Re: Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-13 Thread Tim Bell
> This is all as expected, although perhaps questionable style. > > Given Fredrik's comments too, are you ok with the changes? Thanks for the back-story on this corner of the build. I am fine with the changes. Tim

Re: Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-13 Thread Kelly O'Hair
On Mar 12, 2012, at 10:14 PM, Tim Bell wrote: > Hi Kelly > >> Need a reviewer for these build-infra changes to the strip properties >> utility in the corba repository. >> >> 7153266: Adjustments to corba strip property utility (neutral to builds) >> http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ohair/openjdk8/i

Re: Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-13 Thread Kelly O'Hair
The way properties files are handled in the jdk builds is inconsistent and this should be considered a bandaid until we get the common makefile logic up into the top repository and used by all lower level repositories. I recall making a change a long time ago to StripProperties.java to allow for

Re: Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-13 Thread Dmitry Samersoff
Frederik, > In the new build system, the StripProperties and CompileProperties > will be annotation processors inside the smart javac wrapper inside > langtools. Neat and clean. OK. Thank you! It probably much better than sed script with conditional changes. -Dmitry On 2012-03-13 13:47, Fredrik

Re: Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-13 Thread Fredrik Öhrström
2012-03-13 10:24, Dmitry Samersoff skrev: > Frederik, > > Just a curious - why we need a Java program here? > Could sed do the same with less efforts? In the old build system, there are two StripProperties.java in corba and in the jdk with slightly different implementations and command line option

Re: Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-13 Thread Dmitry Samersoff
Frederik, Just a curious - why we need a Java program here? Could sed do the same with less efforts? -Dmitry On 2012-03-13 13:08, Fredrik Öhrström wrote: > 2012-03-13 06:30, Tim Bell skrev: >> >> Sorry, I meant to pick on these lines, and also mention that >> args.length should be an even numbe

Re: Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-13 Thread Fredrik Öhrström
2012-03-13 06:30, Tim Bell skrev: > > Sorry, I meant to pick on these lines, and also mention that > args.length should be an even number at line 64... > > 107 infiles.add(args[i]); > 108 outfiles.add(args[i]); > > Otherwise, my remarks apply, FWIW. You are right,

Re: Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-12 Thread Tim Bell
I wrote: > I find this is a bit alarming - won't it overwrite the input file with > the output file? > >  120             String infile = inIter.next(); >  121             String outfile = outIter.next(); Sorry, I meant to pick on these lines, and also mention that args.length should be an even n

Re: Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-12 Thread Tim Bell
Hi Kelly > Need a reviewer for these build-infra changes to the strip properties utility > in the corba repository. > > 7153266: Adjustments to corba strip property utility (neutral to builds) > http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ohair/openjdk8/infra-corba/webrev/ Looks good overall. I find this is a

Need reviewer: corba changes for build infra

2012-03-12 Thread Kelly O'Hair
Need a reviewer for these build-infra changes to the strip properties utility in the corba repository. 7153266: Adjustments to corba strip property utility (neutral to builds) http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ohair/openjdk8/infra-corba/webrev/ -kto