Re: [Astlinux-users] Skype vs Astlinux[Scanned]

2008-06-10 Thread Martin Rogers
I would just add two comments. One critical criteria for me on the Skype v SIP debate has been whether or not the user can always guarantee they will have access to a computer. I have found that for traveling employees Skype has its place. I agree that trying to run two systems side by side

Re: [Astlinux-users] Skype vs Astlinux[Scanned]

2008-06-10 Thread David Caldwell
Thanks for your reply, David, Martin. Much appreciated and made me think about a few things. No, we don't have VoIP currently; we have a plain old Meridian switch. I think we can get cards to extend its capabilities but the whole idea of the staff members using VoIP was to save money and I

Re: [Astlinux-users] Skype vs Astlinux[Scanned]

2008-06-10 Thread Darren Grant
On 10/06/2008 08:56, David Caldwell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If I go down the DIY Asterisk route, then my users would be given some SIP software on their PC (not Skype!). An advantage to building an Asterisk (or probably Astlinux) server would be that it would prove (or otherwise) the

Re: [Astlinux-users] Skype vs Astlinux[Scanned]

2008-06-10 Thread David Caldwell
Thanks Darren. What codec do you prefer? I found previously that the best balance between bandwidth and voice quality was a proprietary one -- g729? Darren Grant wrote: On 10/06/2008 08:56, "David Caldwell" [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If I go down the DIY Asterisk route, then my

Re: [Astlinux-users] Skype vs Astlinux[Scanned]

2008-06-10 Thread David Caldwell
Thanks Tom. Hadn't thought of that. Tom Lynn wrote: If you have any compliance issues that require Call Detail Records, you'll want to manage the VOIP infrastructure yourself. I'm not sure if Skype supports this type of reporting. On Tue, Jun 10, 2008 at 3:08 AM, David Caldwell [EMAIL

Re: [Astlinux-users] Skype vs Astlinux[Scanned]

2008-06-09 Thread David Kerr
Skype is great for casual use. But, it uses it's own proprietary protocol and requires Skype at both ends, or you pay for Skype-out service. Skype protocol cannot (easily) be hooked into a Asterisk PBX. There are solutions but they require running the Skype client and hooking in to its API, and I