Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-07-03 Thread Gordon
> > If we did split it out, would you be interested in being a maintainer? > > I was against this at first but the more I've thought about it, I would be interested. Has anyone else expressed any interest or will I be the only maintainer? I have another project coming up that will most likely

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-06-03 Thread Jannis Leidel
On 03.06.2014, at 14:53, Josh Smeaton wrote: > If formtools were to be pulled out and released separately, would that > theoretically mean that releases could come more frequently than django core > (provided there was community interest and maintenance)? I think that would > be a decent carro

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-06-03 Thread Josh Smeaton
If formtools were to be pulled out and released separately, would that theoretically mean that releases could come more frequently than django core (provided there was community interest and maintenance)? I think that would be a decent carrot for community members that rely on its functionality

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-06-03 Thread Marc Tamlyn
In my opinion, the reasoning for whether something should be a part of contrib is as follows: - The application is of vital importance to the vast majority of Django sites, and needs to be done "correctly". Examples include auth and staticfiles, sessions. - The application closely depends on inter

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-06-03 Thread Jannis Leidel
Hi all, I’ve actually changed my mind about this after we successfully pulled out django-localflavor (another niche contrib app) after some initial bumps. It’s now maintained under the Django umbrella org on Github: https://github.com/django/django-localflavor/ I would like to propose to do th

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-06-02 Thread Tim Graham
contrib.databrowse is an example of something that was removed from Django. It seems to have found a home here: https://pypi.python.org/pypi/django-databrowse Deprecation of contrib.formtools was actually proposed on the mailing list in 2011, see https://groups.google.com/d/topic/django-develo

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-06-02 Thread Thomas Leo
The company I'm currently contracting for, makes heavy use of formtools, I'd be disappointed to see it go. On Monday, May 26, 2014 6:04:31 PM UTC-4, Tim Graham wrote: > > My observation is that not many core developers seem interested in > contrib.formtools these days. It was added by Adrian in

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-06-02 Thread Gordon
How would that work? Being part of contrib is a big plus for the app in many ways. I am not familiar with another app that was removed from contrib that would show an overview of the process and if it was successful. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-05-26 Thread Tim Graham
If we did split it out, would you be interested in being a maintainer? On Monday, May 26, 2014 6:51:13 PM UTC-4, Gordon wrote: > > > > On Monday, May 26, 2014 6:04:31 PM UTC-4, Tim Graham wrote: >> >> My observation is that not many core developers seem interested in >> contrib.formtools these da

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-05-26 Thread Gordon
On Monday, May 26, 2014 6:04:31 PM UTC-4, Tim Graham wrote: > > My observation is that not many core developers seem interested in > contrib.formtools these days. It was added by Adrian in 2006, but as far as > I can see from the commit history, it hasn't received much love lately. If > would

Re: FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-05-26 Thread Tim Graham
My observation is that not many core developers seem interested in contrib.formtools these days. It was added by Adrian in 2006, but as far as I can see from the commit history, it hasn't received much love lately. If would be a good candidate for deprecation from Django itself, in my opinion.

FormWizard needs confirmation step logic. ticket #21644

2014-05-26 Thread Gordon
Hello, I have posted an implementation/proof of concept to ticket 21644 (https://code.djangoproject.com/ticket/21644). The implementation is currently written as a mixin because I need to be able to use it now and I don't like maintaining a custom fork of django for my projects. If changed t