Re: DIS: Rule 1868 Paradox

2007-01-26 Thread Ed Murphy
Jacob Sutton wrote: */Kerim Aydin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>/* wrote: >Check out CFJ 1575: >http://zenith.homelinux.net/cotc/viewcase.php?cfj=1575 I guess that case could be reopened, then. In fact, it was, and root re-judged it as required: http://zenith.homelinux.net/cotc/viewcas

Re: DIS: Rule 1868 Paradox

2007-01-26 Thread Ed Murphy
Jacob Sutton wrote: Ed Murphy wrote: >Jacob Sutton wrote: >> Rule 1868 states that a CFJ is open if it has not been judged and >>closed >>if it is not open >>So, if a case has been judged, there is no rule keeping it from still >>being considered open. >Correct. So it's not open. (

Re: DIS: Rule 1868 Paradox

2007-01-26 Thread Jacob Sutton
Kerim Aydin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >Jacob Sutton wrote: >> Just because it is open before it's judged doesn't mean that's >> the only time it's open. >Check out CFJ 1575: >http://zenith.homelinux.net/cotc/viewcase.php?cfj=1575 I guess that case could be reopened, then. "Invisib

DIS: Rule 1868 Paradox

2007-01-26 Thread Kerim Aydin
Jacob Sutton wrote: Just because it is open before it's judged doesn't mean that's the only time it's open. Check out CFJ 1575: http://zenith.homelinux.net/cotc/viewcase.php?cfj=1575

DIS: Rule 1868 Paradox

2007-01-26 Thread Jacob Sutton
Ed Murphy wrote: >Jacob Sutton wrote: >> Rule 1868 states that a CFJ is open if it has not been judged and >>closed >>if it is not open >>So, if a case has been judged, there is no rule keeping it from still >>being considered open. >Correct. So it's not open. (Assuming it also doesn't

Re: DIS: Rule 1868 Paradox

2007-01-26 Thread Ed Murphy
Jacob Sutton wrote: Rule 1868 states that a CFJ is open if it has not been judged and closed if it is not open So, if a case has been judged, there is no rule keeping it from still being considered open. Correct. So it's not open. (Assuming it also doesn't have any outstanding motions.) Th

DIS: Rule 1868 Paradox

2007-01-26 Thread Jacob Sutton
Rule 1868 states that a CFJ is open if it has not been judged and closed if it is not open So, if a case has been judged, there is no rule keeping it from still being considered open. Thus, after a CFJ has been judged, there is no way to determine if it is open or closed. Therefore, it can