Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread Allen Firstenberg
On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 3:37 PM, Tony B wrote: > > Word definitions change, but generally "the cloud" refers to a bunch > of computers connected via network where your data is kept. It also > implies that there's no way of finding a specific copy of your data on > one hard drive; you really don't

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread phartz...@gmail.com
On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 4:40 PM, John Duncan Yoyo wrote: > The cloud means you really don't know where it is.  If your data is anywhere > nebulous it is in the cloud.   If you can't tell me where the drive is > physically located- it is in the cloud.  There is very little I could tell > where the

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread Tony B
I suppose, if I paid them enough. It's certainly *possible*, if somewhat unlikely. Unlike driving over to Carbonite and trying to take a hard drive with your backup on it. On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 4:36 PM, mike wrote: > So your host will let you walk into their server room and physically remove >

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread John Duncan Yoyo
The cloud means you really don't know where it is. If your data is anywhere nebulous it is in the cloud. If you can't tell me where the drive is physically located- it is in the cloud. There is very little I could tell where the server is and I mostly don't care where it is. It doesn't matter

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread mike
So your host will let you walk into their server room and physically remove the HD? On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 2:25 PM, Tony B wrote: > First, remember I pointed out I'm not completely sure if gmail via the > web is cloud-stored or not. Certainly if you use POP with gmail it's > not cloud. > > But n

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread Tony B
First, remember I pointed out I'm not completely sure if gmail via the web is cloud-stored or not. Certainly if you use POP with gmail it's not cloud. But now I think we're all on the same page. Your revised definition below is in line with my own. I could drive to my host and physically take the

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread Stewart Marshall
Depends. If it is data only you are supposed to have access to, but that is controlled by another entity (administration server etc.) that could qualify as cloud. I am presently using Drop Box (Thanks guys for sharing that place) and that is definitely cloud even though it appears on my deskt

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread mike
Seems a distinction without a difference. Or at very list the splitting of very fine hairs. How is it your website is not in the cloud but gmail is? What is the difference? I can download an app that basically allows me to FTP files to my gmail account...when I run this app does that mean it is

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread Tony B
No, data on a remote server is definitely *not* in a cloud. I mean, my website is on a remote server which is on a shared host so I don't administer the server. But if I FTP a file to it, I haven't put the file in a cloud. On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 3:09 PM, Stewart Marshall wrote: > In that it is a

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread Tony B
No, it most certainly is not. Thanks for helping to clarify. Word definitions change, but generally "the cloud" refers to a bunch of computers connected via network where your data is kept. It also implies that there's no way of finding a specific copy of your data on one hard drive; you really do

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread Stewart Marshall
In that it is a remote server administrated by someone other than you yes. Stewart At 01:50 PM 12/9/2009, you wrote: Okay. However, Classmates.com, being accessible by users only by way of the internet is, in fact, in and of the "cloud," is it not? I stand ready to be corrected. Steve

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread phartz...@gmail.com
On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 1:43 PM, Tony B wrote: > Anyway, after the thread got bumped for a few days I just thought I > would comment on the subject header, and point out that we really > don't know if classmates.com *uses* cloud storage. Okay. However, Classmates.com, being accessible by users

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not

2009-12-09 Thread Tony B
No. You have misinterpreted my point completely. I am unfamiliar with what was lost because as soon as I saw it was a question about classmates.com I knew I know nothing about them so I stopped reading. Would that more people on this list did the same! Anyway, after the thread got bumped for a fe

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not was: The "Cloud" stole her data...

2009-12-09 Thread phartz...@gmail.com
On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 12:10 PM, Tony B wrote: > This is a very misleading subject line, as we have no evidence or > indication that this data was stored in a cloud. Thus we also have no > evidence it was a failure of cloud storage that caused information > loss. > > I just worry a couple of the

Re: [CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not was: The "Cloud" stole her data...

2009-12-09 Thread Stewart Marshall
It is in realty loosing your data to a data aggregator. Classmates.com gets data in from every classmate that registers and then aggregates that date for everyone to see. They are a for profit company wanting you to register and pay them money for all this stuff to be seen. The cloud is mo

[CGUYS] Maybe, maybe not was: The "Cloud" stole her data...

2009-12-09 Thread Tony B
This is a very misleading subject line, as we have no evidence or indication that this data was stored in a cloud. Thus we also have no evidence it was a failure of cloud storage that caused information loss. I just worry a couple of the luddites on the list will actually reference this event in t