DIS: Re: BUS: [FRC] Problems

2019-08-13 Thread Kerim Aydin
Take care Aris, I've found over time that sometimes Agora is a good
way to occupy my mind for my health, but sometimes a person just needs
a darned break, too.  Even if the tournament stops right here the
entries have been quite enjoyable, so thank you for running it.  -G.

On Sat, Aug 10, 2019 at 8:47 PM Aris Merchant
 wrote:
>
> This is entire message is OOC.
>
> I'm not doing very well. I've been having both physical health problems and
> fairly serious mental health problems, in addition to a bunch of real life
> responsibilities (TBH, I'm not sure I can even get to all of those at the
> moment). I'd like to remain judge, and am planning to try to fulfill my
> responsibilities. If I can't though, I don't want the contest to die just
> because I'm no longer able to judge it. This amendment to the regulations 
> would
> give me a way to stop that from happening if the need arises. I'm sorry to
> everyone for letting you down.
>
> I intend, Without 3 Objections, to amend the Birthday Tournament regulations 
> by
> adding the following regulation:
>
> 15. The Judge may with 3 Support, appoint a specified player as judge, 
> provided
> that player consents. Upon doing so, the former Judge is no longer Judge,
> and the new Judge assumes all powers and responsibilities of being judge
> and ceases being a contestant, if e was one.


DIS: Re: BUS: CFJ 3769 judged TRUE

2019-08-13 Thread Jason Cobb

On 8/13/19 11:58 AM, Timon Walshe-Grey wrote:

I find no fault with the caller's arguments, though I admit I can't see why e 
cares one way or the other about the matter. I judge this CFJ TRUE.

-twg


As for why I care:

It came up in an earlier CFJ (3761) about causing an asset to come into 
existence.The first judgement argued that if ratification w/o objection 
were performed, then the person performing the ratification would have 
caused the asset to come into existence. I argued that it didn't count 
as the person causing the changes, so the person wasn't causing the 
asset to come into existence. The judgement was reconsidered and given a 
different resolution, but I felt the question was still valid.


--
Jason Cobb