Re: DIS: Campaign proposal proto

2017-11-22 Thread Ørjan Johansen
On Wed, 22 Nov 2017, Corona wrote: Well, I felt uncomfortable not having a Campaign Proposal if PSS is going to have one, so... I'd rather if y'all checked it for obvious holes, since it looks like it can't be retracted once announced. Hm you CAN retract it from the Proposal Pool (rule 2350).

Re: DIS: Campaign proposal proto

2017-11-22 Thread ATMunn
I think it's an interesting idea, but it's a bit too pragmatic. I haven't read anyone else's messages, but here are my comments. On 11/22/2017 6:17 PM, Corona wrote: Well, I felt uncomfortable not having a Campaign Proposal if PSS is going to have one, so... I'd rather if y'all checked it for

Re: DIS: Campaign proposal proto

2017-11-22 Thread Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
You SHOULD make it a SHOULD not a SHALL. That is how other emotion things have been done. Publius Scribonius Scholasticus p.scribonius.scholasti...@gmail.com > On Nov 22, 2017, at 6:26 PM, Corona wrote: > > That was intended to be the point; you could choose

Re: DIS: Campaign proposal proto

2017-11-22 Thread Corona
Oh well. If it turns out to be unpopular, I won't submit it, and in no case will I commit to it. On 11/22/17, VJ Rada wrote: > It's a proto, correctly sent to discussion. > > I question the wisdom of imposing an obligation on anyone who reads a > particular message. It's not

Re: DIS: Campaign proposal proto

2017-11-22 Thread Corona
That was intended to be the point; you could choose not to disclose that you have read the message, avoiding any punishment for not having emotion X On 11/22/17, VJ Rada wrote: > It's a proto, correctly sent to discussion. > > I question the wisdom of imposing an obligation

Re: DIS: Campaign proposal proto

2017-11-22 Thread Corona
It's a proto. I apologise for the pronouns, here's a fixed version: I submit my Campaign Proposal for the Herald election: Create a new rule with power 1, name "Fireworks" and text as follows: All types of Fireworks are fixed assets. The Herald is the recordkeepor of all types of Fireworks. The

Re: DIS: Campaign proposal proto

2017-11-22 Thread VJ Rada
It's a proto, correctly sent to discussion. I question the wisdom of imposing an obligation on anyone who reads a particular message. It's not possible to know who reads what. Also, I'd like not to be punished for not being happy enough please. You can't tell me what to do! Finally, I voted

Re: DIS: Campaign proposal proto

2017-11-22 Thread Madeline
Need to TTttPF, and also you forgot Spivak pronouns. On 2017-11-23 10:17, Corona wrote: Well, I felt uncomfortable not having a Campaign Proposal if PSS is going to have one, so... I'd rather if y'all checked it for obvious holes, since it looks like it can't be retracted once announced. The