Re: [agi] Introducing Steve's Theory of Everything in cognition.

2008-12-28 Thread Steve Richfield
Loosemore, et al, Just to get this discussion out of esoteric math, here is a REALLY SIMPLE way of doing unsupervised learning with dp/dt that looks like it ought to work. Suppose we record each occurrence of the inputs to a neuron, keeping counters to identify how many times each combination

[agi] Alternative Cicuitry

2008-12-28 Thread John G. Rose
Reading this - http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/23/health/23blin.html?ref=science makes me wonder what other circuitry we have that's discouraged from being accepted. John --- agi Archives: https://www.listbox.com/member/archive/303/=now RSS

RE: [agi] Universal intelligence test benchmark

2008-12-28 Thread John G. Rose
From: Matt Mahoney [mailto:matmaho...@yahoo.com] --- On Sat, 12/27/08, John G. Rose johnr...@polyplexic.com wrote: Well I think consciousness must be some sort of out of band intelligence that bolsters an entity in terms of survival. Intelligence probably stratifies or optimizes in

Re: [agi] Alternative Cicuitry

2008-12-28 Thread Richard Loosemore
John G. Rose wrote: Reading this - http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/23/health/23blin.html?ref=science makes me wonder what other circuitry we have that's discouraged from being accepted. This blindsight news is not really news. It has been known for decades that there are two separate

RE: [agi] Universal intelligence test benchmark

2008-12-28 Thread Matt Mahoney
--- On Sun, 12/28/08, John G. Rose johnr...@polyplexic.com wrote: So maybe for improved genetic algorithms used for obtaining max compression there needs to be a consciousness component in the agents? Just an idea I think there is potential for distributed consciousness inside of command

Re: [agi] Introducing Steve's Theory of Everything in cognition.

2008-12-28 Thread Abram Demski
Steve, This sort of simple solution us what makes me say that relational learning is where real progress is to be made. That's not to say that we shouldn't rely on past work in flat learning: a great deal of progress has been made in that area, boosting them far beyond what simplistic solutions

Re: [agi] Introducing Steve's Theory of Everything in cognition.

2008-12-28 Thread Abram Demski
Steve, There has been plenty of speculation regarding just WHAT is buried in those principal components. Do they generally comprise simple combinations if identifiable features, or some sort of smushing that virtually encrypts the features? I have heard arguments on both sides of this

Re: Human-centric AGI approach-paper (was Re: Indexing and Re: [agi] AGI Preschool: sketch of an evaluation framework for early stage AGI systems aimed at human-level, roughly humanlike AGI

2008-12-28 Thread Mike Tintner
Robert, What kind of problems have you designed this to solve? Can you give some examples? Robert: A brief paper on an AGI system for human-level ...had only 2 pages to fit in. If you are working on a system, you probably hope it will one day help design a better world,

Re: [agi] Universal intelligence test benchmark

2008-12-28 Thread Philip Hunt
2008/12/27 Matt Mahoney matmaho...@yahoo.com: --- On Fri, 12/26/08, Philip Hunt cabala...@googlemail.com wrote: Humans are very good at predicting sequences of symbols, e.g. the next word in a text stream. Why not have that as your problem domain, instead of text compression? That's the

Re: [agi] Universal intelligence test benchmark

2008-12-28 Thread Philip Hunt
2008/12/28 Philip Hunt cabala...@googlemail.com: Now, consider if I build a program that can predict how some sequences will continue. For example, given ABACADAEA it'll predict the next letter is F, or given: 1 2 4 8 16 32 it'll predict the next number is 64. (Whether the program

Re: Human-centric AGI approach-paper (was Re: Indexing and Re: [agi] AGI Preschool: sketch of an evaluation framework for early stage AGI systems aimed at human-level, roughly humanlike AGI

2008-12-28 Thread Robert Swaine
Mike,   Mike wrote: What kind of problems have you designed this to solve? Can you give some examples?   Natural language understanding, path finding, game playing   Any problems that can be represented as a situation in the four component domain (value - role - relation -  feature models) can

Re: Human-centric AGI approach-paper (was Re: Indexing and Re: [agi] AGI Preschool: sketch of an evaluation framework for early stage AGI systems aimed at human-level, roughly humanlike AGI

2008-12-28 Thread Mike Tintner
Robert: Example: Here's a pattern example you may not have seen before, but by 3C you discover the pattern and how to make an example: As spoken aloud: five and nine[is] fine two and six [is] twix five and seven [is] fiven Robert, So, if I understand, you're designing a system

Re: [agi] Universal intelligence test benchmark

2008-12-28 Thread Philip Hunt
2008/12/29 Matt Mahoney matmaho...@yahoo.com: Please remember that I am not proposing compression as a solution to the AGI problem. I am proposing it as a measure of progress in an important component (prediction). Then why not cut out the middleman and measure prediction directly? I.e. put

Re: Human-centric AGI approach-paper (was Re: Indexing and Re: [agi] AGI Preschool: sketch of an evaluation framework for early stage AGI systems aimed at human-level, roughly humanlike AGI

2008-12-28 Thread Robert Swaine
Mike, Very good choice.   But the system always *knows* these domains beforehand  - and that it must consider them in any problem?     YES  the domains content structure is what you mean, are the human-centric ones provided by living a childs life loading the value system with biases such as

Re: Human-centric AGI approach-paper (was Re: Indexing and Re: [agi] AGI Preschool: sketch of an evaluation framework for early stage AGI systems aimed at human-level, roughly humanlike AGI

2008-12-28 Thread Mike Tintner
Robert, Thanks for your detailed, helpful replies. I like your approach of operating in multiple domains for problemsolving. But if the domains are known beforehand, then it's not truly creative problemsolving - where you do have to be prepared to go in search of the appropriate domains - and

Re: [agi] Introducing Steve's Theory of Everything in cognition.

2008-12-28 Thread Abram Demski
Steve, I should have specified further. When I say good I mean good at predicting. PCA attempts to isolate components that give maximum information... so my question to you becomes, do you think that the problem you're pointing towards is suboptimal models that don't predict the data well enough,

Re: [agi] Universal intelligence test benchmark

2008-12-28 Thread Philip Hunt
2008/12/29 Philip Hunt cabala...@googlemail.com: 2008/12/29 Matt Mahoney matmaho...@yahoo.com: Please remember that I am not proposing compression as a solution to the AGI problem. I am proposing it as a measure of progress in an important component (prediction). [...] Turning a