Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-28 Thread Karl Pauls
Yes, I will call a vote now. regards, Karl On Tue, Jan 28, 2020 at 9:33 PM Thomas Watson wrote: > > With Karl's help we have now updated Atomos to be able to use a build of > the Felix Framework that implements OSGi Connect. I have not yet figured > out how to automate running the junit tests

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-28 Thread Thomas Watson
With Karl's help we have now updated Atomos to be able to use a build of the Felix Framework that implements OSGi Connect. I have not yet figured out how to automate running the junit tests on both Equinox and Felix with Atomos just yet. But Atomos now has a substrate example using Equinox and

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-24 Thread Mark Raynsford
On 2020-01-23T09:08:40 -0600 Thomas Watson wrote: > > 2) Using the Java module path - Atomos will discover all modules in the > Module Layer hierarchy and represent them as installed bundles. This > includes modules that have bundle manifests as well as ones that do not. > This also extends to

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Karl Pauls
I updated the implementation in my sandbox to the latest interfaces. I guess I'll have to try them with Atomos next :-) regards, Karl On Thu, Jan 23, 2020 at 4:25 PM Karl Pauls wrote: > > I have an implementation based on the original interfaces in my sandbox. > >

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Jean-Baptiste Onofré
Definitely +1 for me. Regards JB On 23/01/2020 16:08, Thomas Watson wrote: > Hi, > > The OSGI R8 Core specification is currently being worked on by the OSGi > Alliance. One of the proposals is to add something called OSGi Connect to > the Core Framework specification [1] [2]. > > This

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Pierre De Rop
thanks Karl, Thomas for the clarifications, I'll give a try. regards Pierre On Thu, Jan 23, 2020 at 5:55 PM Thomas Watson wrote: > The idea for OSGi Connect specification is that the Framework itself does > not need to support Graal native image bundles. However, something like > Atomos which

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Thomas Watson
The idea for OSGi Connect specification is that the Framework itself does not need to support Graal native image bundles. However, something like Atomos which provides a ConnectFramework to launch a Framework implementation with can support loading bundles from a Graal native image. But that also

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Karl Pauls
On Thu, Jan 23, 2020 at 5:42 PM Pierre De Rop wrote: > > +1 from me as well. > > I'm also very interested. > I did not know that Karl also worked on implementing the OSGi Connect RFC. Well, Tom and I sort of started it together and the initial interfaces actually are from Felix. > Karl, will it

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Pierre De Rop
+1 from me as well. I'm also very interested. I did not know that Karl also worked on implementing the OSGi Connect RFC. Karl, will it also support class loading from a Graal Substrate native image environment ? I ask this because I'm currently trying to adapt the Felix Connect ([1]) for the

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Richard S. Hall
Sounds reasonable to me. -> richard On 1/23/20 10:08 AM, Thomas Watson wrote: Hi, The OSGI R8 Core specification is currently being worked on by the OSGi Alliance. One of the proposals is to add something called OSGi Connect to the Core Framework specification [1] [2]. This specification

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread David Bosschaert
+1 from me to the contribution. Cheers, David On Thu, 23 Jan 2020 at 15:26, Karl Pauls wrote: > I have an implementation based on the original interfaces in my sandbox. > > http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/felix/sandbox/pauls/connect/ > > It needs to be updated to the new interfaces which

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Karl Pauls
I have an implementation based on the original interfaces in my sandbox. http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/felix/sandbox/pauls/connect/ It needs to be updated to the new interfaces which shouldn't be too hard. I should have that done soon. regards, Karl On Thu, Jan 23, 2020 at 4:23 PM Carsten

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Carsten Ziegeler
Hi Tom, sounds great to me. Afaik, the Felix framework does currently not implement OSGi connect. I guess in order to experience atomos with the Felix framework this work would need to be done as well. Are there any plans? Regards Carsten On 23.01.2020 16:08, Thomas Watson wrote: Hi, The

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Neil Bartlett
I agree, this would be a very good thing. Neil On Thu, 23 Jan 2020 at 15:21, Raymond Auge wrote: > Great idea! > > +1 > > - Ray > > On Thu, Jan 23, 2020 at 10:09 AM Thomas Watson wrote: > > > Hi, > > > > The OSGI R8 Core specification is currently being worked on by the OSGi > > Alliance.

Re: [DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Raymond Auge
Great idea! +1 - Ray On Thu, Jan 23, 2020 at 10:09 AM Thomas Watson wrote: > Hi, > > The OSGI R8 Core specification is currently being worked on by the OSGi > Alliance. One of the proposals is to add something called OSGi Connect to > the Core Framework specification [1] [2]. > > This

[DISCUSS] Contribute Atomos to Apache Felix

2020-01-23 Thread Thomas Watson
Hi, The OSGI R8 Core specification is currently being worked on by the OSGi Alliance. One of the proposals is to add something called OSGi Connect to the Core Framework specification [1] [2]. This specification takes much of its initial inspiration from the current Felix Connect/PojoSR project.