Re: [Vo]:Working on possible error in my paper on Mizuno

2015-02-13 Thread Teslaalset
Meanwhile Mizuno appeared to have filed his technology. WO2015008859
recently was published:
http://worldwide.espacenet.com/publicationDetails/originalDocument?CC=WONR=2015008859A2KC=A2FT=DND=3date=20150122DB=EPODOClocale=en_EP


On Thu, Feb 12, 2015 at 9:51 PM, Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com wrote:

 I may have discovered an error in the paper I wrote on Mizuno. It may be
 serious enough to invalidate the results. This goes back to what I wrote
 here on January 21 in response to David Roberson:



 How do you explain the fact that the temperature in the vicinity of the
 palladium wire drops very quickly after the pulse?


 I noticed that. It will take more calibrations to sort out what is going
 on there. I do not fully trust that thermocouple. . . . I would like to see
 what's going on in the counter-electrode which is also Pd.


 I do not want to specify what I have in mind because I am still working on
 it. I may discover I am getting all upset about nothing. Give me another
 week or so to sort it out. I will publish full details either way, even if
 it turns out to be a false alarm.

 I mention this here just in case Dave or someone else discovers the
 problem and publishes before I do. (Assuming there is a problem.) To be
 honest, I am posting this message now mainly because I do not wish to be
 accused of covering up a serious mistake in my own work. You might call
 this a claim of negative priority.

 - Jed




[Vo]:Working on possible error in my paper on Mizuno

2015-02-12 Thread Jed Rothwell
I may have discovered an error in the paper I wrote on Mizuno. It may be
serious enough to invalidate the results. This goes back to what I wrote
here on January 21 in response to David Roberson:



 How do you explain the fact that the temperature in the vicinity of the
 palladium wire drops very quickly after the pulse?


I noticed that. It will take more calibrations to sort out what is going on
there. I do not fully trust that thermocouple. . . . I would like to see
what's going on in the counter-electrode which is also Pd.


I do not want to specify what I have in mind because I am still working on
it. I may discover I am getting all upset about nothing. Give me another
week or so to sort it out. I will publish full details either way, even if
it turns out to be a false alarm.

I mention this here just in case Dave or someone else discovers the problem
and publishes before I do. (Assuming there is a problem.) To be honest, I
am posting this message now mainly because I do not wish to be accused of
covering up a serious mistake in my own work. You might call this a claim
of negative priority.

- Jed