Re: 4-26-2020 update on Kubernetes Operator

2020-04-27 Thread Deepak Vohra
I have added a potential Goal to CEP-2:Deploying and managing Kubernetes resources depends a lot on the Cloud Service provider used. Is it a goal to target  integration with any/all/some Cloud Service providers??? On Monday, April 27, 2020, 04:33:45 p.m. UTC, Stefan Miklosovic wrote:

Re: Google Season of Docs 2020 participation

2020-04-27 Thread Deepak Vohra
It may be early, but  considering  first an organization has to apply, and as I am familiar with what sections of documentation could be improved, I have a few suggestions. Only two projects (1 and 2 of 5 listed) were completed in 2019, and GSoD expects only one project to be completed.

Google Season of Docs 2020 participation

2020-04-27 Thread Dinesh Joshi
Folks, GSoD 2020 is upon us. The organizational applications are due soon May 4th 2020 and I'd like us to participate in it again. GSoD 2019 brought in great deal of improvements to the C* docs and I believe GSoD 2020 will be able to bring in more enhancements. I realize we are also talking

Re: DataStax Driver Donation to Apache Cassandra Project

2020-04-27 Thread Nate McCall
Thanks, Stephen, this is really helpful! On Tue, Apr 28, 2020 at 6:24 AM Stephen Mallette wrote: > > > > To step out of the weeds a bit - other than the Zookeeper / Curator > > example, does anyone know of any other apache projects that have either > > subprojects or complementary sideprojects

Re: DataStax Driver Donation to Apache Cassandra Project

2020-04-27 Thread Stephen Mallette
> > To step out of the weeds a bit - other than the Zookeeper / Curator > example, does anyone know of any other apache projects that have either > subprojects or complementary sideprojects they're interdependent upon in > their ecosystems? Every Apache project is different, so it's quite

Re: DataStax Driver Donation to Apache Cassandra Project

2020-04-27 Thread Jon Haddad
Separate JIRA is enough enough, separate dev list.. maybe. I don't see much purpose in trying to organize into a hierarchy, what problem are you actually solving here? It sounds like you don't trust folks who work on the driver to not commit random code to Cassandra, is that the case? If that's

Re: DataStax Driver Donation to Apache Cassandra Project

2020-04-27 Thread Benedict Elliott Smith
+1, this is essentially my position, and I agree with the baseline requirements for a merged project. I'm not trying to rule anything out, just wondering what the optimal division is. I think from the user point of view we can hopefully achieve the same appearance with or without the same

Re: DataStax Driver Donation to Apache Cassandra Project

2020-04-27 Thread Joshua McKenzie
To step out of the weeds a bit - other than the Zookeeper / Curator example, does anyone know of any other apache projects that have either subprojects or complementary sideprojects they're interdependent upon in their ecosystems? I'd like to reach out to some other pmc's for advice and feedback

Re: DataStax Driver Donation to Apache Cassandra Project

2020-04-27 Thread Joshua McKenzie
re: ML noise, how hard would it be to filter out JIRA updates w/component "Drivers"? Or from JIRA queries? For governance, I see it cutting both ways. If we have two separate projects and ML's for drivers and C*, how do we keep a coherent view of new features and roadmap stuff? Do we have CEP's

Re: DataStax Driver Donation to Apache Cassandra Project

2020-04-27 Thread Dinesh Joshi
> On Apr 27, 2020, at 2:50 AM, Sylvain Lebresne wrote: > > Fwiw, I agree with the concerns raised by Benedict, and think we should > carefully think about how this is handled. Which isn't not a rejection of > the donation in any way. > > Drivers are not small projects, and the majority of

Re: 4-26-2020 update on Kubernetes Operator

2020-04-27 Thread Stefan Miklosovic
Hi Deepak, while we would be delighted to take Instaclustr's operator as a baseline, this is not so simple ... I think we should gather all functional requirements first, improve and complete the actual CEP and based on these facts we should distil the best solution, whatever it would be. In

Re: 4-26-2020 update on Kubernetes Operator

2020-04-27 Thread Eric Evans
On Mon, Apr 27, 2020 at 2:30 AM Dinesh Joshi wrote: > Hi Patrick, > > Thanks for driving the meetings. It would be good to have the on going > discussions on the dev list for people in time zones that cannot attend the > meetings in real time. > +1 I would never (try to) tell anyone that they

Re: 4-26-2020 update on Kubernetes Operator

2020-04-27 Thread Deepak Vohra
An operator for Apache Cassandra in alpha is provided by Instaclustr that supports StatefulSet, scaling and monitoring. Could it be used as the base operator to build on? OperatorHub.io | The registry for Kubernetes Operators | | | | OperatorHub.io | The registry for Kubernetes Operators

Re: DataStax Driver Donation to Apache Cassandra Project

2020-04-27 Thread Sylvain Lebresne
Fwiw, I agree with the concerns raised by Benedict, and think we should carefully think about how this is handled. Which isn't not a rejection of the donation in any way. Drivers are not small projects, and the majority of their day to day maintenance is unrelated to the server (and the reverse

Re: DataStax Driver Donation to Apache Cassandra Project

2020-04-27 Thread Mick Semb Wever
> > - How will we run CI for these contributions? > > > > ASF Jenkins/CircleCI works? Do the drivers have specific needs beyond this? > > > That will probably work. I asked partially because the driver CI can have > a fairly extensive matrix of platforms, runtimes, and server versions. I'm > not

Re: 4-26-2020 update on Kubernetes Operator

2020-04-27 Thread Dinesh Joshi
Hi Patrick, Thanks for driving the meetings. It would be good to have the on going discussions on the dev list for people in time zones that cannot attend the meetings in real time. Dinesh > On Apr 26, 2020, at 10:49 PM, Patrick McFadin wrote: > > *Hi everyone,Over the past two weeks, we