[IxDA Discuss] What makes a great question (or what doesn't)?

2010-01-10 Thread Arthur Fink
Our outward product may be an information architecture, a web site structure, a user interface for a program. But the generative process is one of asking questions. I think of observing user behavior as another kind of questioning, asking and receiving with non-verbal language. These

[IxDA Discuss] A quick survey on reactions to visual design.

2010-01-10 Thread Eric Reiss
Friends (with many apologies for cross-posting), I have a theory I'd like you to help me prove or disprove. If you have five minutes (in all - tops) and are involved in both: - presenting proposed visual web designs to clients - observing user testing of these designs

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Thought experiment: Law against usability that's TOO good?

2010-01-10 Thread James Page
Christine, You make an intresting point. Some academic claim that Usability is not Science but instead an ethic. See Paul Cairns Harold Thimbleby 2008 http://en.scientificcommons.org/42316368 I am not fully convinced of this but I think it is an intresting argument. If Usability is an Ethic

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Arriving late in the game

2010-01-10 Thread Alan Wexelblat
On Fri, Jan 8, 2010 at 1:50 PM, Jonathan Abbett jonat...@abbett.org wrote: Say you're brought in to do user research and feature definition for a software project that's already underway (i.e. development began on day one). You have your tried-and-true process where you interview users long

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Thought experiment: Law against usability that's TOO good?

2010-01-10 Thread j. eric townsend
R. Groot wrote: Companies like Google and Apple have gotten so skilled in getting it right, in having such an outstanding user experience, that we are drawn to their products like months to a flame. They're also skilled in buying companies who got it right and burying it when they get it

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Arriving late in the game

2010-01-10 Thread Jonathan Abbett
- Something wholly new. - The dev team understands that their current UI may change radically. - We're working for a group of academic research institutes. This is their first project together. Our normal approach is a wide one -- looking at the greater context around the client's perceived

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Thought experiment: Law against usability that's TOO good?

2010-01-10 Thread Jaanus Kase
Christine, I agree with what you say and I did not think that aspect through enough when posting. I subscribe to everything that you say; additionally, I like the research that says that our language affects our thinking, and that it has been proven that the thought patterns of different

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Thought experiment: Law against usability that's TOO good?

2010-01-10 Thread Christine Boese
I had a feeling we were both honing in on the same goals, Jaanus, and weren't really too far off. I'm just sensitive to the neutral tool argument because at one time I tried to hold to that reasoning, and was shown how it didn't hold up. But we hold the same values, and I really like that we're

Re: [IxDA Discuss] User cookie authentication vs. Security

2010-01-10 Thread Sean Gerety
One of the things that we did on a recent project is to provide a message that their session is about to expire and a button for them to click to extend the session. Should they go beyond the allotted time for the session, we show a message that asks for their password and we return them to where