
int true = 1;
void *nonnull = (void *)0x7000;
true = true && nonnull;
printf("%d\n", true);
}
which does work correctly.
Arnaud
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
"Arnaud Bergeron" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
> mt-daapd suffers from a case I've named 0.5:
>
> pointer -> int
>
> and then the int is used as a truth value. So this is not a bug.
Not a bug? Really?
$ cat foo.c
int
main()
{
int true;
void *nonnull = (void *)0x7000;
true = nonnull;
printf(true ? "true\n" : "false\n");
true = !!nonnull;
printf(true ? "true\n" : "false\n");
}
$ make foo
cc -O2 -pipe-o foo foo.c
foo.c: In function `main':
foo.c:7: warning: assignment makes integer from pointer without a cast
$ ./foo
false
true
$
//art
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
On Wed, 2 Jul 2008, Arnaud Bergeron wrote: >mt-daapd suffers from a case I've named 0.5: > >pointer -> int > >and then the int is used as a truth value. So this is not a bug. >I'll wait for the decision on silencing innocuous warnings before >sending a patch if needed. Um, what if the low-order 32 bits of a non-null pointer are all zero? Dave -- Dave Anderson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
mt-daapd suffers from a case I've named 0.5: pointer -> int and then the int is used as a truth value. So this is not a bug. I'll wait for the decision on silencing innocuous warnings before sending a patch if needed. Arnaud
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
Matthew Dempsky <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I'm looking at the Erlang port's build logs, and I see some "warning: > cast from pointer to integer of different size" messages. Are there > any other messages to look out for? I grepped for these: warning: assignment makes integer from pointer without a cast warning: assignment makes pointer from integer without a cast warning: cast from pointer to integer of different size warning: cast to pointer from integer of different size -- Christian "naddy" Weisgerber [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
On Mon, Jun 30, 2008 at 8:31 AM, Christian Weisgerber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > A grep over a recent set of amd64 bulk build logs shows these ports > generating warnings that indicate possible 64-bit problems: I'm looking at the Erlang port's build logs, and I see some "warning: cast from pointer to integer of different size" messages. Are there any other messages to look out for?
Re: Ports with possible 64-bit problems
On 2008/06/30 15:31, Christian Weisgerber wrote: > A grep over a recent set of amd64 bulk build logs shows these ports > generating warnings that indicate possible 64-bit problems: Build logs of these are available at http://spacehopper.org/amd64-logs/
Ports with possible 64-bit problems
A grep over a recent set of amd64 bulk build logs shows these ports generating warnings that indicate possible 64-bit problems: 915resolution-0.5.3 9wm-1.2prep0 ADMsmb-0.2p0 BitchX-1.0c18p3 Canna35b2 Imaging-1.1.5-python2.4 Imaging-1.1.5-python2.5 STk-4.0.1p4 TclCurl-0.10.5p3 Tktable-2.9p0 WindowMaker-0.92.0 Wnn4.2 XPostitPlus-2.3p2 Xaw3d-1.5p1 XawMu-1.5p1 Xdialog-2.3.1 a2ps-4.13bp4-a4 a2ps-4.13bp4-letter aalib-1.4-no_x11 aalib-1.4 agm-1.3.1p1 amaya-5.1p3-motif amiwm-0.20.48 analog-6.0p1 angband-3.0.6p0-no_x11 angband-3.0.6p0 ap2-mod_fastcgi-2.4.2 app_conference-20070809p0 aqualung-0.9beta9.1p3 archie-1.4.1 arena-0.9.13 arm-elf-binutils-2.16 arm-elf-gdb-6.4 arm-elf-newlib-1.14.0 arts-1.5.9p0 ascd-0.13.2p1 asfiles-1.0 atomix-2.14.0p0 audacious-plugins-1.5.0 avidemux-2.4.1p1 avr-binutils-2.15p0 axe-6.1.2p0 axyftp-0.5.1p1 beaver-0.2.7p0 bibview-2.2 blender-2.45p1 bmp-0.9.7 bombermaze-0.6.6p1 bricons-3.0p0 brltty-3.6 btoa-5.2.1 cdrtools-2.01p1 cfengine-2.2.1p1 cftp-0.12p0 chbg-1.5 chipmunk-1.57p0 clamav-0.93 clamsmtp-1.8p1 claws-mail-3.4.0-ldap cnagios-0.25 coldfire-0.3.1 connect4-3.2p0 cook-2.21 cooledit-3.17.14p3-python cooledit-3.17.14p3 corewars-0.9.13 cssed-0.4.0p4 ctwm-3.6p0 cyrus-imapd-2.3.12-drac cyrus-imapd-2.3.12 cyrus-sasl-2.1.22p4-ldap dc_gui-0.42p0 dctc-0.68.0 dia-0.96.1p7 digikam-0.9.3 docbook-to-man-0.0p0 dovecot-1.0.15-ldap-mysql-postgresql-sqlite dovecot-1.0.15-ldap dovecot-1.0.15-mysql dovecot-1.0.15-postgresql dovecot-1.0.15-sqlite dovecot-1.0.15 doxygen-1.5.4.src dspam-3.8.0-sqlite3-ldap dvd+rw-tools-7.0p0 dynamips-0.2.8rc2p0 e-20071211p3 e16keyedit-0.5 ecore-20071211 edje-20071211 elm-2.4ME+66 embryo-20071211 emiclock-2.0.2p0 enigmail-0.95.6 erlang-12b.3 es-0.9b1p0 eterm-0.9.4p0-kanji eterm-0.9.4p0 etk-20071211p1 ettercap-0.7.3p0-no_x11 ettercap-0.7.3p0 evolution-data-server-2.22.2p0 evolution-plugin-rss-0.0.8p1 exim-4.69-ldap exim-4.69-mysql exim-4.69-no_exiscan exim-4.69-postgresql exim-4.69 expect-5.43.0p0-no_tk expect-5.43.0p0 extace-1.9.9 faces-1.6.1 falconseye-1.9.3p2 fbpanel-4.12 fcgi-2.4.0p3 feh-1.3.4 festival-1.95betap2-ogi festival-1.95betap2 figlet-2.2.1p0 findutils-4.1p0 flite-1.2p1 fltk-1.1.7p0 fluidsynth-1.0.8p0 fox-1.6.28 freeciv-2.1.4 freedroid-1.0.2 fvwm-2.4.20-i18n fvwm-2.4.20 fvwm95-2.0.43ap1 fxtv-1.03p2 gail-1.20.2p3 galculator-1.3.1p1 galeon-2.0.3p3 gbdfed-1.4 geany-0.13p2 gedit-2.20.4p3 gegl-0.0.16 generator-0.35r2p0 gettext-0.17 ghc-6.6.1 ghostscript-8.62p1-a4-cups ghostscript-8.62p1-a4-gtk-cups ghostscript-8.62p1-a4-gtk ghostscript-8.62p1-a4-no_x11-cups ghostscript-8.62p1-a4-no_x11 ghostscript-8.62p1-a4 ghostscript-8.62p1-cups ghostscript-8.62p1-gtk-cups ghostscript-8.62p1-gtk ghostscript-8.62p1-no_x11-cups ghostscript-8.62p1-no_x11 ghostscript-8.62p1 gkrellsun-0.12.1p9 glimpse-4.1p1 glut-3.7p2 gmudix-0.10p5 gnats-3.113.1p4 gnokii-0.6.14p7 gnome-keyring-manager-2.20.0p0 gnome-scan-0.6 gnopernicus-1.1.2p2 gnumeric-1.8.3 gnupg-1.4.9 gnustep-gui-0.14.0 gnutls-2.0.4 gofer-2.30a gok-1.3.7p4 golem-0.0.5p0 gphoto-0.4.3p3 gphoto-2.4.1 gpsbabel-1.3.4 gq-1.0beta1p8 grace-5.1.15p0 grip-3.2.0p10 grisbi-0.5.9p1 gromit-20041213p5 grpn-1.1.2 gtetrinet-0.7.11 gtimer-1.1.6p0 gtk+-2.12.9 gtk-engines2-2.14.1 gtkaml-0.2.1.0p0 gtkballs-3.1.5p5 gtkglext-1.2.0p0 gtklp-1.2.6 gtksee-0.5.0 gutenprint-5.0.1 gv-3.5.8p4 hexcalc-19951219 hnb-1.9.17 hoc-1.1p0 honeyd-1.5cp2 howl-1.0.0p0 ht-2.0.14-no_x11 ht-2.0.14 hugs98-2005.03 hyperestraier-1.4.13 hypermail-2.1.8p0-gdbm hypermail-2.1.8p0 icb-5.0.9p3 iksemel-1.2 imap-2007a1-plaintext imap-2007a1 imapproxy-1.2.5p1 imlib-1.9.14p6 intel2gas-1.3.3 iodbc-3.52.4 ion-20070318p1 irssi-silc-1.1.4 isc-dhcp-3.1.0 isearch-1.14 isic-0.07 isomaster-1.3.1 ispell-3.2.06 itcl-3.3p0 ivan-0.50p0 iview-1.4 ja-kterm-6.2.0p3-xaw3d ja-kterm-6.2.0p3 ja-less-3.32pl2.48p0 jabberd-2.0s11p4-mysql-ldap jabberd-2.0s11p4-mysql jdk-1.5.0.14 jdk-1.7.0.00 jed-0.99.16-no_x11 jed-0.99.16 jesred-1.2.1p0 jlint-3.0 json-c-0.7 junkbuster-2.0.2p2 kaffe-1.1.7 kakasi-2.3.4 kanatest-0.3.6p3 kanjips-19900310 kazehakase-0.5.4 kdebase-3.5.9 kdeedu-3.5.9 kdemultimedia-3.5.9 kdenetwork-3.5.9 kdepim-3.5.9p0 kicad-20070115 klone-2.1ap0 koffice-1.6.3p4 konqueror-20060121p2 larswm-7.5.3p1 lesstif-0.92.6p0 lgeneral-0.5.0 libast-0.7p3 libbonobo-2.20.3p3 libfmt-2.0 libgail-gnome-1.20.0p2 libgnomeprint-2.18.4p1 libgphoto-2.4.1 libical-0.27 libmal-0.44 libmatchbox-1.8p1 libnasl-2.2.9p0 libnetdude-0.10ap0 libproplist-0.10.1p1 libssh2-0.18 libunicode-0.4p1 libxml1-1.8.17p2 lifelines-3.0.60p0 liferea-1.4.15 lighttpd-1.4.19p3-ldap-mysql lighttpd-1.4.19p3-ldap links-1.00pre20 linleech-2.2.1 liveMedia-20080409 lmbench-1.1 logsurfer-1.5bp0 lopster-1.2.2 lout-3.30 maelstrom-3.0.6p0 magicpoint-1.11bp6 mbrowse-0.3.1 mcl-06_058 mcsim-4.2.0 meanwhile-1.0.2p1 metamail-2.7p0 mgdiff-1.0p0 mico-2.3.6p2 micropolis-20080211 mimedefang-2.64 minimo-20080410 mjpegtools-1.9.0rc3p0-quicktime mjpegtools-1.9.0rc3p0 mk-2.0p0 mldonkey-2.9.1 mlterm-2.9.0p7 mod_auth_ldap-1.6.0p5 mod_auth_mysql-3.2p3 mod_auth_radius-1.5.7p4 mod_dav-
