Re: [boinc_dev] Plan classes for AMD GPUs

2010-12-14 Thread Richard Haselgrove
I don't think David was saying that only one model number can be handled per manufacturer - many user posts on many message boards would put the lie to that. He said that only one 'type' of GPU can be handled, which in turn I take to mean that only one can be specified per GPU brand. Provided

Re: [boinc_dev] Plan classes for AMD GPUs

2010-12-14 Thread Matt Arsenault
On Dec 11, 2010, at 5:50 PM, Raistmer wrote: >> From Lunatics beta thread: > " > Quote from: cenit on Today at 00:35:57 > Put for example that I have a HD 4870 and a HD 5870 in the same host, with a > unified app it would be easy to get full performances (with both app, I would > have to use th

Re: [boinc_dev] Plan classes for AMD GPUs

2010-12-14 Thread Raistmer
And if tomorrow some new brand will develop? What then? For example, in near future Intel will provide OpenCL support for their CPU+GPU chips. That is, new GPU vendor... IMHO, this support should be generalized to not require such deep hardcoding in BOINC. Abstract "compute device" model should

Re: [boinc_dev] Plan classes for AMD GPUs

2010-12-14 Thread Martin
On 14/12/10 22:19, David Anderson wrote: > BOINC can currently handle only 1 type of GPU per brand per host; > i.e. it can handle 1 type of NVIDIA GPU and 1 type of ATI GPU. > > Removing this restriction if possible but would be a > medium-large development project. Dang! So, does that mean that

Re: [boinc_dev] Plan classes for AMD GPUs

2010-12-14 Thread David Anderson
BOINC can currently handle only 1 type of GPU per brand per host; i.e. it can handle 1 type of NVIDIA GPU and 1 type of ATI GPU. Removing this restriction if possible but would be a medium-large development project. -- David On 14-Dec-2010 2:15 PM, Raistmer wrote: > And what about anonymous pla

Re: [boinc_dev] Plan classes for AMD GPUs

2010-12-14 Thread Raistmer
And what about anonymous platform? How can I define that one GPU requires one type of app and another GPU requires another app type? Project can have no GPU apps at all in general, but there can be third-party GPU apps... - Original Message - From: David Anderson To: boinc_dev@ssl.berk

Re: [boinc_dev] Plan classes for AMD GPUs

2010-12-14 Thread David Anderson
The plan class mechanism lets projects define their own plan classes, and they can use these to target app versions to specific GPU characteristics if they like. They don't need BOINC to define these plan classes for them. -- David On 11-Dec-2010 2:50 PM, Raistmer wrote: >> From Lunatics beta thre