Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy?

2012-04-05 Thread David Christ
I was once involved in durable goods retailing -- mid to high end bicycles in this case. It was not uncommon for customers to get hung up between the bicycle they wanted to buy and the bicycle they thought they "should" buy. This was usually triggered by price. I told them that unless spen

Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy?

2012-04-05 Thread Jim Lowman
True, when I decided on the Eagle over the K3, I added the price of similar accessories that I would want to each radio to determine total cost. The K3 came out slightly more expensive, but most of the difference was the sales tax on the Elecraft. BTW, I'm ordering a K3 as we speak! The thing

[Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy?

2012-04-05 Thread Dyarnes
Hi All, This seems to come up a lot, and I always have to wonder how such a question can be effectively answered, at least convincingly. The problem is that everyone has different wants and needs. Also, just about every radio out there is significantly different in various ways, whether it's

[Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy - BUT somewhat off topic

2012-04-05 Thread Adrian
Nice example here; vk4tux -Original Message- From: elecraft-boun...@mailman.qth.net [mailto:elecraft-boun...@mailman.qth.net] On Behalf Of Tony Estep Sent: Thursday, 5 April 2012 1:26 PM To: Elecraft Reflector Subject: Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy - BUT somewhat off topic

Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy - BUT somewhat off topic

2012-04-04 Thread Tony Estep
On Wed, Apr 4, 2012 at 10:41 PM, Don Wilhelm wrote: > If you are able to achieve a linear 1 dial division equals 1 kHz > calibration for that dial, please let me know what capacitor you used... === Naw, that's not what I meant. I just loved the cool way the dial itself worked an

Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy - BUT somewhat off topic

2012-04-04 Thread Don Wilhelm
Tony, If you are able to achieve a linear 1 dial division equals 1 kHz calibration for that dial, please let me know what capacitor you used and other parameters involved - I have two of those National Dials in the jumkbox/ It is typical that dial could be read in 1 kHz increments given that

Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy - BUT somewhat off topic

2012-04-04 Thread Tony Estep
On Wed, Apr 4, 2012 at 9:49 PM, Ron D'Eau Claire wrote: > My first "world class" receiver was a National HRO5TA1 from the early > 1940's. === The HRO receivers had that fantastic dial with the planetary vernier gizmo inside and the numbers peeking through the holes -- to me, that was

Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy - BUT somewhat off topic

2012-04-04 Thread Ron D'Eau Claire
My first "world class" receiver was a National HRO5TA1 from the early 1940's. It came to me via another Ham in the mid 50's. By the mid 1960's the HRO was in need of some work. In those days resistors drifted, capacitors leaked and tubes grew weak and gassy. But I had no manual. So I wrote the Nati

Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy - BUT somewhat off topic

2012-04-04 Thread Brian Denley
B1VBF http://home.comcast.net/~b.denley/index.html - Original Message - From: "Don Wilhelm" To: Sent: Wednesday, April 04, 2012 8:34 PM Subject: Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy? > Dave, > > I have to agree. My rig prior to the K2 was a Yaesu FT-900AT. I th

Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy?

2012-04-04 Thread Don Wilhelm
Dave, I have to agree. My rig prior to the K2 was a Yaesu FT-900AT. I think that rig is one of Yaesu's best kept secrets - good performance in a 100 watt class transmitter and good receive performance. Removable front panel - but the buttons and knobs were quite close together. When I bui

Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy?

2012-04-04 Thread David Gilbert
I have to fully agree on both points. When I bought my K3 I kept hearing all the comments about the density of the knobs on the front panel, so I actually did a comparison to my old 756Pro. I measured the area of each front panel and divided by the number of knobs and buttons. Guess what ...

Re: [Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy?

2012-04-04 Thread Nate Bargmann
My hands are not small and the K3 has plenty of spacing between its buttions and knobs that inadvertent contact is due to my sloppy reach rather than an issue with the K3. Like any other radio it does take some time to learn well. The menus are for configuration and once you have it working as yo

[Elecraft] Which ONE rig would I buy?

2012-04-04 Thread David Perrin
Hi Bob- That is a dilemma for sure. I enjoy building and assembling as much as operating so the K3, P3 and KPA500 and K2/100 are all contenders. Too many controls and many menus are a hassle so the K3 lessens its appeal to me. The ORION II is the perfect size, I can actually can get my fingers