Re: [PROPOSAL] Apache KIE Default Guidelines

Hello, Not late. I will keep this open for a while before a vote. The default Apache Guideline has even the code change as a Lazy Consensus vote. Default Project Guidelines - INCUBATOR - Apache Software Foundation

Re: [PROPOSAL] Apache KIE Default Guidelines

Thank you for the feedback. Removing and adding repositories might be something we need to vote separately. One option is that we make that a PMC level vote, instead of Committer level. Happy to hear feedback on this. My worry is that we even at this point have repositories that do not see update

Re: [PROPOSAL] Apache KIE Default Guidelines

Hi, In general, I think removing stuff requires consensus (basically because, as common sense dictates, it affects functionality that is already there). For example, we currently have consensus to remove/deprecate Infinispan support (we disagree on the details, but we are certainly getting rid of I

Re: [PROPOSAL] Apache KIE Default Guidelines

Hi Tony, first of all, many thanks for all your efforts and dedication! I'm late on the discussion, but reading the RTC table, IIUC, it seems that for -> A decision on a specific proposal to alter KIE in a significant way. > Includes adding or removing code bases and repositories. > only Majority

Re: [PROPOSAL] Apache KIE Default Guidelines

Good point. I changed "Who can vote" to "Who has binding vote" to clarify. The goal is to give the community more power on community actions, but also you can vote even if your vote is not binding. Non-binding votes are allowed to signal wans, needs and intentions. Toni On Wed, Apr 2, 2025 at 5:3

Re: [PROPOSAL] Apache KIE Default Guidelines

Thank you, Toni! The KIE version guidelines introduce good clarifications to the default one. One question: Is "binding" defined? A) Always only PMC members have binding votes. (like https://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html#binding-votes) or B) "Who can vote" in the table have binding vo

[PROPOSAL] Apache KIE Default Guidelines

Hello, Based on comments from our mentor I am redoing the ByLaws proposal as this Guidelines proposal. The back story is in the wiki page comments. Link to what the proposed wiki page would look like: https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/KIE/%5BPROPOSAL%5D+Basic+Apache+KIE+Guidelines T