Re: TomEE MicroProfile and Jakarta

2022-04-01 Thread Romain Manni-Bucau
The risk for TomEE (IMHO indeed) is that, using smallrye, you break the core value "apache" or at least "owned by apache" and break the other core value "lightweight" since it comes with a tons of uneeded stuff and implementation is not even JAXRS friendly (it breaks literally jaxrs and cdi at

Re: TomEE MicroProfile and Jakarta

2022-04-01 Thread Zowalla, Richard
So we basically have to options (if I understand the discussion correctly): (A) Put some effort / resources into upgrade our MP impls to the latest versions to fully support Jakarta namespace. From my understanding maintaining these impls is a bit PITA as MP tends to break its API every few

Re: TomEE MicroProfile and Jakarta

2022-04-01 Thread David Blevins
This is very close. The dangers of A are not quite captured. Completely agree with the dangers of B. > On Apr 1, 2022, at 1:13 AM, Zowalla, Richard > wrote: > > So we basically have to options (if I understand the discussion > correctly): > > (A) Put some effort / resources into upgrade