RE: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-31 Thread Dennis E. Hamilton
[mailto:orc...@apache.org] Sent: Monday, August 31, 2015 10:58 To: dev@openoffice.apache.org Subject: RE: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...) Thanks, Andrea. I see what is questioned about that page. This folder also appears on the AOO410 branch and I assume i

RE: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-31 Thread Dennis E. Hamilton
ennis -Original Message- From: Andrea Pescetti [mailto:pesce...@apache.org] Sent: Monday, August 31, 2015 09:28 To: dev@openoffice.apache.org Subject: Re: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...) Dennis E. Hamilton wrote: > I cannot find direct

Re: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-31 Thread Andrea Pescetti
Dennis E. Hamilton wrote: I cannot find directory main/ooo_custom_images on https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/openoffice/trunk/main and there is nothing similar on the web site. It's there at https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/openoffice/trunk/main/ooo_custom_images/industrial/README and (nicer) h

RE: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-31 Thread Dennis E. Hamilton
...@apache.org] Sent: Monday, August 31, 2015 07:16 To: orc...@apache.org; Apache OO Subject: Re: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...) Hi again Dennis; I stopped using AOO's bugzilla after an unconfortable incident. Since the PMC was notified twice about

Re: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-31 Thread Pedro Giffuni
Hi again Dennis; I stopped using AOO's bugzilla after an unconfortable incident. Since the PMC was notified twice about it, I will just make it public. You should take a look at: main/ooo_custom_images/industrial/README Pedro. On 30/08/2015 10:57 p.m., Pedro Giffuni wrote: Hi Dennis; I find

RE: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-30 Thread Dennis E. Hamilton
ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...) [ ... ] Considering your personal remark are you referring to clause 4 (a) and (d)? IANAL and that's someone else's job at the ASF, but I didn't find those in the root tree of a certain third party, which is where I wou

Re: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-30 Thread Pedro Giffuni
Hi Dennis; I find your posting somewhat confusing as the topic would indicate something different from the body of the message. I agree in observation 5 that the ASF (actually I can only speak partially for AOO) does *not* police the use of ALv2 content by third parties. This, of course, doesn

RE: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-30 Thread Dennis E. Hamilton
st 30, 2015 12:41 To: dev@openoffice.apache.org Subject: Re: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...) I appreciate all your diligence about licenses. It is valuable. Whatever you want to call this thread ... One intention was to discuss what if anything is

Re: Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-30 Thread Dave Fisher
I appreciate all your diligence about licenses. It is valuable. Whatever you want to call this thread ... One intention was to discuss what if anything is required with respect to trademarks when ANY third party product is (re)based on Apache OpenOffice. For example it cannot be called OpenOffi

Third-Party ALv2 Dependencies (RE: Limiting Trademark Policy Discussion ...)

2015-08-30 Thread Dennis E. Hamilton
>From the Chair, I need to speak up about the "rebasing" business. 1. Use of the ALv2 has nothing to do with trademarks, so this conversation should be on a separate thread. 2. However, it probably should not be held here and certainly not privately by the PMC. If someone wants to pursue