Re: [computer-go] XML alternatives to SGF

2007-10-25 Thread William Shubert
I'm not an authority on SGF, but I am the owner of one of the larger SGF libraries (the KGS archives, 19,599,303 games as of this moment), and author one of the more common SGF editors (CGoban 3). Everybody wants something different from a SGF replacement. The syntax of SGF sucks, but once you

Re: [computer-go] XML alternatives to SGF

2007-10-25 Thread Stuart A. Yeates
I sat down and read the DTD and the documentation and have some direct feedback on it. I'm aware that the DTD is quite old, and some of the ideas and solutions I'm going to suggest might not have been available (or as popular) when the DTD was written. Lines starting with ! are quotes from the

[computer-go] SGF Utility

2007-10-25 Thread Phil Garcia
Hi! I put together a small utility that converts coordinate encodings in SGF files to/from the official SGF specification and normal Go board coordinates and optionally format the file to be easier to read. One of the cool uses is to convert a SGF file to standard Go board coordinates, make

RE: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread David Fotland
10 minutes per side should be enough for Many Faces 11. Version 11 has fixed search limits, and only does time management if it runs low on time. It can usually play a game in 10 minutes on the computer I'll use. It will be slower against Mogo since the games are longer and there might me more

[computer-go] MoGo

2007-10-25 Thread Joshua Shriver
Is MoGo a commercial or free program? Open or closed source? Linux version available? Thanks in advance :) -Josh ___ computer-go mailing list computer-go@computer-go.org http://www.computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go/

RE: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread David Fotland
I just tried it, but I can't connect. David -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Christoph Birk Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 1:16 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; computer-go Subject: Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS On Tue, 23 Oct 2007,

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread Jason House
On 10/25/07, David Fotland [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I just tried it, but I can't connect. That's expected. Past discussion seems to imply there's some kind of firewall (or similar) blocking external access. ___ computer-go mailing list

RE: [computer-go] XML alternatives to SGF

2007-10-25 Thread David Fotland
GMP (go modem protocol) was invented for direct computer to computer play using a 300 baud modem, before the internet existed. It was used in tournaments since it was easy to connect up serial ports to emulate modems. GTP solves a completely different problem, of go engines communicating with a

Re: [computer-go] MoGo

2007-10-25 Thread Chris Fant
Free, Closed, It prefers Linux. On 10/25/07, Joshua Shriver [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is MoGo a commercial or free program? Open or closed source? Linux version available? Thanks in advance :) -Josh ___ computer-go mailing list

Re: [computer-go] MoGo

2007-10-25 Thread Jason House
Free but closed source. There is a linux version, see http://www.lri.fr/~gelly/MoGo_Download.htm On 10/25/07, Joshua Shriver [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is MoGo a commercial or free program? Open or closed source? Linux version available? Thanks in advance :) -Josh

RE: [computer-go] XML alternatives to SGF

2007-10-25 Thread David Fotland
There is a standard file format like PGN for Go, that uses standard go notation. It's the Ishi Press Go Format used by the original Many Faces of go, and still supported by Many Faces. You might still find files out there with a .go extension. It was invented before sgf, but the go commuinity

RE: [computer-go] XML alternatives to SGF

2007-10-25 Thread David Fotland
Anders Kierulf, who created the sgf standard for the go program he wrote for his Ph.D thesis in 1990. Search for Smart Go to see his current go program. -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Jason House Sent: Thursday, October 25, 2007 11:45 AM

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread Don Dailey
Hi David, I argue that the matches should be longer, perhaps 30 minutes per side.They should more closely resemble time controls used in a serious competition. Here is the reason I say that.One could argue that with computers it doesn't matter, they do not need to be constrained as

Re: [computer-go] XML alternatives to SGF

2007-10-25 Thread Don Dailey
I tried to manually compose a JSON example to roughly match the xml example Stuart Yates gave. I don't know if I did it right because I'm not an expert on JSON although I've used it a little bit in javascript programming: { White: John Doe, Black: Fred Johnson, BoardSize: 19,

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread terry mcintyre
I'd argue that 30 minutes is a good compromise. Among humans, that would be a brisk pace but not blitz - common time controls are 60 or 90 minutes, and much longer for some pro tournaments. For computers, 30 minutes should give enough time to bump up the standard of play a few more kyu, while

RE: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread David Fotland
most computer-computer tournaments have used 1 hour per side, and did 5 or 6 rounds over 1 1/2 days. -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of David Fotland Sent: Thursday, October 25, 2007 1:04 PM To: 'computer-go' Subject: RE:

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread Don Dailey
I would prefer 1 hour actually, but it would take a really long time to get a substantial number of games in, so I think for practical reasons we shouldn't go that far. Unless we set up a special server just for Mogo vs ManyFaces. I could do that on my own computer. I'm not sure what

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread Olivier Teytaud
I'm not sure what the status of the 19x19 server is, if it looks like it isn't going to happen I have another option. Technically it works, but an authorization (for opening the ports for computers out of the laboratory) is still missing. But, if someone else wants to install it, no problem

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread Don Dailey
I think I'm going to restart CGOS 19x19 on boardspace. I'll ping the group when I'm ready - probably be tomorrow night. - Don Olivier Teytaud wrote: I'm not sure what the status of the 19x19 server is, if it looks like it isn't going to happen I have another option. Technically it

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread steve uurtamo
I'd still like to see handicap games between computers. Some programs, such as Mogo, dominate the field. Some are quite bad. Is the difference one or two stones, or is it nine or 27 stones? The handicap which gives something close to 50-50 ratio would give a useful idea. This would also

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread Christoph Birk
On Thu, 25 Oct 2007, Don Dailey wrote: I think I'm going to restart CGOS 19x19 on boardspace. I'll ping the group when I'm ready - probably be tomorrow night. Thanks. Christoph ___ computer-go mailing list computer-go@computer-go.org

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread Christoph Birk
On Fri, 26 Oct 2007, Hideki Kato wrote: I'd like to ask shorter time settings. How about a compromise of 20 minutes. That's 4 times the amount for 9x9 and (about) proportional to the area. Christoph ___ computer-go mailing list

Re: [computer-go] 19x19 CGOS

2007-10-25 Thread Don Dailey
Let me think about that one. How about 22 min 17 seconds per side? Just kidding. I once thought about setting up fast games on CGOS that ran in sync with slow games. The idea is that when a slow game is finished, you can play 1 or more fast games instead of waiting for the next round. I

Re: [computer-go] XML alternatives to SGF

2007-10-25 Thread Don Dailey
I saw this on the web a JSON library for C: JSON-C implements a reference counting object model that allows you to easily construct JSON objects in C, output them as JSON formatted strings and parse JSON formatted strings back into the C representation of JSON objects. I think I will change