Re: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond

2005-09-06 Thread David Jencks
On Sep 5, 2005, at 9:38 PM, Jeff Genender wrote: I like what you have done here. Very nice work. thanks :-) However, IMHO, I would be concerned in the long run of shipping Jetty and Tomcat together. We will be accused of being too heavy weight. Then also, where do we draw the line of

Re: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond

2005-09-06 Thread Jacek Laskowski
David Jencks wrote: ... I wrote a namespace-driven switching module builder to determine if the jetty or tomcat builder is used. It has a defaultNamespace option which is what currently determines the target. The module builders register themselves with the switch and supply their

Re: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond

2005-09-06 Thread Joe Bohn
I too am confused about the use case scenario that would drive this? Also, can we be more specific on the level of granularity that is being considered here? Would it be just: 1 tomcat container, 1 jetty container, both a single tomcat and a single jetty container? Or is it also being

RE: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond

2005-09-06 Thread Jeff Genender
-Original Message- From: Joe Bohn [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2005 7:27 AM To: dev@geronimo.apache.org Subject: Re: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond I too am confused about the use case scenario that would drive this? Also

RE: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond

2005-09-06 Thread Jeff Genender
-Original Message- From: Jacek Laskowski [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2005 4:36 AM To: dev@geronimo.apache.org Subject: Re: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond Hi Dave, Both, by default? Interesting. Will there be a way in your

Re: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond

2005-09-06 Thread Geir Magnusson Jr.
On Sep 6, 2005, at 12:38 AM, Jeff Genender wrote: I like what you have done here. Very nice work. However, IMHO, I would be concerned in the long run of shipping Jetty and Tomcat together. We will be accused of being too heavy weight. Then also, where do we draw the line of shipping

Re: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond

2005-09-06 Thread Jeff Genender
Geir Magnusson Jr. wrote: On Sep 6, 2005, at 12:38 AM, Jeff Genender wrote: I like what you have done here. Very nice work. However, IMHO, I would be concerned in the long run of shipping Jetty and Tomcat together. We will be accused of being too heavy weight. Then also, where do we

How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond

2005-09-05 Thread David Jencks
As part of my work on breaking up our monolithic configuration into smaller pieces, I now have a set of configurations that modularize jetty and tomcat into two configurations each. These can be turned on and off individually, by means of starting with different config.list files or by an

Re: How do we ship jetty and tomcat versions? Please respond

2005-09-05 Thread Jeremy Boynes
Jeff Genender wrote: I like what you have done here. Very nice work. However, IMHO, I would be concerned in the long run of shipping Jetty and Tomcat together. We will be accused of being too heavy weight. Then also, where do we draw the line of shipping everything (ie. multiple orbs, and