Re: Bind not starting

[Stephane Bortzmeyer]

On Fri, Oct 01, 2010 at 12:13:33PM -0400,
 John Wingenbach  wrote 
 a message of 440 lines which said:

> NS records must point to an A record. 

Or a  record.
___
bind-users mailing list
bind-users@lists.isc.org
https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind-users

Re: Bind not starting

[John Wingenbach]

 NS records must point to an A record.  ns1 and ns2 .nsdomain.com do 
not have A records defined for them according to the zone file.


-- John

On 10/1/2010 12:14 AM, rams wrote:

Hi,

I have configured records as follows in bind. When we start the bind 
9.7, bind is not starting.
But bind is started successfully when commented below ns domains which 
are marked as RED. Could you please clarify me.


*Note: Bind 9.6 is started successfully with the same below zone. *
Error:
zone nsdomain.com/IN : NS 'ns1.nsdomain.com 
' has no address records (A or )

zone nsdomain.com/IN : not loaded due to errors.
_default/nsdomain.com/IN : bad zone


$ORIGIN nsdomain.com .
@ IN SOA dns1.dns.net . ppk.yahoo.com 
. (

2009111903 ; serial
10800 ; refresh
3600 ; retry
2592000 ; expire
86400 ; minimum
)
a.nsdomain.com .86400INA1.1.1.1
a1.nsdomain.COM .86400INFE80::
a1.nsdomain.com .86400INFE80::
a1.nsdomain.com .86400INA1.1.1.1
a1.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a1.nsdomain.com .
a10.nsdomain.com .9IN
NSns1.nu.moon.
a11.nsdomain.com .9INNS 
abc.nsdomain.com .
a12.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
mx.nsdomain.com .
a13.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
cname.nsdomain.com .
a13.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a.nsdomain.com .
a13.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
mx.nsdomain.com .
a14.nsdomain.com .2147483647INNS 
ns1.a14.nsdomain.com .
a15.nsdomain.com .2147483647INNS 
ns1.a15.nsdomain.com .
a2.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
nsdomain.com .
a3.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a3.nsdomain.com .
a3.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a2.nsdomain.com .
a3.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a1.nsdomain.com .
a3.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
nsdomain.com .
a4.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a4.nsdomain.com .
a4.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a4.nsdomain.com .
a4.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a4.nsdomain.com .

A5.NSDOMAIN.COM .86400INFE80::
a5.NSDOMAIN.com .86400INFE80::
A5.nsdomain.com .86400INFE80::
a5.nsdomain.com .86400INFE80::
A5.NSDOMAIN.COM .86400INA
255.255.255.255
a5.nsdomain.COM .86400INA
255.255.255.255
a5.NSDOMAIN.com .86400INA
255.255.255.255
A5.nsdomain.com .86400INA
255.255.255.255
a5.nsdomain.com .86400INA
255.255.255.255
a5.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
A5.NSDOMAIN.COM .
a5.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a5.nsdomain.COM .
a5.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a5.NSDOMAIN.com .
a5.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
A5.nsdomain.com .
A6.NSDOMAIN.COM .86400INA
255.255.255.255
a6.nsdomain.COM .86400INA
255.255.255.254
a6.NSDOMAIN.com .86400INA
255.255.255.253
A6.nsdomain.com .86400INA
255.255.255.252
a6.nsdomain.com .86400INA
255.255.255.251
a6.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
A6.NSDOMAIN.COM .
a6.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a6.nsdomain.COM .
a6.nsdomain.com .86400INNS 
a6

Re: Bind not starting

[Matus UHLAR - fantomas]

> On Fri, Oct 01, 2010 at 09:44:42AM +0530,
>  rams  wrote 
>  a message of 300 lines which said:
> 
> > But bind is started successfully when commented below ns domains
> > which are marked as RED.

On 01.10.10 08:57, Stephane Bortzmeyer wrote:
> Some people are color-blind and some do not use a Web browser to read
> email. Using colors on a technical list is a really bad idea.

using HTML mail is a bad idea, especially on mailing lists :-)

> > zone nsdomain.com/IN: NS 'ns1.nsdomain.com' has no address records (A or
> > )
> 
> It is true: you configure name servers for nsdomain.com which are
> themselves inside the nsdomain.com zone but these name servers appear
> nowhere. You have to add address records (A or  records with the
> addresses of these in-zone name servers).

Every NS record must poing to name that has A and/or  records.

The NS record for the zone itself must also have same NS records
in the parent zone, together with A records if NS point to the zone.
They are called glue records and are required for DNS traversal.

-- 
Matus UHLAR - fantomas, uh...@fantomas.sk ; http://www.fantomas.sk/
Warning: I wish NOT to receive e-mail advertising to this address.
Varovanie: na tuto adresu chcem NEDOSTAVAT akukolvek reklamnu postu.
"The box said 'Requires Windows 95 or better', so I bought a Macintosh".
___
bind-users mailing list
bind-users@lists.isc.org
https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind-users

Re: Bind not starting

[Stephane Bortzmeyer]

On Fri, Oct 01, 2010 at 09:44:42AM +0530,
 rams  wrote 
 a message of 300 lines which said:

> But bind is started successfully when commented below ns domains
> which are marked as RED.

Some people are color-blind and some do not use a Web browser to read
email. Using colors on a technical list is a really bad idea.

> zone nsdomain.com/IN: NS 'ns1.nsdomain.com' has no address records (A or
> )

It is true: you configure name servers for nsdomain.com which are
themselves inside the nsdomain.com zone but these name servers appear
nowhere. You have to add address records (A or  records with the
addresses of these in-zone name servers).

___
bind-users mailing list
bind-users@lists.isc.org
https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind-users

Bind not starting

[rams]

Hi,

I have configured records as follows in bind. When we start the bind 9.7,
bind is not starting.
But bind is started successfully when commented below ns domains which are
marked as RED. Could you please clarify me.

*Note: Bind 9.6 is started successfully with the same below zone. *
Error:
zone nsdomain.com/IN: NS 'ns1.nsdomain.com' has no address records (A or
)
zone nsdomain.com/IN: not loaded due to errors.
_default/nsdomain.com/IN: bad zone


$ORIGIN nsdomain.com.
@ IN SOA dns1.dns.net. ppk.yahoo.com. (
2009111903 ; serial
10800 ; refresh
3600 ; retry
2592000 ; expire
86400 ; minimum
)
a.nsdomain.com.86400INA1.1.1.1
a1.nsdomain.COM.86400INFE80::
a1.nsdomain.com.86400INFE80::
a1.nsdomain.com.86400INA1.1.1.1
a1.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa1.nsdomain.com.
a10.nsdomain.com.9INNSns1.nu.moon.
a11.nsdomain.com.9INNSabc.nsdomain.com.
a12.nsdomain.com.86400INNSmx.nsdomain.com.
a13.nsdomain.com.86400INNScname.nsdomain.com.
a13.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa.nsdomain.com.
a13.nsdomain.com.86400INNSmx.nsdomain.com.
a14.nsdomain.com.2147483647INNSns1.a14.nsdomain.com.
a15.nsdomain.com.2147483647INNSns1.a15.nsdomain.com.
a2.nsdomain.com.86400INNSnsdomain.com.
a3.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa3.nsdomain.com.
a3.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa2.nsdomain.com.
a3.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa1.nsdomain.com.
a3.nsdomain.com.86400INNSnsdomain.com.
a4.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa4.nsdomain.com.
a4.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa4.nsdomain.com.
a4.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa4.nsdomain.com.
A5.NSDOMAIN.COM.86400INFE80::
a5.NSDOMAIN.com.86400INFE80::
A5.nsdomain.com.86400INFE80::
a5.nsdomain.com.86400INFE80::
A5.NSDOMAIN.COM.86400INA255.255.255.255
a5.nsdomain.COM.86400INA255.255.255.255
a5.NSDOMAIN.com.86400INA255.255.255.255
A5.nsdomain.com.86400INA255.255.255.255
a5.nsdomain.com.86400INA255.255.255.255
a5.nsdomain.com.86400INNSA5.NSDOMAIN.COM.
a5.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa5.nsdomain.COM.
a5.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa5.NSDOMAIN.com.
a5.nsdomain.com.86400INNSA5.nsdomain.com.
A6.NSDOMAIN.COM.86400INA255.255.255.255
a6.nsdomain.COM.86400INA255.255.255.254
a6.NSDOMAIN.com.86400INA255.255.255.253
A6.nsdomain.com.86400INA255.255.255.252
a6.nsdomain.com.86400INA255.255.255.251
a6.nsdomain.com.86400INNSA6.NSDOMAIN.COM.
a6.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa6.nsdomain.COM.
a6.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa6.NSDOMAIN.com.
a6.nsdomain.com.86400INNSA6.nsdomain.com.
a6.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa6.nsdomain.com.
A7.NSDOMAIN.COM.86400IN2001::1001
a7.nsdomain.COM.86400IN2001::
a7.NSDOMAIN.com.86400INFEA0::
A7.nsdomain.com.86400INFE90::
a7.nsdomain.com.86400INFE80::
a7.nsdomain.com.86400INNSA7.NSDOMAIN.COM.
a7.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa7.nsdomain.COM.
a7.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa7.NSDOMAIN.com.
a7.nsdomain.com.86400INNSA7.nsdomain.com.
a7.nsdomain.com.86400INNSa7.nsdomain.com.
a8.nsdomain.com.0INNSns1.nu.moon.
a9.nsdomain.com.100INNSns1.nu.moon.
cname.nsdomain.com.86400INCNAMEnsdomain.com.
mx.nsdomain.com.86400INMX10 nsdomain.com.
net.nsdomain.com.86400INNSns3.dns.net.nsdomain.com.
net.nsdomain.com.86400INNSns2.dns.net.nsdomain.com.
net.nsdomain.com.86400INNSns1.dns.net.nsdomain.com.
ns1.dns.net.nsdomain.com.86400IN
2001:0DCE:2000:0002::::0130
ns1.dns.net.nsdomain.com.86400INA202.46.190.130
ns2.dns.net.nsdomain.com.86400IN
2001:0DCE:2000:0002::::0130
ns2.dns.net.nsdomain.com.86400INA202.46.191.130
ns3.dns.net.nsdomain.com.86400INA203.97.8.250
*;nsdomain.com.86400INNSns2.nsdomain.com.
;nsdomain.com.86400INNSns1.nsdomain.com.*
nsdomain.com.86400INNSdns2.dns.net.
nsdomain.com.86400INNSdns1.dns.net.
;End of file: 1285827330


Thanks & Regards,
Ramesh
___
bind-users mailing list
bind-users@lists.isc.org
https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind-users