Re: [agi] Introducing Steve's "Theory of Everything" in cognition.

2009-01-01 Thread Abram Demski
Steve, Sorry for not responding for a little while. Comments follow: >> >> PCA attempts to isolate components that give maximum >> information... so my question to you becomes, do you think that the >> problem you're pointing towards is suboptimal models that don't >> predict the data well enough

Re: [agi] Hypercomputation and AGI

2009-01-01 Thread Steve Richfield
J. Andrew, On 1/1/09, J. Andrew Rogers wrote: > > > On Jan 1, 2009, at 2:35 PM, J. Andrew Rogers wrote: > >> Since "digital" and "analog" are the same thing computationally ("digital" >> is a subset of "analog"), and non-digital computers have been generally >> superior for several decades, this

Re: [agi] Hypercomputation and AGI

2009-01-01 Thread Abram Demski
Ben, A few points concerning the central argument: --Reading the argument again, I again mistakenly interpreted it the way I had the first time (until I recalled the details of our previous discussion). The presentation of the argument causes me to assume that U is some kind of oracle directly ac

Re: [agi] [Science Daily] Our Unconscious Brain Makes The Best Decisions Possible

2009-01-01 Thread Richard Loosemore
Jim Bromer wrote: On Mon, Dec 29, 2008 at 4:02 PM, Richard Loosemore wrote: My friend Mike Oaksford in the UK has written several papers giving a higher level cognitive theory that says that people are, in fact, doing something like bayesian estimation when then make judgments. In fact, peopl

Re: [agi] Hypercomputation and AGI

2009-01-01 Thread J. Andrew Rogers
On Jan 1, 2009, at 2:35 PM, J. Andrew Rogers wrote: Since "digital" and "analog" are the same thing computationally ("digital" is a subset of "analog"), and non-digital computers have been generally superior for several decades, this is not relevant. Gah, that should be *digital* computers

Re: [agi] Hypercomputation and AGI

2009-01-01 Thread J. Andrew Rogers
On Dec 30, 2008, at 11:45 AM, Steve Richfield wrote: Bingo! You have to "tailor" the techniques to the problem - more than just "solving the equations", but often the representation of quantities needs to be in some sort of multivalued form. What I meant is that if the standard algebraic r

Re: [agi] [Science Daily] Our Unconscious Brain Makes The Best Decisions Possible

2009-01-01 Thread Jim Bromer
On Mon, Dec 29, 2008 at 4:02 PM, Richard Loosemore wrote: > My friend Mike Oaksford in the UK has written several > papers giving a higher level cognitive theory that says that people are, in > fact, doing something like bayesian estimation when then make judgments. In > fact, people are very go