Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Sean Moss-Pultz
On Tue, 2007-03-13 at 15:21 -0400, Mike wrote: This is open source development. So we developers aren't making money here. I for, one am NOT willing to pay $350 to get a device that I'm not sure will work with whatever service I choose, and therefore that I'm not sure I can even develop

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Sean Moss-Pultz
On Tue, 2007-03-13 at 20:14 +0100, Danijel Orsolic wrote: I hope you don't mind; I've copied your call for help here: http://www.mobiliberty.com/openmoko_needs_your_help And I submit it to a popular GNU/Linux news site. More exposure means greater chances of you finding the help you need.

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Lars Hallberg
hank williams skrev: On 3/13/07, *Gabriel Ambuehl* [EMAIL PROTECTED] mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Tuesday 13 March 2007 18:49:17 dimitris wrote: Sean, given the uncertainty surrounding Wifi drivers, would an externally-accessible SDIO slot be a better step for the

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Sean Moss-Pultz
On Wed, 2007-03-14 at 00:58 +0100, Robin Sonefors wrote: I have a much more important question, however: will the Neo work with european electrons, or will I need to import asian ones? If I'd need to import a new set of electrons to use for charging my battery every time it runs out, it'd

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Sean Moss-Pultz
On Tue, 2007-03-13 at 19:09 +0100, Gabriel Ambuehl wrote: On Tuesday 13 March 2007 18:49:17 dimitris wrote: Sean, given the uncertainty surrounding Wifi drivers, would an externally-accessible SDIO slot be a better step for the next hw revision? I would very much welcome a standard SD

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Mikko Rauhala
ke, 2007-03-14 kello 16:30 +0800, Sean Moss-Pultz kirjoitti: If you're seriously considering buying a Windows Mobile over something like a power adapter, which you could buy at any store for maybe 10 euro, this really is the wrong the device for you now. Sean, Sean, Sean, all the trolling

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Richard Bennett
On Wednesday 14 March 2007 09:30, Sean Moss-Pultz wrote: I have a much more important question, however: will the Neo work with european electrons, or will I need to import asian ones? If I'd need to import a new set of electrons to use for charging my battery every time it runs out,

I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :((

2007-03-14 Thread Robert Michel
Mike (or better everybody new to this project/list)! I'm in favor to welcome everybody on this list, to respect him and to help that his interest, effort and skills will be supported and answered that it is most efficent for him and the community. But as hard as I try to stay patient and

Re: I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :((

2007-03-14 Thread Jonathon Suggs
Robert Michel wrote: PS: Ahh, and when your aim is to sabotage openmoko (or someone would try it in your style) your noise will not stopp anybody here who is seriously active on/with openmoko - no it will/would strengthen the community. Yeah, through all that ranting I think I/we actually laid

Re: I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :((

2007-03-14 Thread Eric Heinemann
Guys/Gals, Cingular is not clear as to which data plan is the proper one to purchase for a specific phone. Some reps are well informed, while others are not. I currently have a Blackjack, and after 3 days of asking which is the proper plan I just decided to screw it and went with the

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Tim Shannon
I don't know about you guys, but even if I couldn't get a compatible plan, I'd probably buy the device anyway. A gorgeous, open Linux device backed by a community like this one? I think it's definitely worth the $350. On 3/14/07, Sean Moss-Pultz [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Tue, 2007-03-13 at

Re: I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :((

2007-03-14 Thread Jonathon Suggs
Eric Heinemann wrote: Guys/Gals, Cingular is not clear as to which data plan is the proper one to purchase for a specific phone. Some reps are well informed, while others are not. I currently have a Blackjack, and after 3 days of asking which is the proper plan I just decided to screw it

Thanks for all the WiFI help

2007-03-14 Thread Sean Moss-Pultz
Dear Community, A _huge_ thanks for all the feedback on this WiFi stuff! We've got some new leads now and will keep you all posted when we find one that meets our freedom requirements. ;-) -Sean ___ OpenMoko community mailing list

Re: I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :( (

2007-03-14 Thread Andreas Kostyrka
well the wap apn would make me suspicious if you'll get normal internet connectivity with it. But yes if it's only wap, and if the final version will include a wap browser, then yes, the Neo will work with the plan. OTOH you might something different than what you expect from it.

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Martin Lefkowitz
bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.openmoko.org/pipermail/community/attachments/20070314/0e25e775/gjordan.vcf -- ___ OpenMoko community mailing list community@lists.openmoko.org http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman

Re: I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :( (

2007-03-14 Thread Jonathon Suggs
Andreas Kostyrka wrote: well the wap apn would make me suspicious if you'll get normal internet connectivity with it. But yes if it's only wap, and if the final version will include a wap browser, then yes, the Neo will work with the plan. OTOH you might something different than what you

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Martin Lefkowitz
I did some research on Nanoradio for my employer. They have very good specs, actually the best I've seen for power. I'm not sure how mature the product is. Nowhere does it mention opensource. Marty Date: Tue, 13 Mar 2007 17:50:49 -0800 From: Steve Bibayoff [EMAIL PROTECTED] Hello, On

Re: I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :( (

2007-03-14 Thread Gabriel Ambuehl
On Wednesday 14 March 2007 16:07:25 Jonathon Suggs wrote: Andreas The wap APN does provide generic internet access. But the difference is that is uses a NAT'ed private IP address. Therefore you probably can't use it with a VPN (you would need PDA Connect if that is a requirement for you).

community issues (was: Crossroads)

2007-03-14 Thread Wolfgang S. Rupprecht
This Gogole training video showed up in slashdot a few days ago, but might be worth reposting here. The title is a bit on the nasty side, but the message itself is much more positive. Folks in other countries might want to edit the url's .com to point to their regional google and get a bit

Re: I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :( (

2007-03-14 Thread Andreas Kostyrka
That suggests that the isp apn does not use nat. If so that's cool. OTOH all (admittingly European carriers) do nat for internet access. OTOH the wap apns provide a walled garden that include a wap proxy that allows surfing http sites. Despite how many people associate internet==IE, having a

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Mike
Sean Moss-Pultz wrote: GSM should work just about anywhere. Maybe you could just tell us where you want to use this device? Plus you're really arguing for no reason. This thread was _us_ asking _you_ for help getting WiFi into this phone ;-) -Sean Sean, I did that in my thread What

Re: I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :( (

2007-03-14 Thread Joe Pfeiffer
NAT makes life harder for a VPN, but not impossible. The easiest case is if you've got a machine tucked away someplace that doesn't use NAT, you can use it as an openvpn server and have all the clients hidden behind NATed firewalls. That's actually what I do -- I've got an old machine under my

Re: I know why I dislike anonymous participants on mailinglists :( (

2007-03-14 Thread Andreas Kostyrka
* Gabriel Ambuehl [EMAIL PROTECTED] [070314 16:37]: On Wednesday 14 March 2007 16:07:25 Jonathon Suggs wrote: Andreas The wap APN does provide generic internet access. But the difference is that is uses a NAT'ed private IP address. Therefore you probably can't use it with a VPN (you

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Harald Welte
On Wed, Mar 14, 2007 at 08:01:08AM -0700, Martin Lefkowitz wrote: In my opinion, unless there is another company that can meet his requirements, the only real answer is to have an SDIO interface and let the end user/developer decide how to load a binary into the kernel from the chipset

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Mike
Harald Welte wrote: On Tue, Mar 13, 2007 at 03:21:06PM -0400, Mike wrote: What this has to do with wifi is covered in my last email. If I can't have wifi on the device, then I have to rely on the mobile service provider. If I have to rely on the mobile service provider, then I have to

Re: Call-for-WiFi (was Re: Crossroads)

2007-03-14 Thread Gabriel Ambuehl
On Wednesday 14 March 2007 16:34:48 Harald Welte wrote: I've added this (and some more info) to http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/WiFi_support_in_OpenMoko I've added a link to http://www.zcomax.com/1mbfile/G%20product/XG-880M_specification%20.pdf to the wiki. prplague on #openmoko is working on

RE: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Graham Auld
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Mike Sent: 14 March 2007 15:31 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: community@lists.openmoko.org; Scott Rushforth Subject: Re: Crossroads Sean Moss-Pultz wrote: GSM should work just about anywhere. Maybe you could

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Martin Lefkowitz
The Prism is not getting much traction in the market. The company has been bounced around from owner to owner. I would think that using the prism in a design would be very risky because the chip may not be around for the life of the product. Marty Date: Wed, 14 Mar 2007 16:55:49 +0100 From:

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Jonathon Suggs
Mike wrote: Thanks Harald, I'm out, I think I speak for us all when I say, Don't let the door hit ya where the good Lord split ya. ___ OpenMoko community mailing list community@lists.openmoko.org http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Wolfgang S. Rupprecht
Harald Welte [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Now if some of you ask yourself: But you're having binary-only GPS code! My answer is: 1) it's in userspace, and thus not a legal issue at all. Nobody argues that running Oracle on top of a Linux kernel is a GPL violation. No grey arae.

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Imre Kaloz
On Tue, 13 Mar 2007 18:52:56 +0100, jeff [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Imre Kaloz wrote: Atheros AR6K - check http://atheros.com/pt/AR6001Bulletins.htm , and for the fully GPL'ed driver and SDIO stack please check http://sourceforge.net/projects/sdio-linux/ I hardly think you will find a

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Harald Welte
On Wed, Mar 14, 2007 at 12:10:22PM -0400, Mike wrote: I had thought this would be like other third party electronics- like third party phone chargers for example- which do specify (and guarantee) what they'll work with. I guess not. I don't understand what is wrong about selling a device that

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Attila Csipa
On Wednesday 14 March 2007 17:10, Mike wrote: I had thought this would be like other third party electronics- like third party phone chargers for example- which do specify (and guarantee) what they'll work with. I guess not. Metaphorically speaking, you're looking at the wrong end of the

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Harald Welte
On Wed, Mar 14, 2007 at 09:51:37AM -0700, Martin Lefkowitz wrote: I disagree with that premise that it is a nasty legal area. Modules can be proprietary this is a fact. Not only have I been directly involved in the development of such, but have talked to people that did serious research

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Marcin Juszkiewicz
Dnia środa, 14 marca 2007, Mike napisał: If what you say is true, I can't imagine what the business case is for expensive third-party phones.  Here's a $350 device, good luck getting it to be useful. Pick a two year contract and cross your fingers. Expensive? Unlocked Nokia 6280 costs same

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Imre Kaloz
On Wed, 14 Mar 2007 17:51:37 +0100, Martin Lefkowitz [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I disagree with that premise that it is a nasty legal area. Modules can be proprietary this is a fact. Grey area, but hard to argue until they use any GPL code or symbol. If it were not then everybody would

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Martin Lefkowitz
I was not aware of your work in the legal area. It sounds like you are biting the hand that feeds you. If you succeed in getting companies afraid to be adding modules to a kernel for fear of having to expose their detailed register layout to the public either by documentation or code you will

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Marcin Juszkiewicz
Dnia środa, 14 marca 2007, Imre Kaloz napisał: On Wed, 14 Mar 2007 00:07:45 +0100, Grahame Jordan [EMAIL PROTECTED] What about the Marvell® 88W8385 module used on the wifistix Open source drivers can be found at http://gumstix.com No open source drivers for that either. If you check the

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Martin Lefkowitz
I just briefly took a look at the chip, and yes this does look different. They are doing what Marvell is doing, and what TI did, by finally embedding a controller on the device side. How much of the MAC is on that side is a good question. I assume they are still using the host for Scatter

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Joe Pfeiffer
Martin Lefkowitz writes: I was not aware of your work in the legal area. It sounds like you are biting the hand that feeds you. Please, I beg you, don't let this turn into a GPL license/closed firmware/other legal stuff thread. As has already been pointed out, these issues are debated daily, to

Re: [openmoko-announce] Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Harald Welte
On Wed, Mar 14, 2007 at 10:12:11AM -0700, Martin Lefkowitz wrote: I was not aware of your work in the legal area. It sounds like you are biting the hand that feeds you. I am not biting the hand that feeds me, but I am biting companies who knowingly and willingly disrespect both copyright law

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Andreas Kostyrka
* Harald Welte [EMAIL PROTECTED] [070314 19:02]: On Wed, Mar 14, 2007 at 12:10:22PM -0400, Mike wrote: I had thought this would be like other third party electronics- like third party phone chargers for example- which do specify (and guarantee) what they'll work with. I guess not. I

Idea: Datatransfer during conversation

2007-03-14 Thread Ole Tange
I am not sure if this idea is already described. When you have a conversation with another OpenMoko user you may want to transfer some data. It may be a business card or an URL or something similar. My idea is to have the smartphone send a synchronizing sound and then do the data transfer.

Idea: up-to-date business card

2007-03-14 Thread Ole Tange
If I receive a business card it sometimes happens I try to call a year later. At that point the person has a new phone number and I will have to look that up. I would much rather receive an intelligent business card that was always up to date. To secure anonymity we will need a protocol that

RE: Idea: up-to-date business card

2007-03-14 Thread Dean Collins
It's called Plaxo. Why reinvent the wheel, works great and is free. Regards, Dean Collins Cognation Pty Ltd [EMAIL PROTECTED] +1-212-203-4357 Ph -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:community- [EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Ole Tange Sent: Wednesday, 14 March 2007

Re: Idea: Datatransfer during conversation

2007-03-14 Thread Matthew S. Hamrick
Yup.. This is the vCard Bursting concept. One of the designs we're working on at the Homebrew Mobile Phone Club includes a mobile phone where the audio path goes through the apps processor so it can start sending data over the GSM voice channel. There's a little more info on that at:

Re: Idea: up-to-date business card

2007-03-14 Thread Matthew S. Hamrick
Yes... if you have a Blackberry, Treo or HTC phone, run Windows and don't mind keeping your data on Plaxo's servers, Plaxo is indeed a good solution. Still... I'm fairly certain that most GSM phones can't make the data call to the Plaxo servers _while_ they are on a voice call with

Device support / life (was: community issues)

2007-03-14 Thread Elrond
Hi all and Wolfgang, On Wed, Mar 14, 2007 at 08:12:48AM -0700, Wolfgang S. Rupprecht wrote: [...] The second cent is that many folks here are looking at the developer's phone as simply a way of getting the consumer's phone 6 months early. These people obviously have never used early rev.

Re: Idea: up-to-date business card

2007-03-14 Thread Matthew S. Hamrick
Yeah... this is called Meishi. I developed it while I was in Japan. The idea was that you put a unique bar code on the bottom of your business card. The code is essentially a serial number and URL to your online Meishi server MACed with a secret key you maintain. You give your business

Re: Idea: up-to-date business card

2007-03-14 Thread Jonathon Suggs
Matthew S. Hamrick wrote: Yes... if you have a Blackberry, Treo or HTC phone, run Windows and don't mind keeping your data on Plaxo's servers, Plaxo is indeed a good solution. Still... I'm fairly certain that most GSM phones can't make the data call to the Plaxo servers _while_ they are on a

RE: Idea: up-to-date business card

2007-03-14 Thread Dean Collins
Hi Matthew, You might want to have a chat to Scott Shaffer who writes a blog called The Pondering Primate. http://theponderingprimate.blogspot.com/ He goes nuts for that kind of stuff. Regards, Dean Collins Cognation Pty Ltd [EMAIL PROTECTED] +1-212-203-4357 Ph -Original Message-

OpenMoko external developers hits the 1000 mark!

2007-03-14 Thread Rod Whitby
By virtue of being able to track the IP addresses of people who download the MokoMakefile (a utility that makes it easy for new developers to set up an OpenMoko build environment), I can now report that (according to the download logs) over 1100 people at unique IP addresses have downloaded the

Re: Call-for-WiFi (was Re: Crossroads)

2007-03-14 Thread Ole Tange
On 3/14/07, Harald Welte [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: We absolutely need chipset (or even SMT module using the chipset) specifically designed for the power and size constraints of mobile phones or other equipment such as portable media players. Can you give some numbers for the power consumption

Re: Device support / life (was: community issues)

2007-03-14 Thread Andreas Kostyrka
* Elrond [EMAIL PROTECTED] [070314 21:14]: c) I really hope against and can't see the orphaning of older hardware. One thing that we should not forget, OpenMoko is a platform, that will support any number of phones in the future, so supporting different hardware revisions of the Neo

RE: Thanks for all the WiFI help

2007-03-14 Thread Ryan
Yeah, great work community! Its nice to see some positive forward movement in this area, as opposed to just discussion about not having a certain feature. Remember that we are a fairly large community at the moment, and while discussion may be great (sometimes) other times it can divert effort

Re: Crossroads

2007-03-14 Thread Sean Moss-Pultz
On Wed, 2007-03-14 at 12:57 +0200, Mikko Rauhala wrote: ke, 2007-03-14 kello 16:30 +0800, Sean Moss-Pultz kirjoitti: If you're seriously considering buying a Windows Mobile over something like a power adapter, which you could buy at any store for maybe 10 euro, this really is the wrong the