Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-25 Thread blais...@gmail.com
Be careful about SnappyHexMesh. You can use it to make hex-only meshes, but it will generate a tesselated mesh (which does not really conform to the boundary, it is by all means a voxel mesh). If you fully use Snappy, it will generate a polyhedral mesh with as many as 20 faces per element. This

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-25 Thread Jean-Paul Pelteret
Oh, and and just in case you’ve not heard of it before and it might be useful, there’s also this tool that does automated hex meshing: https://www.openfoam.com/documentation/guides/latest/doc/guide-meshing-snappyhexmesh.html

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-25 Thread Jean-Paul Pelteret
Since you have access to Cubit/Trellis, “that patch” is probably not necessary. Cubit uses the Mesquite library for mesh quality improvement, so if you could try to increase the mesh quality that way. Although I’d have to agree with Wolfgang that it might not help too much in this case, but

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-25 Thread Wolfgang Bangerth
On 9/25/20 4:58 AM, Paras Kumar wrote: In the quest of alternative solutions, I came across the Mesquite library and was curious to know if that could be helpful to improve the quality of the Delaunay based Hex mesh so as to avoid the issue with stress irregularities. It also seems that

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-25 Thread Paras Kumar
Dear Prof. Bangerth, Thank you for the appreciation. In the quest of alternative solutions, I came across the Mesquite library and was curious to know if that could be helpful to improve the quality of the Delaunay based Hex mesh so as to avoid the issue with stress irregularities. It also

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-23 Thread Timo Heister
I am coming late to the conversation (and I only looked at it quickly, sorry), but I have two additional suggestions: 1. Depending on the deformation of cells and the PDE in question, it might be important to check if the quadrature degree is high enough to not contribute to the overall error.

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-22 Thread Wolfgang Bangerth
On 9/22/20 4:27 PM, Wolfgang Bangerth wrote: I wished every student project were as comprehensively explored! :-) I tacitly assumed that Maurice Rohracker is your student. I didn't mean to imply that the work you're doing is at the "student level" -- quite the contrary: What your reports

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-22 Thread Wolfgang Bangerth
On 9/22/20 11:09 AM, Paras Kumar wrote: In order to verify if the "improper" modeling of the curved particle surface due to the reason you explained above, is the cause for this irregularities, we tried with a cubic particle, thereby eliminating the above issue, but still observe

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-22 Thread Wolfgang Bangerth
On 9/22/20 10:41 AM, Paras Kumar wrote: As can be seen in figures 7 & 8 of the attached report, a further refinement results in relatively smoother contours, but the irregularities are still not eliminated. OK, that's good to know at least as a check that your program is doing something

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-09 Thread Wolfgang Bangerth
On 9/9/20 12:31 PM, Paras Kumar wrote: This does not say anything about the *absolute level of accuracy*. I would not be surprised if for a mesh like the one you show (in which pretty much every hexahedron is poorly shaped), the solution is less than for the corresponding

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-09 Thread blais...@gmail.com
Dear Paras, I have faced a lot of similar issues in the past and maybe these suggestions can help (or maybe not). 1. Generally visual rendering software (at least paraview) renders data on quad/hex meshes using triangular polygons. Consequently, when you look at the color map within a square,

Re: [deal.II] Issue with unstructured hex mesh

2020-09-08 Thread Wolfgang Bangerth
Paras, I am working on homogenization of particulate nano-composites and thus have to solve the finite deformation quasistatics problem on different microstructures, such as one shown in the attachment pic-1.png. In order to automate the generation of (2D & 3D) meshes for microstructures