Re: LabelBot New Design in Production

2018-11-17 Thread Steffen Rochel
+1 for the proposal Thanks Harsh for your initiative to improve the productivity of the community. I agree with Sheng that care needs to be taken using the proposed label appropriately. Having a committer to actually close the issue is therefor a good gate. However, I'm in favor of such label an

Re: LabelBot New Design in Production

2018-11-16 Thread sandeep krishnamurthy
I believe having this label - [suggest-closed] is helpful. 1. Adding this label is not an automated bot script that marks stale issues. A bot script would definitely be unwelcoming and also miss major issues just because it is stale. 2. This label is simply a way to identify issues that can be clo

Re: LabelBot New Design in Production

2018-11-16 Thread Sheng Zha
Thanks, Harsh. I saw that this was created and used on several issues and I removed it for now because: - the issues that they are used on issues that don't seem to be resolved. - it leaves the impression to the requesters that people think their issues are not worth people's attention in this co

Re: LabelBot New Design in Production

2018-11-16 Thread Harsh Patel
Hey all, To help with how we handle issues for MXNet, I am proposing a new label be created called: [suggest-closed]. I, alongside many others, observe many stale issues which can be candidates for closure and searching for these of the 800+ issues we have is a daunting task. This label is meant to

Re: LabelBot New Design in Production

2018-11-08 Thread Hagay Lupesko
Thanks for this useful contribution Harsh! +1 to an updated issue template and +1 to Marco's idea as well Anything that helps the community triage and make it easier for folks that file issues is greatly appreciated Hagay On Thu, Nov 8, 2018 at 4:05 PM Marco de Abreu wrote: > Great job, Harsh!

Re: LabelBot New Design in Production

2018-11-08 Thread Marco de Abreu
Great job, Harsh! That's a very good idea, Naveen. Harsh, Qing and I have been thinking about the bot "welcoming" the user when they create an issue or pull request by creating a comment as soon as the thread gets created. This message could contain basic instructions like these commands, recommen

Re: LabelBot New Design in Production

2018-11-08 Thread Naveen Swamy
Great job!, this is very helpful to triage issues!, users when creating a new Issue could themselves tag the issues. May be we should add that to the issue template? On Thu, Nov 8, 2018 at 3:54 PM Harsh Patel wrote: > Hey all, > The upgraded label bot has been pushed into production. Current > f

LabelBot New Design in Production

2018-11-08 Thread Harsh Patel
Hey all, The upgraded label bot has been pushed into production. Current functionality includes add, delete, and update. (i.e. @mxnet-label-bot add ['label'] @mxnet-label-bot remove ['label'] @mxnet-label-bot update ['label']) Users should feel free to leave suggestions and any potential issues. T