Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-19 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
I don't have a new complete list, but I did manage to bend JIRA into the shape to give the numbers on usage, broken down by component and status. It is a "two-dimensional filter statistics" dashboard, for anybody interested. Unfortunately, I don't think anybody else can see my dashboard, so I

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Jan Høydahl
We could start by narrowing the admin group to equal the PMC group and then educate ourselves about when (not) to create new components or releases. Then if someone need admin rights (I could imagine e.g. Release Managers) we could tackle it as we go. Next, someone suggests a complete revised

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
I thought I had a memory of being able to add a component before I got committer access. But perhaps it would have been rejected when I clicked submit. Or my memory is faulty. Either way, that was the reason I thought maybe some permission got perhaps assigned to 'Registered' users. I am happy to

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Cassandra Targett
On Thu, Feb 16, 2017 at 10:17 AM, Alexandre Rafalovitch wrote: > Are we SURE that the role has not been relaxed by INFRA? Because if it > is just us, we could do a one-time cleanup and try to be neat. Relaxed in what way? That all users have project admin-level permissions?

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
Are we SURE that the role has not been relaxed by INFRA? Because if it is just us, we could do a one-time cleanup and try to be neat. Could potentially also have a weekly alert for any component count less than 3 or some such. Assuming JIRA metadata could be pulled into facet-style info.

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Jan Høydahl
Hmm, we’re not the only one having the challenge https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/JRA-42068 However, it’s only Project Admins who can create new components on the fly: Adrien GrandAlan WoodwardAlexandre RafalovitchAndi VajdaAndrzej BialeckiAnshum

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Jan Høydahl
Done. You are right that there are quite some overlap, we have “security” vs “Authentication” mm. The problem is that anyone can create new components just by typing some string in the field and selecting “new”. Could we disable that feature? I could not see how. -- Jan Høydahl, search

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
+1 (there might even be more than 2) +5 (if I had it) on general review of the component names, possibly with a page in a guide or JIRA somewhere to explain how to pick them. I think there are misspellings, synonyms and the other usual search problems. Regards, Alex.

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Stefan Matheis
+1 -Stefan On Feb 16, 2017 1:34 PM, "Jan Høydahl" wrote: > We have two components for the same thing: "web gui" (55 issues) and UI > (22 issues). > We should merge them to one. Suggest we also rename it to “Admin UI” which > is the most > common term used. > > -- > Jan

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Adrien Grand
+1 Le jeu. 16 févr. 2017 à 15:28, David Smiley a écrit : > +1 > On Thu, Feb 16, 2017 at 4:34 AM Jan Høydahl wrote: > > We have two components for the same thing: "web gui" (55 issues) and UI > (22 issues). > We should merge them to one. Suggest we

Re: Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread David Smiley
+1 On Thu, Feb 16, 2017 at 4:34 AM Jan Høydahl wrote: > We have two components for the same thing: "web gui" (55 issues) and UI > (22 issues). > We should merge them to one. Suggest we also rename it to “Admin UI” which > is the most > common term used. > > -- > Jan Høydahl >

Solr JIRA: Merge components "web gui" and "UI"

2017-02-16 Thread Jan Høydahl
We have two components for the same thing: "web gui" (55 issues) and UI (22 issues). We should merge them to one. Suggest we also rename it to “Admin UI” which is the most common term used. -- Jan Høydahl Search Solution architect Cominvent AS www.cominvent.com +47 90125809