Re: Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread Musachy Barroso
Don, did you see an email about a NPE in showcase when running from trunk? I'm having the same problem on my current project so I had to switch svn rv to before your commit :) regards musachy On 9/24/07, Don Brown <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I'd also recommend 2.1, but if it turns out to be a s

Re: Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread Don Brown
I'd also recommend 2.1, but if it turns out to be a small change, backporting it might be nice to get it out quicker. As for the state of 2.1, my EL, conversion API, and static refactories are done, tests pass, but I wouldn't be surprised if there aren't runtime issues at this stage. The other big

Re: Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread James Holmes
There will likely be a Struts 2.0.12 release from the Struts 2_0_X branch. Ted is also planning to do a Struts 2.1 beta release this month I believe, but it's anybody's guess as to when 2.1 might go GA. 2.1 is probably the best place since that is where Don is working on the underlying changes

Re: Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread Matt Raible
OK - so I guess the question is, what version should I try to fix things in? XWork 2.0.4 or the latest XWork trunk? I'd like to fix this and be able to use it in the next month or two, so what will the next release of Struts require? Thanks, Matt On 9/24/07, James Holmes <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wro

Re: Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread James Holmes
I'm not sure if Don is planning to change the EL mechanism or just *make it possible" to change the mechanism. On Mon Sep 24 16:42 , 'Matt Raible' <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> sent: >Is it worth trying to fix this issue (non-existent properties not >reported) if the underlying EL mechanism is going to c

Re: Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread Matt Raible
Is it worth trying to fix this issue (non-existent properties not reported) if the underlying EL mechanism is going to change? I guess the best thing to do is see if I can reproduce the problem using xwork/struts-trunk. Matt On 9/24/07, Dave Newton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > --- Matt Raible <[

Re: Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread Dave Newton
--- Matt Raible <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > OK, so if I'm mostly concerned with the Struts 2.0.x > branches, is there a revision of XWork I can/should > work with? XWork revved with most of the S2 revs; S2 2.0.6/XW 2.0.1, S2 2.0.8/XW 2.0.3, etc. Maybe start from the higher revs and see if it can

Re: Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread Matt Raible
OK, so if I'm mostly concerned with the Struts 2.0.x branches, is there a revision of XWork I can/should work with? Thanks, Matt On 9/24/07, Piero Sartini <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Should I be using the latest version of Struts with the latest version > > of XWork to attempt to fix this iss

Re: Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread Piero Sartini
> Should I be using the latest version of Struts with the latest version > of XWork to attempt to fix this issue? As far as I know, xwork 2.1 does work with struts 2.1 only. But - and that is the bad news: I was not able to get 2.1 running (maybe trunk is broken?) See the thread "NPE on struts2-

Fixing XW-559: No warnings when property or method doesn't exist in Action

2007-09-24 Thread Matt Raible
Background at: http://jira.opensymphony.com/browse/XW-559 Basically, Struts 2 sucks. ;-) When prototyping a project with Struts 2, I found it annoying that when I fat-fingered a property or method in my JSP, I was never given an error by Struts. For people that are brand-new to Struts, I'd imagin