Re: Car plugin is fighting with maven too much

2006-12-15 Thread Donald Woods
Message- From: David Jencks [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Thu, 14 Dec 2006 10:51:41 To:Geronimo Dev List (JIRA) dev@geronimo.apache.org Subject: Car plugin is fighting with maven too much Ever since we got close to having an m2 build we've been having problems with the car plugin overloading

Car plugin is fighting with maven too much

2006-12-14 Thread David Jencks
Ever since we got close to having an m2 build we've been having problems with the car plugin overloading the maven scopes to mean something in geronimo. This has caused endless problems, the latest of which is that in order to be able to use the car plugin outside geronimo, you have to

Re: Car plugin is fighting with maven too much

2006-12-14 Thread Guillaume Nodet
I'm not completely aware of what the car plugin do, but I think this is pretty close to what we have done for servicemix. I think we should be able to get back transitive dependencies on jars, by rebuilding the full dependency graph, and excluding artifacts that are already included by referenced

Re: Car plugin is fighting with maven too much

2006-12-14 Thread Aaron Mulder
I just want to add that for Geronimo plugins, it's not very useful to have the car-maven-plugin write the environment into the deployment plan. More often that not, you want the source tree to contain a fully valid and correct deployment plan, so you can easily redeploy the module (e.g. on the

Re: Car plugin is fighting with maven too much

2006-12-14 Thread Guillaume Nodet
Just a side note. It took me some time to understand that you *have* to build Geronimo if you want to build a plugin against a SNAPSHOT version. The reason is that the plugin loads cars that depend on snapshot jars (it works against the new 1.2beta). But if you download snapshots using maven,

Re: Car plugin is fighting with maven too much

2006-12-14 Thread Aaron Mulder
On 12/14/06, Guillaume Nodet [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Just a side note. It took me some time to understand that you *have* to build Geronimo if you want to build a plugin against a SNAPSHOT version. The reason is that the plugin loads cars that depend on snapshot jars (it works against the new

Re: Car plugin is fighting with maven too much

2006-12-14 Thread David Jencks
On Dec 14, 2006, at 2:02 PM, Aaron Mulder wrote: I just want to add that for Geronimo plugins, it's not very useful to have the car-maven-plugin write the environment into the deployment plan. More often that not, you want the source tree to contain a fully valid and correct deployment plan,

Re: Car plugin is fighting with maven too much

2006-12-14 Thread jason . dillon
To:Geronimo Dev List (JIRA) dev@geronimo.apache.org Subject: Car plugin is fighting with maven too much Ever since we got close to having an m2 build we've been having problems with the car plugin overloading the maven scopes to mean something in geronimo. This has caused endless problems, the latest