Yes, I meant of those tickets we agreed at ApacheCon a year ago, blocking at
most GA seems reasonable - roughly in accordance with what Benjamin was saying.
Not that the entire codebase should be brought up to our preferred standards
before any new releases are cut. I'm also not opposed to
>
> As an aside, I disagree about this blocking GA. We have a decade or so of
> debt and this is essentially a category without a ceiling. Under this
> umbrella we could feasibly delay 4.0 for another multiple years.
I do not think that anybody wants to delay 4.0 more than needed.
Now, nothing
>
> - Anticipated not to find serious bugs (e.g. old unchanged but poorly
> tested features): Block GA
As an aside, I disagree about this blocking GA. We have a decade or so of
debt and this is essentially a category without a ceiling. Under this
umbrella we could feasibly delay 4.0 for another
After a little bit of investigation, it turns out that we can't bring v5 out of
beta in 3.11 as there are already a number of v5 features which 3.11 doesn't
support. This necessarily couples the C*, protocol and driver versions. For
instance, java driver 3.0.x is able to support v5 with 3.11,
Reasonable categories. We haven't discussed what qualifies where for 4.0
have we? (new lacking | changed modest | old lacking)
On Fri, Dec 11, 2020 at 9:14 AM Benedict Elliott Smith
wrote:
> In my opinion...
>
> - Expected to find serious bugs (e.g. new poorly tested features): Block
> beta
> -
In my opinion...
- Expected to find serious bugs (e.g. new poorly tested features): Block beta
- Anticipated to possibly find serious bugs (e.g. extensively changed features
with modest testing): Block RC
- Anticipated not to find serious bugs (e.g. old unchanged but poorly tested
features):
It looks like my question raised more questions than I had in mind.
1. What is the meaning of the fix version?
2. When do we move from beta to RC?
3. Where does the Quality tickets fit in all that?
*What is the meaning of the fix version?*
It looks like we should just pick a definition and
