On Sat, Jun 3, 2023 at 7:37 PM Fernando Frediani
wrote:
> If there are not enough incentives already let's create more then. We, as
> a community in a bottom up process as responsible for creating them based
> on what is right and fair to most people.
>
> Use the excuse that the broker market is
Michel -
That might help for transfers that are completed, but does nothing about
facilitators that aren’t really qualified and never manage to get a transfer
completed – despite representations of their purported capabilities to do so.
To the extent that you wish some form of public reporting
> John Curran wrote :
> [..] one with a lower probability that those selecting a facilitator from the
> list will end up dissatisfied.
A good start would be to make the process transparent : for each transaction,
have all of the details made public : the block size, the price, and the fees
Mike -
It’s still a simple service for the community, but now hopefully one with a
lower probability that those selecting a facilitator from the list will end up
dissatisfied.
Thanks,
/John
John Curran
President and CEO
American Registry for Internet Numbers
On Jun 4, 2023, at 1:35 PM, Mike
Hi John,
Not an argument, I just think it was a Freudian slip that revealed the
underlying purpose of the entire exercise-creating a list of “trusted” brokers.
Why even “qualify” brokers? Why does ARIN feel the need to take a step that no
other registry has felt the need to take.
Every RIR
Mike -
One can argue about the optimum terminology to use in the program title, but
what is most important aspect of ARIN’s liability is that the qualifications
are clear and uniformed applied - customers need to be able to know and trust
the level of vetting that ARIN does/does not apply to
One more thing John….
You keep referring to his as the “Trusted” Facilitator program, not Qualified.
Why does ARIN feel to the need to create a trusted list, doesn’t that open ARIN
to even more liability exposure?
Regards,
Mike
From: ARIN-PPML On Behalf Of John Curran
Sent: Sunday,
Thanks John.
Why are foreign facilitators banned?
I am concerned about a tit-for-tat response.
This is a global market supported by inter-regional policies.
If it’s just to make facilitators easier to sue, I think things are getting
paranoid/ridiculous.
Regards,
Mike
From:
Folks -
I’d like to briefly address some of issues that have arisen in this thread
about the forthcoming ARIN Trusted Facilitator Program and its associated fee
change.
First, in terms of discussing this topic on ppml, this is probably the best
course of action today – despite the long-term
