Re: Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

Sergio, Thanks for your answer. On Fri, Aug 11, 2017 at 11:33 AM Sergio Fernández wrote: > Doyung, release candidate would need to get at least 3 binding votes. If > you don't get them from dev@s2graph, you would need to go to > general@incubator. Mentors or not, every IPMC

Re: Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

Doyung, release candidate would need to get at least 3 binding votes. If you don't get them from dev@s2graph, you would need to go to general@incubator. Mentors or not, every IPMC member counts here. On Thu, Aug 10, 2017 at 8:08 AM, DO YUNG YOON wrote: > Hi John. > > I was

Re: Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

Apologize for not being able to be around much lately. I'm moving to work to another continent, so last weeks have been very difficult for me. Thanks Andrew for signing the report. On Thu, Aug 10, 2017 at 8:51 PM, Andrew Purtell wrote: > Yes, s2graph is very stable. I

Re: Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

Thanks Andrew. Just wondering, is S2Graph stable enough to graduate? John On 2017-08-10 13:53, Andrew Purtell wrote: > I signed off with the comment > > "We need to find more mentors for this podling. In the past > Sergio was helpful but he hasn't been around

Re: Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

Thank you for signing off Andrew. On Fri, Aug 11, 2017 at 2:54 AM Andrew Purtell wrote: > I signed off with the comment > > "We need to find more mentors for this podling. In the past > Sergio was helpful but he hasn't been around much recently. I would >

Re: Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

I signed off with the comment "We need to find more mentors for this podling. In the past Sergio was helpful but he hasn't been around much recently. I would resign but am lurking as mentor of last resort." and removed s2graph from the list of podlings missing signoff. (This

Re: Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

Correct me if I am wrong John but I don't think you need a mentor to vote on a release candidate. Once the PPMC has concluded voting on the RC, you submit it to the IPMC per the normal process and once there are sufficient binding votes there the RC becomes a release. On Wed, Aug 9, 2017 at

Re: Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

I can sign off this time. Normally I would have resigned by now but am lurking enough to be a last resort. Thanks for bringing this to my attention. We should find more mentors for S2Graph. The current situation is quite unfair to them. On Wed, Aug 9, 2017 at 6:58 PM, John D. Ament

Re: Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

Hi John. I was wondering what podlings supposed to do if we failed to get sign off from our mentors. Also we opened up vote for new release candidates( http://markmail.org/message/i7ix3rqk7ishp4r3) and we still need binding vote from our mentors. I am also wondering what RM should do to proceed

Need mentor sign off on the S2Graph report

All, Just a reminder, we need at least one mentor to sign off on the S2 Graph report. If no one can get to it in the next 24 hours I'll need to move the podling to monthly and expect a report next month. John