Re: [DNSOP] [Ext] no regitry for you, Possible alt-tld last call?

2022-10-23 Thread David Conrad
Suzanne, On Oct 23, 2022, at 3:50 AM, Suzanne Woolf wrote: > We've been told repeatedly that no one wants to engage legal analysis or > liaison communications on a document that doesn't have WG consensus. This appears broken. In this specific case, the way forward appears to be predicated on

Re: [DNSOP] [Ext] no regitry for you, Possible alt-tld last call?

2022-10-23 Thread Paul Vixie
Martin Schanzenbach wrote on 2022-10-23 04:38: On 23.10.22 10:50, Suzanne Woolf wrote: ... The chairs would like to hear it if anyone has anything new to say about such a registry on its technical merits, including specific registry policy and operational challenges with administering it

Re: [DNSOP] [Ext] no regitry for you, Possible alt-tld last call?

2022-10-23 Thread Martin Schanzenbach
On 23.10.22 10:50, Suzanne Woolf wrote: > Eliot, > > On Oct 23, 2022, at 2:15 AM, Eliot Lear mailto:l...@lear.ch>> > wrote: > > > On 23.10.22 05:40, John Levine wrote: > It appears that Eliot Lear mailto:l...@lear.ch>> said: > As a matter of practicality, a registry surely will be form. It

Re: [DNSOP] [Ext] no regitry for you, Possible alt-tld last call?

2022-10-23 Thread Suzanne Woolf
Eliot, On Oct 23, 2022, at 2:15 AM, Eliot Lear mailto:l...@lear.ch>> wrote: On 23.10.22 05:40, John Levine wrote: It appears that Eliot Lear mailto:l...@lear.ch>> said: As a matter of practicality, a registry surely will be form. It is simply a matter of whether the IANA will host it. If

Re: [DNSOP] [Ext] no regitry for you, Possible alt-tld last call?

2022-10-23 Thread Eliot Lear
On 23.10.22 05:40, John Levine wrote: It appears that Eliot Lear said: As a matter of practicality, a registry surely will be form.  It is simply a matter of whether the IANA will host it.  If the IANA does not host it, then by shifting it elsewhere this group is actually weakening the IANA

Re: [DNSOP] [Ext] no regitry for you, Possible alt-tld last call?

2022-10-22 Thread John Levine
It appears that Eliot Lear said: >As a matter of practicality, a registry surely will be form.  It is >simply a matter of whether the IANA will host it.  If the IANA does not >host it, then by shifting it elsewhere this group is actually weakening >the IANA function, and that would be sad.