Re: Invalid forms and cleaned_data

2007-12-03 Thread Gary Wilson
Malcolm Tredinnick wrote: > Anybody have strong objections to ticket #5524: not completely nuking > form.cleaned_data is a form instance has any non-zero validation errors? No objections here, seems like the Right Thing to do. My data was cleaned, keep it that way. Gary --~--~-~--~

Re: Invalid forms and cleaned_data

2007-12-03 Thread Adrian Holovaty
On Dec 3, 2007 2:47 PM, Malcolm Tredinnick <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Anybody have strong objections to ticket #5524: not completely nuking > form.cleaned_data is a form instance has any non-zero validation errors? No objections here -- it actually looks like it could be useful, even. :-) Adri

Re: Invalid forms and cleaned_data

2007-12-03 Thread James Bennett
On 12/3/07, Malcolm Tredinnick <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Anybody have strong objections to ticket #5524: not completely nuking > form.cleaned_data is a form instance has any non-zero validation errors? The only objection I'd have is that it would enable naive code to screw up by just looking a

Re: Invalid forms and cleaned_data

2007-12-03 Thread Russell Keith-Magee
On Dec 4, 2007 5:47 AM, Malcolm Tredinnick <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Adrian, Russell, Gary: > > Anybody have strong objections to ticket #5524: not completely nuking > form.cleaned_data is a form instance has any non-zero validation errors? > > I'm pretty much "don't care" and I gather Jacob

Invalid forms and cleaned_data

2007-12-03 Thread Malcolm Tredinnick
Adrian, Russell, Gary: Anybody have strong objections to ticket #5524: not completely nuking form.cleaned_data is a form instance has any non-zero validation errors? I'm pretty much "don't care" and I gather Jacob is about the same, but it keeps cropping up in various disguises. For the record,