Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-14 Thread Jeff Weaver
This is an amazing project, and it will be very exciting to see what comes from the data. Do you know how you will make it available? One thing that would be really interesting to publicize is what people say is important to their voting decisions and study if that affects how others vote: if

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-13 Thread Kishore Mandyam
Thejesh, great questions. Here are some answers. 1. Physical because our intent is to get the opinion of aam janta. And less than 10% of them have Internet connections. The biases in only-online surveys is unbelievable. 2. Non-OCR for Hindi was an operational decision that some of our surveying

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-13 Thread Sutirtha Roy
Hi Kishore: Thanks for sharing this information. It will be very interesting to see the results that emerge from this exercise. I like the way you stated the problem: impact of having over 2.5 lakh people discussing these issues with their friends and family will be significant, we believe, in

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-13 Thread Kishore Mandyam
Sutirtha, I don't think your question is vague at all: it is one of the issues we ourselves wrestled with last year. We did attempt this exercise in Karnataka: to map the issues from our surveys with the issues discussed (or even raised as questions) by MLAs. Unfortunately, we were unable to find

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-13 Thread Meera
At a Bangalore level (3 MPs), We (Citizen Matters) are trying to map the questions and perhaps the debates as something directly relevant to the constituents or not. Will keep you posted on that. Meanwhile, we got some details of the MPLADs expenditure data for the Bangalore MPs - available on

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-11 Thread Kishore Mandyam
Thanks, Neependra! On 11-Feb-2014 4:18 PM, Neependra Khare neependra.kh...@gmail.com wrote: On Mon, Feb 10, 2014 at 11:06 AM, Kishore (Narasimhan) Mandyam kish...@dakshindia.org wrote: Daksh is currently conducting a Nationwide in-field survey about people's perceptions about their MPs.

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-10 Thread Venkata Pingali
Ok. I may have misread earlier note. It may help to share the questionnaire. That may give people ideas as well. On Mon, Feb 10, 2014 at 1:54 PM, Kishore (Narasimhan) Mandyam kish...@dakshindia.org wrote: Venkata, maybe I was not clear earlier: the survey is already underway and will be

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-10 Thread Srinivasan Ramani
Some thoughts - * The survey of 2.5 lakh would certainly be exhaustive but I personally feel it could be over-done. Sampling can be somewhat lesser than that to yield more focussed results (for easier post-survey processing, I suppose). * But that said, the survey could seek to not to fully

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-10 Thread Kishore (Narasimhan) Mandyam
Nisha, no problems messing up my name - I'm already used to that with my other one (Narasimhan) :) By 15 Mar, the survey would be complete and the data will all be in, so yes, we could play with it at the ODC. We can talk once you've had a chance to review the questionnaire. Kishore.

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-10 Thread Srinivasan Ramani
Dear Kishore, Thanks for the clarifications. Perhaps relatedly, one point I think you could lay emphasis on is to not to discard those outliers. As this paper by K K Kailash emphasizes, there is a social story that those outliers could tell -

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-09 Thread Venkata Pingali
Couple of thoughts: 1. We can ask about origin/hometown. This can help us understand urbanization process. 2. Will the data be public information? Who is the sponsor of this initiative? On Mon, Feb 10, 2014 at 11:06 AM, Kishore (Narasimhan) Mandyam kish...@dakshindia.org wrote: Daksh is

Re: [datameet] What kinds of things could we do with Daksh 2014 MP Constituency data?

2014-02-09 Thread Venkata Pingali
Thanks for clarifying. Sounds like a good opportunity to link up ODC and ADR (ref: upcoming ODC meeting with elections as focus). Thej/Nisha would know more. Urbanization can be look at both from stock (where are people) and flows (what is the dynamics). In addition to asking their current area