Re: Proposal: remove compatibility for old signing functions

2011-03-28 Thread Paul McMillan
I agree with the others. This is very much the correct step going forward. These fallback methods have worried me, and definitely weaken the security of the improvements. One idea I had been kicking around was some way to tell Django what version of these things to expect, and disable the fallback

Re: Proposal: remove compatibility for old signing functions

2011-03-28 Thread Gabriel Hurley
+1, this seemed kludgy to me and had potential insecurities as it was. You're only as strong as your weakest link, right? All the best, - Gabriel -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Django developers" group. To post to this group, send email to dj

Re: Proposal: remove compatibility for old signing functions

2011-03-28 Thread Jacob Kaplan-Moss
On Mon, Mar 28, 2011 at 4:19 PM, Luke Plant wrote: > Proposal: remove compatibility fallbacks for short-lifetime signed data > (shortening the deprecation process). Sounds perfectly fine to me. Skipping versions is generally a dicey idea anyway, so recommending a brief stop in 1.3 for people goin

Proposal: remove compatibility for old signing functions

2011-03-28 Thread Luke Plant
Proposal: remove compatibility fallbacks for short-lifetime signed data (shortening the deprecation process). = Explanation = In 1.3, various bits of code were updated to use a better system for signing using the SECRET_KEY. However, for compatibility with existing data, the old methods were left