Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-29 Thread Chris Brody
I think we have consensus now to start dropping support for Android 4.4 & 5.0, minimum is now 5.1. Reasoning and explanations are clear to me, seem to be clear to others. I think we would go through the normal process on GitHub, which we know to be a major breaking change. Switching the browser

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Norman Breau
I think ES6 is a legit concern. The only way I think we can use ES6 features and *guarantee* there will work for all users is if we use a transpiler such as babel to convert es6 syntax to es3, or whatever the minimum we believe to be safe. So simply dropping 4.4 and 5.0 doesn't mean we can

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Gearoid M
+1 on setting the minimum to 5.1 Personally, I always set the minimum for my own apps to 5.1 anyway as React doesn't work on 5.0 or below without polyfills On Tue, 28 Jan 2020, at 16:27, julio cesar sanchez wrote: > I like the "we officially support SDK 22, SDK 21 might work", I'm +1 on SDK >

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread julio cesar sanchez
I like the "we officially support SDK 22, SDK 21 might work", I'm +1 on SDK 22 then But for ES6, I think that's a bigger problem. Android 5+ is supposed to have the updatable webview, but that's not always true, some vendors didn't implement it for some reason. Also, even if implemented, users

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Bryan Ellis
My primary view for dropping 5.0 was also based off of low usage. Obviously there will always be vulnerabilities. The CVE list showed a dropped from 5.0.0 to 5.0.2 but an increase again in 5.1. This, of course, will always be expected on minor and major releases. It was also known that 5.0 has a

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Jesse
+1 to drop everything before 5.1 > On Jan 28, 2020, at 7:53 AM, Chris Brody wrote: > > +1 to drop Android 4.4 support > >> Do we have a reason for 5.1 instead of 5.0 other than the low usage? >> >> Originally, I was thinking 5.0+, but after seeing low usage, I leaned >> over to 5.1. So low

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Chris Brody
+1 to drop Android 4.4 support > Do we have a reason for 5.1 instead of 5.0 other than the low usage? > > Originally, I was thinking 5.0+, but after seeing low usage, I leaned > over to 5.1. So low usage was my primary reasoning for my +1. +1 to drop 5.0 and +1 on the reasoning here I don't

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Norman Breau
Do we have a reason for 5.1 instead of 5.0 other than the low usage? Originally, I was thinking 5.0+, but after seeing low usage, I leaned over to 5.1. So low usage was my primary reasoning for my +1. On 2020-01-28 11:32 a.m., julio cesar sanchez wrote: +1 for dropping Android 4.4 since it

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread julio cesar sanchez
+1 for dropping Android 4.4 since it doesn't have updatable webview and it's a pain to maintain such old chromium version Do we have a reason for 5.1 instead of 5.0 other than the low usage? El mar., 28 ene. 2020 a las 16:13, Norman Breau () escribió: > +1 to drop Android 4.4 - 5.0. > +1 to

Re: [PROPOSAL] Drop Android 4.4 Support

2020-01-28 Thread Norman Breau
+1 to drop Android 4.4 - 5.0. +1 to support Android >= 5.1 On 2020-01-28 10:59 a.m., Bryan Ellis wrote: I would like to open the discussion and vote to *drop Android 4.4 (KitKat) support* in the upcoming next major release. As of Dec 2019, Stat Counter reports that the *market share for