Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Edwin Lock
http://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/92713 Hello Openmokoers! This is actually the reason that I got to read about the openmoko, I read an article about mobile phones being bug-able some time ago and googled for an open linux phone. And I found the openmoko ;) Just a quick question, what the

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Ian Stirling
Edwin Lock wrote: http://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/92713 Hello Openmokoers! This is actually the reason that I got to read about the openmoko, I read an article about mobile phones being bug-able some time ago and googled for an open linux phone. And I found the openmoko ;) Just a quick

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Simon
http://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/92713 Sorry cant read deutsch (yet)... =) You realize the communication is going from your phone to a network to another phone, right? Usually the Mafia will put a bug locally in your house, your phone, etc... The police will bug the network through

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread David \Lefty\ Schlesinger
Okay, not to put too fine a point on it, but this is possibly the silliest reason ever for choosing one phone over another. Cell phone communications are transmitted via radio, and are trivial to eavesdrop on with the right equipment. If you're actually worried about this possibility (and I can't

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Ian Stirling
David Lefty Schlesinger wrote: Okay, not to put too fine a point on it, but this is possibly the silliest reason ever for choosing one phone over another. Cell phone communications are transmitted via radio, and are trivial to eavesdrop on with the right equipment. If you're actually worried

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Simon
and the phone being able to be remotely turned on without the users knowledge, to act as a bug. Would that be some sort of manipulation of private property ? ___ OpenMoko community mailing list community@lists.openmoko.org

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Lars Hallberg
David Lefty Schlesinger skrev: Okay, not to put too fine a point on it, but this is possibly the silliest reason ever for choosing one phone over another. Cell phone communications are transmitted via radio, and are trivial to eavesdrop on with the right equipment. I think the issue is if the

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Fabien
Just to (hopefully) clarify: I've read, probably from some very unreliable internet source, about a scheme where police make the carrier uploads an improved firmware over the air, which turns the phone into a microphone, even when not calling; it changes the shutdown function into a pretend to

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Rodolphe Ortalo
Le dimanche 15 juillet 2007 à 11:35 -0500, Simon a écrit : and the phone being able to be remotely turned on without the users knowledge, to act as a bug. Would that be some sort of manipulation of private property ? This notion of property of the phone could be manipulated too via

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Rodolphe Ortalo
Le dimanche 15 juillet 2007 à 18:46 +0200, Fabien a écrit : [...] Finally, you can't do anything against geolocation either: your carrier needs to know where you are in order to route calls to you, so state agencies can retrieve that information directly from the carrier, whatever your phone

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Fabien
On 7/15/07, Rodolphe Ortalo [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Technically yes. However, legally, they cannot do this *arbitrarily*. technically / legally / arbitrarily: technically it's doable, we agree; arbitrariness can be debatted in courts indeed, if you ever get to a court. But the main concern

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Ian Darwin
David Lefty Schlesinger wrote: (And you're using _gmail_? Wow.) Good one! ___ OpenMoko community mailing list community@lists.openmoko.org http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread David \Lefty\ Schlesinger
Lars Hallberg wrote: I think the issue is if the phone can bug *any* conversation You have when the phone is around, not only phone conversations. That is a valid concern. And I believe Neo can be safe if we make sure to use the mixer to turn of the mic/speaker connection to the gsm chip while

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Chris Kuethe
On 7/15/07, David Lefty Schlesinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm personally quite confident that if some government or other decides that they need to listen in on my conversations, my having a cellphone which won't cooperate with them isn't going to slow them down particularly. I'm also quite

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Edwin Lock
Thanks a lot for all the answers! My main point was if the state, well, anyone who had connections to the carriers, could turn the neo into a bug too.. And it seems that it isn't possible cause of the software mixer being off when the device is off :) And david? I use gmail, yes ;) Luckily I can

Re: Reason for openmoko - bugsafe?

2007-07-15 Thread Jeff Rush
Edwin Lock wrote: My main point was if the state, well, anyone who had connections to the carriers, could turn the neo into a bug too.. And it seems that it isn't possible cause of the software mixer being off when the device is off :) Actually one may want to implement this on the OpenMoko