Re: Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-27 Thread Susan Maneck
> What you seem to be implying is that if fundamentalists would 'grow up', > they would become liberals. I think there is a fair amount of research > that bears on this issue. As people grow up, mature in their experience > and thinking, they tend to become more conservative and relativistic. De

Re: Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-27 Thread Don Calkins
ristian fundamentalism has matured over the last 125 years or so it has become more relativistic, but has remained as conservative a ever. My major point is that trying to put fundamentalism and liberalism on the same plane or axis obscures more points than it explains. As to Fowlers Stages of Faith, I&#x

RE: Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-27 Thread Owen Allen
Vaughan, I must admit to not having come across this concept. Is it just a question of relativity? Owen -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Vaughn Sheline Sent: Sunday, 27 July 2003 3:35 AM To: Baha'i Studies Subject: RE: Fundamentalis

Re: Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-26 Thread Susan Maneck
> The problem I have with this paper and most others on the subject is the > assumption that fundamentalism is a pole with liberalism at the other > end. Dear Don, That's why I proposed Fowlers's Stages of Faith as an alternative paradigm. In that paradigm *both* liberals and fundamentalist would

Re: Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-26 Thread Don Calkins
Susan Maneck wrote: > > This continues my review of articles from Reason and Revelation. Moojan's > article can be found online here: > http://www.breacais.demon.co.uk/BSR/Articles/2_Momen_Fundamentalism.htm > The site has been re-organized and this paper is now at http://www.breacais.demon.co.uk

RE: Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-26 Thread Vaughn Sheline
-Original Message- From: Owen Allen Sometime in the future the Baha'i Faith will enter its winter and only a few will be able to see their way to the next springtime. Do we allow fate to carry us to that or do we exert every spiritual muscle to prevent it? What do we know or might we come

RE: Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-25 Thread Owen Allen
from Reason and Revelation. Moojan's article can be found online here: http://www.breacais.demon.co.uk/BSR/Articles/2_Momen_Fundamentalism.htmMoojan Momen's article "Fundamentalism and Liberalism" argues that these two different approaches to religious questions can be better un

Fundamentalism and Liberalism

2003-07-23 Thread Susan Maneck
This continues my review of articles from Reason and Revelation. Moojan's article can be found online here: http://www.breacais.demon.co.uk/BSR/Articles/2_Momen_Fundamentalism.htm Moojan Momen's article "Fundamentalism and Liberalism" argues that these two different app