Bug#340433: Current status of GEANT-FLUKA code in Debian

2006-01-16 Thread Kevin B. McCarty
Dear Dr. Ferrari,

I am happy to be able to inform you that the GEANT-FLUKA code you told
me about in the Debian packages of CERNLIB has finally been completely
removed from the testing and unstable distributions of Debian
GNU/Linux (also known as Etch and Sid, respectively).  The delay was
due to backlogs on some of the computers that automatically build
packages for different architectures.

I have just prepared packages of CERNLIB that will also remove the
GEANT-FLUKA code from the current stable distribution of Debian,
code-named Sarge, and I have uploaded the packages to
stable-proposed-updates.  Unlike the case with the testing and
unstable distributions, I have no control over whether or not these
new packages will be accepted.  We will just have to wait and hope that
the stable release manager will accept them for the next point release
of Sarge.

If I correctly understand your previous comment,

 As explained in the CERNLIB disclaimers those files are permitted to 
 be used with GEANT321. So no problem on that and no hurry to remove.
 The issue is that they are not GPL licensed and I understand this is
 not what you want (a mixture of GPL and different, not compatible
 licenses) for obvious reasons.

then you do not have a problem with Debian continuing to distribute the
code in question while we wait for the release manager's decision.
Thank you for your patience and understanding about this issue!

best regards,

-- 
Kevin B. McCarty [EMAIL PROTECTED]   Physics Department
WWW: http://www.princeton.edu/~kmccarty/Princeton University
GPG: public key ID 4F83C751 Princeton, NJ 08544


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Bug#340433: Current status of GEANT-FLUKA code in Debian

2006-01-16 Thread Alfredo Ferrari

Dear Kevin

thanks a lot for your efforts!

yes, you interpreted correctly that distributing those files together
with Geant3 is permitted: the only issue is that they are not GPL'ed
and their license (actually an use agreement between my previous 
Institution and CERN) explicitly forbids any use outside Geant3 and/or

modifications.

Thanks again for your help!

  Best regards
 Alfredo Ferrari

On Mon, 16 Jan 2006, Kevin B. McCarty wrote:


Dear Dr. Ferrari,

I am happy to be able to inform you that the GEANT-FLUKA code you told
me about in the Debian packages of CERNLIB has finally been completely
removed from the testing and unstable distributions of Debian
GNU/Linux (also known as Etch and Sid, respectively).  The delay was
due to backlogs on some of the computers that automatically build
packages for different architectures.

I have just prepared packages of CERNLIB that will also remove the
GEANT-FLUKA code from the current stable distribution of Debian,
code-named Sarge, and I have uploaded the packages to
stable-proposed-updates.  Unlike the case with the testing and
unstable distributions, I have no control over whether or not these
new packages will be accepted.  We will just have to wait and hope that
the stable release manager will accept them for the next point release
of Sarge.

If I correctly understand your previous comment,


As explained in the CERNLIB disclaimers those files are permitted to
be used with GEANT321. So no problem on that and no hurry to remove.
The issue is that they are not GPL licensed and I understand this is
not what you want (a mixture of GPL and different, not compatible
licenses) for obvious reasons.


then you do not have a problem with Debian continuing to distribute the
code in question while we wait for the release manager's decision.
Thank you for your patience and understanding about this issue!

best regards,




--

++
|  Alfredo Ferrari||  Tel.: +41.22.767.6119  |
|  CERN-AB||  Fax.: +41.22.767.7555  |
|  1211 Geneva 23 ||  e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]|
|  Switzerland||  [EMAIL PROTECTED] |
++


--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]