PPIG discuss: A different story about how some software got written

2007-10-01 Thread Ruven E Brooks
The following is a true story. I haven't even bothered to change any of the details. 1. The developers were really enthusiastic about .NET technology but they couldn't persuade management to re-write any of the existing products using it. 2. The developers went off and put together a

Re: PPIG discuss: A different story about how some software got written

2007-10-01 Thread Alan Blackwell
Sadly, my professional experience included more projects like Ruven's than like Frank's. This encompasses one generously funded startup, and another high-cost internal development. I've always remembered this succinct comment from a prospective customer: Customer: This system doesn't provide

Re: PPIG discuss: A different story about how some software got written

2007-10-01 Thread Clendon Gibson
While Ruven's story is absolutely relevant, I think the comparison is being made between apples and oranges. The first example, which did not concern itself too much with documentation or test cases, was not a commercial product. It had only to satisfy the community of amateurs that where

Re: PPIG discuss: A different story about how some software got written

2007-10-01 Thread Alan Blackwell
[EMAIL PROTECTED] said: (Volunteer vs. paid labor. Free product vs. for pay. Volunteer Programmer driven vs. Corporate/Market driven.) Toys for programmers vs. useful solutions for everyone else? :-) Alan -- Alan Blackwell Computer Laboratory, University of Cambridge