Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-08 Thread Bruce Ellis
Why? Why the angst? Nix is cool. And the nonexistent demons will release something cool. Now getting back to the lost v10 - which I think is a much more interesting topic. (There work is much more interesting, I guess mine is challenging). I have to go to Canberra to sort this out. Got the

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread pmarin
I thought all the discussion of how the development process should be more open ended with the creation of 9front. For me one of the best things about 9front is that I can follow all the changes in the code by reading their mailing list. pmarin On Sat, Sep 7, 2013 at 6:36 AM, Bruce Ellis

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Kurt H Maier
Quoting Bruce Ellis bruce.el...@gmail.com: I was disturbed by the claim that v10 had been lost because of bullshit, but said nothing. If indeed someone has lost their v10 I can replace it. If you are in australia it's easy. Contact me with the details of your import license and I will arrange

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Bruce Ellis
I'm not sure how to negotiate this. Tiger says: 1) Go back to 1988. 2) Apply for a license. 3) Run it/enjoy it. 4) Stop being a dick brucee On 7 September 2013 23:21, Kurt H Maier k...@sciops.net wrote: Quoting Bruce Ellis bruce.el...@gmail.com: I was disturbed by the claim that v10 had

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Kurt H Maier
Quoting Bruce Ellis bruce.el...@gmail.com: I'm not sure how to negotiate this. Tiger says: 1) Go back to 1988. 2) Apply for a license. 3) Run it/enjoy it. 4) Stop being a dick brucee I agree to these terms. As soon as I can go back to 1988, I'll stop being a dick. khm

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Bruce Ellis
Not sure I believe you. Also. Stephen Jones runs v10 in Seattle. You may be able to bribe him. The manifest on the door of my vax may also help. Attn: G.R.Emlin Room 2C501 600 Mountain Ave Murray Hill, NJ 07974 You'll also need a mux terminal or 16. I have a Blit and a 5630. Stephen has 5620s.

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Aram Hăvărneanu
we got not a single cent for nix. As far as lsub is concerned, it's been a free time effort. You are seriously misrepresenting nix and/or yourself. From http://lsub.org: Nix is joint work of Laboratorio de Sistemas with Bell Laboratories, Sandia National Labs, and Vitanuova. Lsub is part

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Latchesar Ionkov
Stop whining. If you want something done your way, do it yourself, or pay somebody to do it. If you think Nemo and his group (or anybody else) are not following the grants' rules, complain to the funding organizations. I don't remember seeing any funding coming with researchers have to publish

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Anthony Sorace
I believe the rules are different when the work is research, sponsored by public money. People are getting research grants to work on nix. who is getting grants to work on nix? And how do I get in on that? Someone tell me how to get money for working on nix and this thread becomes useful.

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Bruce Ellis
Perhaps by being qualified and having a substantial body of published research and teaching under your belt. Or out-source it. brucee On 8 September 2013 00:58, Anthony Sorace a...@9srv.net wrote: I believe the rules are different when the work is research, sponsored by public money.

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread tlaronde
On Sat, Sep 07, 2013 at 10:58:08AM -0400, Anthony Sorace wrote: Someone tell me how to get money for working on nix and this thread becomes useful. I guess that the answer is: provide your own. This is the GPL plague: saying to developers that as long as they provide gratis something

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread lucio
(Communism: give me your watch and, in fair exchange, I will tell you what time it is.) The misunderstanding here is that conventional ownership does not apply to intellectual property; in fact, it is not property at all and we should stop treating it as if it was. It is even harder to do any

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread tlaronde
On Sat, Sep 07, 2013 at 05:46:24PM +0200, lu...@proxima.alt.za wrote: (Communism: give me your watch and, in fair exchange, I will tell you what time it is.) The misunderstanding here is that conventional ownership does not apply to intellectual property; The algorithms are intellectual

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread erik quanstrom
[...] Nix is not a personal project. It's listed right there on the lsub page one thing seems to be missed is that nix is the name for at least two independent projects. a brief history. this is the best of my understanding. please correct me if i haven't credited folks properly. i am sure

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Ethan Grammatikidis
On Sat, Sep 7, 2013, at 12:35 AM, Aram Hăvărneanu wrote: Everything is developed in secret without the involvment of any potential parties. Sure, everybody has the right to work in any way they like (except when the work is paid by public money), but you reap what youb sow. The lack of public

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread lucio
The gratis software has not been gratis for the ones who have written it. It took time. The bulk of the difference is here. Sure, but we're still applying a modern metric to something that spans history (intellect, whatever that is). The fact that sales and marketing people make more money

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Ethan Grammatikidis
On Sat, Sep 7, 2013, at 05:40 PM, lu...@proxima.alt.za wrote: Of course, the number of different issues that need to be taken into account is much greater than the single item discussed here, but anything that rewards greed ought to be treated, at minimum, with great suspicion, not with

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread tlaronde
On Sat, Sep 07, 2013 at 06:40:48PM +0200, lu...@proxima.alt.za wrote: but anything that rewards greed ought to be treated, at minimum, with great suspicion, not with veneration. This is exactly what I say: the user's greed wanting something for nothing (neither money, nor time given, nor

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Latchesar Ionkov
On Sat, Sep 7, 2013 at 10:28 AM, erik quanstrom quans...@quanstro.netwrote: *WOOSH*. this is an obvious joke. see e.g. http://9fans.net/archive/2006/06/18 either that or you're just trolling. First secret societies, then private jokes? When are all these insults going to end??? :)

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread lucio
One of Life's great lessons for me has been those who most loudly accuse others of greed are themselves the most greedy. No position here is free of greed, no side in any conflict ever is, and that renders discussion of greed weak and potentially harmful. Sorry, can't resist. There's a great

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Gorka Guardiola
On Sat, Sep 7, 2013 at 3:56 PM, Aram Hăvărneanu ara...@mgk.ro wrote: we got not a single cent for nix. As far as lsub is concerned, it's been a free time effort. You are seriously misrepresenting nix and/or yourself. From http://lsub.org: Nix is joint work of Laboratorio de Sistemas

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread lucio
There's a great difference between accusing anyone of greed and treating greed as a beneficial virtue. At least, in my book, there is. ... or a destructive vice, that's the subject being discussed: not who is greedy or otherwise. ++L

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Christopher Nielsen
FWIW, I feel the same way as Steve. I only release code that I feel is going to be useful to others. Sometimes I am simply experimenting and the code isn't worth releasing. On Fri, Sep 6, 2013 at 4:00 PM, Francisco J Ballesteros n...@lsub.org wrote: I think its almost ready at least to try and

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Charles Forsyth
On 7 September 2013 14:56, Aram Hăvărneanu ara...@mgk.ro wrote: Let's quote something from a recent nix paper: We are grateful to Charles Forsyth for his advice regarding this work, and to the new Plan 9 secret society. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KTwnwbG9YLE

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Matthew Veety
You have to look on the bright side here guys: the fact that its secret makes it more tantalizing, and it will be cooler when released. It's like presents. Veety

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-07 Thread Charles Forsyth
On 8 September 2013 00:47, Matthew Veety mve...@gmail.com wrote: the fact that its secret It isn't really secret. We went back more than a few steps earlier in the year, which is one reason it would not be useful at all in its current state. At the moment, it is not, by any means, a series of

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Richard Miller
tl;dr: as far as i know, there is no private nix development going on, Aha, the fact that you don't know proves that it's private. ☺

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Francisco J Ballesteros
On Sep 6, 2013, at 10:49 AM, Richard Miller 9f...@hamnavoe.com wrote: tl;dr: as far as i know, there is no private nix development going on, Aha, the fact that you don't know proves that it's private. ☺ As are most the files I open in my editor, until at some point I do a Put and others can

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread hiro
It would be better if you guys keep it low here on the mailing list or else the people that got tricked into funding this might find out.

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Steve Simon
Aram's point, obviously, is not that working on nix is insulting. Pretending you are a better judge than the whole world on whether something is 'ready to be shared' is insulting. Unless you have lawyers pointing metaophorical guns at your job, in which case just say that. Good

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Francisco J Ballesteros
I think its almost ready at least to try and take a look, I will try to put out a copy next week, unless other authors ask me not to. any useful bit for production usage will be shared, anyway, we have always done it that way. In short, I agree 100% with Steve. On Sep 6, 2013, at 10:27 AM,

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread BurnZeZ
The main development tree is hosted in sources.lsub.org - http://lsub.org/ls/nix.html If true, there has been little unified progress. If false, then isn't this all about misrepresentation? As far as I can tell, the only person to have posted to syssoftware is Ballesteros. If those posts are

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Kurt H Maier
Quoting Steve Simon st...@quintile.net: Don't get me wrong, I am all for sharing code but its to authors right to decide not to share if they wish. You're preaching to the choir there. My personal opinion is the last thing the world needs is more computer software; it merely encourages

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Aram Hăvărneanu
Good grief, I write lots of code for plan9, only some of which I decide is successfull and well written enough to release. This is my choice and only mine I don't remember you bragging about your unpublished work though. I created it I do what I want with it. I believe the rules are

[9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Terry Wendt
Ok, I am The Official Village Idiot, but I always assumed that if you wanted a piece of software you could write it yourself? Or at least learn how to contribute to writing it? Or maybe find several tools to pipe together and script a little and maybe get what you needed done done? Of course

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Nemo
On Sep 7, 2013, at 1:35 AM, Aram Hăvărneanu ara...@mgk.ro wrote: I believe the rules are different when the work is research, sponsored by public money. People are getting research grants to work on nix. Just for the record, we got not a single cent for nix. As far as lsub is concerned, it's

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread erik quanstrom
I created it I do what I want with it. I believe the rules are different when the work is research, sponsored by public money. People are getting research grants to work on nix. who is getting grants to work on nix? as far as i know, there is no private nix development going on Who

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Devon H. O'Dell
2013/9/6 erik quanstrom quans...@quanstro.net: I created it I do what I want with it. I believe the rules are different when the work is research, sponsored by public money. People are getting research grants to work on nix. who is getting grants to work on nix? as far as i know, there

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-06 Thread Bruce Ellis
I don't really understand this thread. I thought it was a stupid flame war, in which case I can only say that I miss Boyd calling a spade a fucking shovel. I was disturbed by the claim that v10 had been lost because of bullshit, but said nothing. If indeed someone has lost their v10 I can

[9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-05 Thread Aram Hăvărneanu
Is nix closed source, dead, or vaporware? The daily generated nix.tgz is either not daily generated or the tree which it is archiving is dead. Most files are from 2012, most recent file (nix/sys/log/nixdistr) is from Feb 8 2013, the kernel is from Jul 10 2012. The variant posted on sources is

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-05 Thread erik quanstrom
Interestingly, the nix source published in 9atom contains newer files, May 20th to be exact. It's not just new drivers ported from 9atom, the newest non-driver, k10-specific file is stamped May 16th. I don't know if the timestamps are simply wrong or some priviledged people do get access to

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-05 Thread Francisco J Ballesteros
the mark I nix was, thanks to erik, made public and got stuff like graphics. Im sure you know where to find it. We have another version which is still experimental and unreleased, but we were distracted by other things. Hopefully we will publish it in the near future. But, we do what we can.

Re: [9fans] Closed nix development is an insult

2013-09-05 Thread Kurt H Maier
I was going to post something along the lines of if you can't increase the quality of a product, you can increase its value via artificial scarcity, but I've been out-trolled already: Quoting Francisco J Ballesteros n...@lsub.org: Sorry to hear that working on it is insulting. This is