Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Alex Cockell
Quite. Would be so good if the Beeb were to put their weight behind a GStreamer plugin for their content.. or one that could talk to multiple media players... enabling, say, Mplayer, MythTV, totem, whatever-the-heck-the-user-interface-is to talk to, select, and play content. Fine - stipulate stre

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Alex Cockell
Syndication? I understand that to be "content fed out from a different server architecture". This is a client to talk to BBC gear. Umm - since *when* have you seen an open-source app flooded with ads? Why has it got to be binary only? Why not release under something like the Apache licence, or

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Richard P Edwards
Yes.. but this list was around before GeoIP, and before the Rights holders had a clue about the internet. Equally, the Trust now. I saw exactly the same things happening with music. Now, twenty years later, some of the music Rights holders have got the plot. What I would like to know is wh

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Chris Warren
If a streaming-only client was distributed in binary form (to ensure the software will always only be streaming-only) and keys were sufficiently protected, and NDAs and commercial agreements were signed you might get somewhere. Of course reach, value, etc. would have to be evaluated. However th

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Alex Cockell
OK... but please answer me this. What is the process by which a streaming-only plugin for, say, VLC *could* be evaluated and approved.. even though it wasn't written in-house by the Beeb? This is the wall that the devs of Beebplayer and XBMC etc are bashing their heads against. They are trying t

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Alex Cockell
Not quite the whole story. People intending to pirate material will have no qualms about faking out the iPlayer backend by pretending to be a legit client... While those which simply enable a wider reach onto architectures not directly developed for, and are trying to act in good faith... Are

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Anthony McKale
Ok puts on bbc hat, lots of us like open source commit to open source etc etc iPlayer¹s a bit of a special case where were often legally bound not to share the files for Rights reasons or even if we do have the rights we have geoip agreements not to share them abroad, then if we do finally have al

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread David Dorward
On 30 Sep 2010, at 17:42, Alex Cockell wrote: > And by doing so, they're only pissing off their best viewers - the early > adopters. Shooting themselves in the foot when hobbyists only want to *help* > The alternative would be aggravating the people who they have license agreements with that

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Alex Cockell
And by doing so, they're only pissing off their best viewers - the early adopters. Shooting themselves in the foot when hobbyists only want to *help* - Original message - > They've been going out of their way trying to stop unapproved apps > grabbing content. They put a lot of effort in

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Stephen Jolly
On 30 Sep 2010, at 16:41, Iain Wallace wrote: > Open Source gets a mention under meetings with Technology, Piracy and > Enforcement ticked in the header of the minutes. If you can suggest a way of facilitating the former without facilitating the things that rights-holders want to prevent, that wo

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Iain Wallace
They've been going out of their way trying to stop unapproved apps grabbing content. They put a lot of effort into making sure content is unavailable to open source systems when simply leaving it as is would mean anyone could write on top of iPlayer. e.g. read the second PDF http://pjakma.wordpres

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Anthony McKale
Replace BBC with iPlayer and I'd agree with some of those points, it's more a indifference and lack of care rather than being directly hostile though. And I'd say that will changes rather soon, due to various management changes. Ps since no one's publicly said I can't Here's some really good

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Alex Cockell
And yet they happily leech off the GNU ecosystem... What changed? Their previous management didn't seem to mind... - Original message - > Unlikely. The BBC have gone out of their way to be hostile to open > source attempts at using iPlayer content, however you will find > working exampl

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Iain Wallace
Unlikely. The BBC have gone out of their way to be hostile to open source attempts at using iPlayer content, however you will find working examples and programs for playing iPlayer stuff on pretty much anything on that same wiki. On Thu, Sep 30, 2010 at 11:15 AM, Alex Cockell wrote: > I'm not per

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Soulla Stylianou
Folks I dont know if anyone is interested in either chatbot technology or virtual worlds for teaching & learning. If you are email me direct as we're doing a couple of seminars in london (7/10) & brum (13/10) if anyone is interested. Not sure if I should post this here but as we once did a chatbot

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Alex Cockell
I'm not personally looking for metadata, but it would be great if some of the open-source players were permitted back into the fold, meaning that VLC and the like could play BBC content... Especially for cpu architectures that Adobe don't support. Oh, and be able to distribute said player plugi

Re: [backstage] I am trying to subscribe to the backstage-dev list and having no joy.

2010-09-30 Thread Gordon Joly
On 28/09/2010 08:32, Ant Miller wrote: I'll try and see if we can get this up again. can't make any guaruntees though- we're in the midst of a migration process right now, and restarting of some services will have to wait for hardware. You need CLOUD COMPUTING! Gordo -- Gordon Joly gord

Re: [backstage] API into iPlayer content

2010-09-30 Thread Iain Wallace
Not sure what you're looking for, but all the metadata that iPlayer pages uses to build a programme page is openly accessible http://beebhack.wikia.com/wiki/IPlayer_Metadata It can't not be otherwise the javascript on those pages wouldn't work. On Wed, Sep 29, 2010 at 2:59 PM, Anthony McKale wro