[computer-go] Re: kartoffel on cgos

2008-07-26 Thread Hideki Kato
I'm afraid that kartoffel may cause some confusion on the ratings. I've set mogo-big-4c-nb-32 never resign but this will help little. I'd like to prefer every program never resign until the author of kartoffel fix the bug to prevent the ratings being corrupted. -Hideki John Fan: [EMAIL

Re: [computer-go] Re: kartoffel on cgos

2008-07-26 Thread Don Dailey
I don't think this has a very large impact on the rating pool. It's annoying, but it will all average out. No extra points are leaving or entering the rating pool as a result of this so this will not cause general inflation or deflation.It may cause a slight compression effect where

Re: [computer-go] Re: kartoffel on cgos

2008-07-26 Thread Hideki Kato
Don Dailey: [EMAIL PROTECTED]: I don't think this has a very large impact on the rating pool. It's annoying, but it will all average out. No extra points are leaving or entering the rating pool as a result of this so this will not cause general inflation or deflation.It may cause a

Re: [computer-go] Re: kartoffel on cgos

2008-07-26 Thread Don Dailey
I can't think of any really clever way to handle this. Here is about the best I can think of right now: Keep statistics on each program - how often it loses due to time or illegal moves. Use those statistics to reduce the impact of the rating formula. I could arrange it so that even

Re: [computer-go] Re: kartoffel on cgos

2008-07-26 Thread Hideki Kato
Don Dailey: [EMAIL PROTECTED]: I can't think of any really clever way to handle this. Here is about the best I can think of right now: Keep statistics on each program - how often it loses due to time or illegal moves. Use those statistics to reduce the impact of the rating formula. I

Re: [computer-go] Re: kartoffel on cgos

2008-07-26 Thread Raymond Wold
Don Dailey wrote: I can't think of any really clever way to handle this. Here is about the best I can think of right now: Keep statistics on each program - how often it loses due to time or illegal moves. Use those statistics to reduce the impact of the rating formula. I could

Re: [computer-go] Re: kartoffel on cgos

2008-07-26 Thread Raymond Wold
Don Dailey wrote: The utility of CGOS wouldn't change except for the better.The way it works is this: After each game: 1. The ill-behaved bot gets rated by the full formula. 2. The opponent of the ill-behaved bot gets a smaller adjustment than usual. Excellent, that makes